In the Heat of Battle and Politics, the Hard Facts Melt

[maddezmom]

By JAMES GLANZ
Published: May 20, 2007
BEWARE the benchmarks of Iraq.

As Congress and the American public begin to ask for tangible and quantitative measures of whether the troop increase in Iraq is creating improvement or presiding over failure, it would be wise to remember the kind of place where the United States is dispatching — metaphorically, at least — its statisticians.

Iraq is the place where there are still wildly conflicting estimates of something as fundamental as how many civilians have died as a result of the war. It is a place where some government officials will swear that there are 348,000 wonderfully trained, motivated and equipped Iraqis in the security forces and other officials will tell you that most of those troops and police either have questionable loyalties, lack equipment or simply do not always report for duty.

The precision is very important: 348,000, according to Wednesday’s update from the Pentagon. Or, perhaps, hundreds of thousands less. And the disagreements do not go away even when various groups agree on basic facts — say, that the United States has now spent $8.9 billion of its own and Iraq’s money on rebuilding the electricity and oil sectors, according to the latest figures from the Government Accountability Office.

In those same numbers, oversight agencies see a rebuilding program that has fallen short of virtually all of its performance goals and had little impact on Iraqis’ lives, while organizations that are heavily involved in the program, like the United States Army Corps of Engineers, see a huge success that has not received due credit.

more;http://www.nytimes.com/2007/05/20/weekinreview/20glanz.html?ref=middleeast

[bluestateguy]

1. Nobody has been able to provide me with an explanation of what a "benchmark" is

It sounds like one of those fancy sounding words that they come up with at corporate retreats, or in bureaucratic operating manuals.

[sam sarrha]

2. is the 20 something yr old Jesus freak girl from Regency still running the Reconstruction.??