|
There are people with power and privilege in this society - and that includes the progressive liberal and leftist organizations. That sense of "no where to go" that many progressives are feeling is because we are butting up against all these little fiefdoms that people have carved out for themselves, and the doors to these groups are not open. The same people are guarding the gates - the aproximately 10-15% of the population who are white, suburban, professional liberals and progressives - that hijacked the grass roots campaigns. These people build organizations that are the political equivalent of gated, exclusive communities.
You can walk into any right wing organization and your skills will be put to use. There are no litmus-tests, no life style requirements, no sophitication requirements, no degrees needed, and no bona fides or credentials need to be shown. If you can do the job, you are put to work.
The liberal, leftist, and progressive organizations, in contrast, are a tight knit bunch of self-righteous hierarchy-oriented and status-conscious insiders, and common people and outsiders are not welcome. The people who control these organizations are the ones who give us this idea that we have no where to go. We are reluctant to criticize them because we "agree with them" or think they are "for the right causes" so they get a free ride.
The everyday regular people, 70% of the population or more, are where we can go. They have no one listening to them or speaking for them.
African Americans, rural people, working people, Christian people, and most Southerners have all been systematically excluded from the left wing organizations, until and unless they will "play ball" - go to college, move to the suburbs, get a corporate job, "get involved" in the right organizations, adopt the right life style - in other words, be more like us.
Left wing politics has become a lifestyle, not a political movement. Drop the love affair with the lifestyle, and we bring in most of the people and we move forward. Treat politics like a fashion accessory or a social club and we stay mired in futility.
Fifteen years ago I was arguing with fellow Dems about this, and it fell on deaf ears. I said that the party was becoming elitist and losing touch with minorities and workers and the poor. I warned that there was a trend towards fascism in the country that was growing. I said that running to the right and imitating the Republicans was dangerous and would backfire.
The Dems have steered clear of confronting the issues that are most important to the average person, and played ball with corporate interests who have stolen the country out from under us with nary a whimper of opposition and have marginalized and alienated progressive voices. They have imitated the rhetoric of the opposition and embraced the programs of the opposition, from "welfare reform" to "tax cuts" to "de-regulation" and "privatization." They have been running scared, afraid to take stands on principle.
The very predictable result has been a total catastrophe, and the needs of the average citizen have been completely disregarded. The hardships of this complete and shameful abdication of the Democratic party leadership from their historic role and moral obligation to protect and defend their constituency have fallen very harshly on the people at the bottom. Those people have either dropped out of the process altogether and given up, or they have moved to voting Republican out of desperation.
I have kissed up to more Dem, liberal and progressive leaders, followed more instructions for political action, written more checks for causes, signed more petitions, ran around with petitions, canvassed, did phone bank work. etc. etc. for 35 years than any sane person should ever have to do. All that stuff really took off as a popular part time activity for suburban liberals in the 70's, and it replaced the dirty noisy union hall and the wildcat strikes and the illegal marches for justice and all of the other hard life and death actions that people have always taken to achieve social justice. Ever since progressive politics became a suburban hobby, we have gone steadily backwards.
I say that the whole program is flawed and will never get there. I am putting forth the opinion that it is flawed because it is all a middle class white college educated suburban feel good social club. Not to exclude people who fit that description - God bless 'em - but to suggest that the strangle hold they have on the movement is counter-productive. I could be wrong, but that is what I see. They are not yet truly hurting and the struggle isn't as real or as immediate for them as a result.
It is not progressive politics that we can't win people over to. What we can't win the people over to is suburbanism. Suburbanism is so interwoven with liberal and progressive politics that people think they are promoting the one when they are actually promoting the other. The people reject progressive causes not because they reject the principles or the goals. They reject the paternalistic air of superiority and entitlement. They reject suburbanism. They don't trust it. They don't trust corporate managers, educated people, academia, lawyers, activists, do-gooders, know-it-all people, "politically correct" people, etc.
It all smells like hypocrisy to people, and they are not wrong about that. Look at the educated suburban liberals going ga-ga over kill-Arabs-lite that Kerry is promoting. Look at how the liberals spurned Jesse Jackson. Look at how the liberals have caved again and again on worker's rights issues and have completely abandoned racial reconciliation. Look at how the liberals argue for and defend the war on drugs. Look at the hateful and contemptuous way liberals talk about Bush and his supporters as stupid rednecks and idiots and neanderthals and ignorant ass****s.
If we are going to wait for the workers, the migrants, the artisans, the farmers and the poor to become like us before we can build a movement, we have a long, long wait. True progressive movements and true liberalism have always been built on diversity, and on the dignity of the common working man - however simple he or she may seem to be when seen from our ivory tower. Different people have different gifts and have different blessings they were born with. To be born white in the US to suburban parents is an enormous advantage. To be bright and articulate is a product of good fortune and lucky genes. It does not make us superior to the mechanic. Our gifts and blessings need to be put to work for the benefit of all of the people if we are serious about politics. That means that WE need to get off our high horse and change, and stop demanding that the world change to meet our criteria.
Most of the people in the world cannot ever become like us - and we cannot change their hearts and minds - they are fighting for survival and because of skin color or disadvantaged background or circumstance can't join our club if they wanted to. They don't have the luxury of sitting around dreaming up castles in the sand of the perfect world according to suburban intellectuals. It isn't a theoretical world they live in. It is harsh and it is getting worse.
|