Reply #40: what is incurious about Realityhack's response? [View All]

[OnTheOtherHand]

I'm trying to understand this. How could Rh revise it to make it more curious?

I also don't understand how geometry enters into your question. If you have evidence of debris being ejected sideways at a time when no known force could account for that, then you wouldn't need geometry to infer the existence of an unknown force. But when would that be?

So far, my honest impression is that you have either a radically intractable math problem, or no math problem at all.

ETA: The more of this I read, the more perplexed I get. It seems like you asked, Is this possible? JBerryhill said, No. You said, Well, I think it is straightforward. JBerryhill said, If you think it is straightforward, why haven't you done it? And you got upset about his emotional attack and how you admit that you're no engineer. And so on. Basically it seems that you just don't like the answer you got.