A serious question about Amanda Knox

[Zadoc]

Here's a serious question. Was the case against Knox stronger than the one against Troy Davis? I think it was. And still she was let go and he was executed.

POLL: Was the case against Troy Davis weaker than the one against Amanda Knox?
Vote: http://www.wepolls.com/p/3360880">http://www.wepolls.com/p/3360880

[MADem]

1. I think that a court in Perugia Italy is not a court in Georgia, USA.

You might as well compare a poodle to a kangaroo. They're both warm blooded animals, but they have not much else in common.

[RandySF]

5. One location was a a Medieval Italian City

The other was Confederate state. They sound similar to me.

[katty]

2. court in Perugia, Italy...way far away from Georgia, USA

[dtexdem]

3. Moral, if you're going to be accused of murder, be accused in Italy.

And also, be white.

[Eric J in MN]

4. They both got railroaded.

It doesn't matter which cases' bogus evidence was more bogus.

[bobburgster]

7. I agree......

bogus is bogus.

[midnight]

12. I agree... Bogus is bogus...

[alphafemale]

6. They are similar but I'm glad justice prevailed this time.

I'm sure Troy Davis would be rejoicing for her as loudly as anyone.

[The Wielding Truth]

8. She would not face the death penalty in Italy and she is white and

not in a southern Republican-run American State.

[emsimon33]

9. Italy banned the death penalty in 1948

Georgia is Georgia and there white is white and non-whites...well, they are NOT whites.

[Eric J in MN]

10. The more important question than which case had weaker evidence...

...is which country has a better appeals process, the US or Italy?

[saras]

11. or which has a better system to get rid of incompetent prosecutors?

[midnight]

13. Good question....