|
Edited on Thu May-31-07 02:22 AM by Peace Patriot
Chavez government and on the left. I've been watching the rightwing opposition in Venezuela quite closely. For the most part, they have acted extremely foolishly--or some of them have--for instance, supporting a violent coup attempt, boycotting the last by-elections (what a totally stupid move), accepting money from the Bush government (our money!) in violation of Venezuelan law, and crying "stolen election!" every time Chavez and his supporters win. Venezuelan elections are the most highly monitored elections on earth, and have been unanimously declared open and aboveboard by the Carter Center, the OAS and EU election monitoring groups. They use electronic voting, but it is an OPEN SOURCE CODE system (unlike our own)--anyone may review the programming code by which the votes are counted--and they furthermore handcount a whopping 55% of the ballots, as a check against machine fraud (know how much WE handcount? 0% to 1%!). So the opposition just made fools of themselves. I thought this was very unfortunate. A good, loyal, patriotic opposition is NEEDED in Venezuela. But the opposition just comes off as a bunch of rich spoiled brats, used to being handed power and wealth--and some of them most certainly are rightwing thugs and fascists, who don't care who or what they trample on to gain power.
That said, there is a legitimate CENTER in Venezuela (I really can't say that the rightwing is legitimate--they've been so bad, disruptive and in some cases lawless and violent). The center would align with the middle and upper-middle class business people, and some of the professionals, who may well have much to contribute to this effort of the Chavez government and the Venezuela people to achieve fairness and hope for the vast poor population, and to create a mixed socialist/capitalist economy. The Bolivarian notions of Latin American sovereignty, self-determination and regional cooperation are also no bad deal for the middle class, and for business people and professionals. In Argentina, for instance, the ravages of World Bank/IMF policy hurt EVERYBODY, and Argentina didn't recover until it paid off its World Bank debt with VENEZUELA's help--which has led to the creation of the Bank of the South, which promises to bail out Bolivia, Ecuador and Paraguay as well. These are very positive developments. They are creating a healthy business climate in the region.
Venezuela's centrists need to shed these crazy rightwing, Bushite-type leaders and troublemakers, and establish a more positive program. I noted that the opposition candidate for president in the last election, who lost badly, nevertheless had the grace and good sense to disavow yet another military coup plot, planned for just after the December election. That seemed to me to be the beginning of a more positive and patriotic opposition. There will inevitably be continued conflict in South America, between rich and poor, because there has been such enormous injustice, but these new, democratic, peaceful, leftist governments--throughout the region--provide hope for a PEACEFUL resolution of these conflicts. The moneyed class, the business people, the professionals and the middle class should be GRATEFUL that the poor of South America are not guillotining them--really, they have much cause--and instead want...schools, medical care, jobs, land for growing food... and a rightful say in their own fate. They want DEMOCRACY! They have been terribly neglected and shunted aside, and could not therefore contribute to creating general prosperity and a good society. Give them a chance, and they WILL. They are chafing at the bit to improve their lives. You should read the accounts of what adult literacy programs in Venezuela have meant to poor people. Remarkable transformations are occurring.
As Evo Morales--the first indigenous president of Bolivia--has said: "We want partners, not dictators." What a mild and beautiful statement, after all that the indigenous have suffered in Bolivia! Partners! A partnership with the have's.
I think there is much hope in South America---and Venezuela has been a major player in creating that hope. The rich, who have yearned to be dictators and overlords, need to give those kinds of goals up, and start cooperating with fairer, cleaner government. They are fools to fight it! A society in which everyone has a decent life, and hope, is better for everybody, not just for the poor. And the Bolivarians are creating that opportunity--the opportunity for a far better, safer, more self-directed and more satisfying life for everybody. How can you have self-respect when the U.S. State Department and its associated global corporate predators are pulling your strings? How can you love your country, and see its resources stolen--even if the foreign predators are wily enough to "trickle" some of that money to you and a few others? It is ultimately a rotten deal.
One more thought on the Venezuelan elite. They have struck me as awfully selfish. Our own rich elite, in the '50s and '60s anyway, valued education, a strong middle class and upward mobility for the poor. They have abandoned those values now, it seems--to the everlasting ruin of our nation. But Venezuela's upper class seems never to have tried , seems never to have felt any responsibility for their poor brethren, or for their society as a whole. They utterly neglected education, for instance. The illiteracy rate at the beginning of the Chavez government stood at 40%. The Chavez government has nearly eliminated illiteracy, through an intense program of adult and other education. Poor areas had no schools. The poor could not hope to go to college. Neither did they have access to medical care. These are grave neglects. The people who oppose Chavez need to THINK about these things. They need to become more responsible--rather than imitating this Bushite "dog eat dog" ethic.
So, yes, there is at least a POTENTIAL legitimate opposition in Venezuela. But they really need to work on creating some common ground and common principles. The rule of law. Constitutional government. For starters. A more just society. And their contribution could be significant on matters like regional trade--Mercosur (the new South American trade group)--on economic development, and on balancing business and trade with the requirements of social justice. If only they would give up ambitions for illegitimate rule, and for unfair self-enrichment, which have so entranced them.
|