Reply #67: I think a step back (a broader perspective) would help. [View All]

[MercutioATC]

First, we are not creating anything. The parents are.

Second, the status of those children is unchanged. If we don't allow them to become "anchor babies", they'll travel back to Mexico (or wherever) with their deported parents and will essentially have the same life they would have if their parents had never illegally entered the U.S.

Collaterally, what message does successfully breaking the law for personal gain send to the child? That child would always be able to legitimately apply for U.S. citizenship in the future...what lesson is taught by showing them that they can benefit by ignoring laws?

I do see where you're coming from and I'm sympathetic. However, I don't believe that gifting a child with U.S. citizenship justifies breaking an important (and practical) principle.