Which of these three Led Zeppelin albums is better?

[coloradodem2005]

[ronzo]

1. I like the raw stuff. I voted for LZII.

and 4's overrated.
Physical Graffiti has it's moments...

[Guaranteed]

2. IV's nowhere near their best.

Physical Graffiti followed by, probably, II, then either I or III. Then after those two Houses of the Holy. Then IV.

You know, HOTH could actually be up there with or even above I or III...it's so damned catchy. But, it is really pop-ee...

[nine23]

3. I must go with II.

Back in grade 10, I (simultaneously) smoked my first blunt, and, "removed my first brassiere" off my first girlfriend (rather flawlessly, I might add). Yes, "The Lemon Song" was playing. And yes, I actually "lasted" until "The Lemon Song" (track 3, approx. 5 minutes...). Quite the feat for a pimply faced 13-year old suburban hoser.

Memories are made of this stuff.

[KitchenWitch]

4. HOTH

Who hasn't had sex to this album in the background???

[Coventina]

9. Me

:hi:

I'm not into Zep.
I couldn't even tell you what songs are on HOTH.

[Left Is Write]

10. Well -

Just don't expect to find HOTH on HOTH. The song HOTH is on Physical Graffiti. :)

[imabadman]

5. II...Very Bluesy n/t

[chenGOD]

6. Voted for II.....

But I think my real favorite is "In Through the Out Door" or "Presence". Maybe "Physical Graffiti" or "III" But I find those inconsistent.. (but goddamn "Since I been Loving You" is a great song..."


Tough choices all round...

[Lady Effingbroke]

7. II.

My favorite Zep albums are "II" and..."In Through The Out Door" although "Hot Dog" is a dorky song.

[sundog]

8. uhhh... III

I hust had to be difficult :P