|
Disabled, elderly, ill or convalescing people are much better off in their own homes, if they can get the help they need to live at home--nursing care, housekeeping assistance. 'Warehousing' people who need such help in a central facility--a nursing home--is among the worst ideas of the last century. If you wanted to assist pathogens in spreading infection among people, that's the way to do it--cram sick or incompetent people into over-crowded, understaffed, for-profit facilities, and if you further wanted to assist said pathogens in mutating into resistant strains, you would choose what appears to be the only remedy available in such circumstances--bombarding the inmates with antibiotics. Guaranteed poor care--no matter the benign intentions of health care staff, who often make heroic efforts to give good care but are defeated by the circumstances (for profit facility, understaffed, overcrowded, breeding ground for germs).
In addition to being the best option for the sick and disabled, if possible, home health care is also vastly LESS expensive than nursing homes. The medical care financial system thus doesn't have to pay for food, rent, electricity, laundry, transportation, facility upkeep, facility insurance, some aspects of restorative care and numerous other costs of running a hospital, including costs of satisfying state and federal regulators who are trying to enforce good care standards in these overcrowded, understaffed, for-profit facilities. Nursing home owners and managers complain about regulations--and use regulatory costs as an excuse to underpay their staff--but the circumstance REQUIRES regulation, or else patients are (and have been) abused. That's the nature of capitalism--to abuse the weak until they are forced not to.
But key to this whole syndrome of the poorest possible regulated care--no matter anyone's intentions--is the very notion of centralized care for the elderly, sick or disabled. It was not prevalent a hundred years ago and is not prevalent--indeed, is unheard of--in many other countries and cultures today. It is our own special brand of social malevolence--and reminds me of the U.S. "war on drugs." Idiocy for profit! Bad policy because somebody is making lots and lots of money off it.
A nursing home is sometimes the only option for particular patients but MANY patients would be much better off at home, in familiar surroundings. Among the things they are more likely to have access to, at home--and NOT in a nursing home--are fresh air, a healthy amount of space, freedom, children, pets, plants, gardens, parks and the outdoors, more personal choice in all aspects of life including both entertainment and quiet, and food, and all the motivations that make life worth living. Also, restorative care (working with patients to maximize their independence and self-respect) is an uphill battle when they are crammed 2 and 3 to a room that is really only adequate for one patient and when they are surrounded by other ill, disabled and needy people in the highly unnatural circumstance of a nursing home.
There is much to say about the social/economic conditions that make it impossible for our working people and families to care for their own. There is much to say about a society that basically is organized to discard "unproductive" human beings, and that, for instance, requires years of agitation and advocacy, and lawsuits and lobbying, to achieve minimum humane care for the medically needy. I salute those who have made those efforts--including the nurses' unions--and the political leaders who have responded. Some funding for home health care is one of the results of that agitation--but it is being severely cut back in the current Great Depression For the Poor/Enrichment of the Rich. Overall, we need to face the reality that some of our society's solutions are WRONG--malevolently wrong, or merely ill thought out, contrived as end-runs around the profiteers. We need to RE-THINK all health care.
Unfortunately--tragically--our political system has been rendered unresponsive to THOUGHT. Common sense ain't in it. Profit for the few is the only rule. And that is not going to change until we take some critically important basic steps, starting with throwing the corporate-run, 'TRADE SECRET' voting machines into 'Boston Harbor' where they belong.
I hope that this Obama infusion of funding into health care--if it is passed by this Scumbag, Diebolded Congress--gets directed at the better ideas, such as home health care. It is RARE, however, that such funding doesn't end up in the wrong pockets for the wrong purposes.
I don't trust our filthy political system to create "an open inbox for many innovators and organizations that have an idea to bring to the table." I can't imagine some of the better ideas making it to that "table." (Is that the same "table" that they took impeachment off it? The "table" that the American people are excluded from?) I hope, at a minimum--the least we should expect from our Democratic Party political leaders--that the nurses' unions have a prominent place as "the table"--but it is a wan hope. More likely, they will have lots of union-busters at "the table." That is the tragedy of our era--that most people in this country no longer have any representation in our government whatsoever, from either party.
-------------------------
Note on the Washington Psst (=CIA): This dirty Corporate rag vastly understates the rate of joblessness in this country. "Hovering" at 9 percent, my ass! And, beware! They may be entirely misstating what is really going on with this new funding--i.e., that is less a job creation program than it is a corporate profiteer program, like every other use of our tax dollars. Will these new jobs provide decent wages and benefits? Will new programs be run like for-profit nursing homes (minimum humane care, forced by regulation), or private prisons, or privatized everything else? Will it be a wormhole of BAD ideas, rather than common sense and good, democratically achieved, government policy? The Washington Psst is an evil corporate/war profiteer propaganda sheet. What are they NOT saying? What are they NOT investigating? WHO is going to profit? The American working class? Right.)
|