Skippy or Jif? Chunky or smooth? Marshmallow or jelly?

[candy]

I'm a Skippy chunky fan---Jif is too sweet for me.

I like it plain,on Pepperidge Farm oatmeal bread,with nothing added. A perfect food IMHO.

[trotsky]

1. Creamy Jif on one slice, butter on the other.

Put 'em together and you've got P.B. heaven.

[mitchtv]

10. one of my favorites

with chocolate milk

[aintitfunny]

2. Jiff, Creamy

with a banana on whole grain. Although I will do skippy when it is on sale.

[davidinalameda]

3. smooth Jif

there's no other peanut butter that can compare

[BOSSHOG]

4. Creamy Jiff

knifed on thick on whole wheat bread. I remember my mother buying both Jiff and Skippy to satisfy my older brother and me who had different tastes in the awesome invention.

[MissMarple]

6. With jelly, please.

:D

[davidinalameda]

30. no jelly

why get the bread all soggy

it detracts from the texture of the peanut butter

[Left Is Write]

5. Jif. I like both creamy and chunky.

I grew up in a Skippy family. That's all my mom ever bought was Skippy, for years and years and years.

In my mid-20s, between radio jobs, I moved back in with my parents for a few months. I had started buying Jif and brought some to their house. My mother tried the Jif, and then she stopped buying Skippy. Thirty years of buying Skippy, and I changed her mind. She's been buying Jif ever since.

I don't eat marshmallow fluff or jelly. I like peanut butter and jam, but it must be jam, lots of pieces of fruit, and preferably homemade if possible.

[movie_girl99]

7. OMG i love

creamy jif on wheatberry bread!!!

[mitchtv]

8. Creamy Jif on toast with

Bacon and Mayo Skippy honey roasted is fine , too.

[nickinSTL]

9. Jif...chunky...jelly

If those are the only choices.

I usually do Peter Pan, though Jif is ok

Always chunky

I prefer honey rather than jelly

[bobbobbins]

11. i get the all natural peanut butter, with the oil on the top

it kicks a polar bears ass

[truthseeker1]

12. I'm with you

once I tasted the real thing, I could never go back to skippy.

[Kazak]

14. Yep, that's the best stuff.

Hands down. I think the brand I usually buy is Smucker's.

[bobbobbins]

15. yup, with a name like Smuckers, it has to be good

[GOPisEvil]

21. Yessir...that is, in fact, the correct answer.

[Solly Mack]

13. Jif, creamy... and nutella

[dr.strangelove]

16. Eat Some Peanut Butter Anytime You Can, But Only If Its Peter Pan

Creamy Peter Pan.

[TahitiNut]

17. Creamy Jif .... yum!

[candy]

18. Jif won----no contest! p.s.---I still like Skippy. n/t

[lavenderdiva]

19. Peter Pan Smooth Whipped...

its whipped to be extra fluffy. On Oroweat HoneyWheatberry bread spread with butter first, then smear the Peter Pan on. Yummy!!! :bounce:

ps. also like to get a spoonful of peanut butter and dip it into a bowl of semi-sweet chocolate chips and enjoy!

[yellowdogintexas]

20. chunky, Peter Pan or actually Albertson's house brand is

good too

I love peanut butter and jelly blended together and spread on saltines with home made vegetable soup. My mom always served that when she made soup it is very tasty.

[Left Is Write]

22. I buy the Albertson's brand when I'm making peanut butter cookies.

Quite good for that!

[lavenderdiva]

23. hey, yellowdogintexas! where are you getting Albertson's

in Texas? They completely pulled of Houston, and I thought I read they pulled out of Texas altogether? I liked shopping at Albertsons...

[GOPisEvil]

24. We have Albertson's here in Austin.

They pulled out of San Antonio though.

[yellowdogintexas]

26. all over Fort Worth, one on every corner.

We have Albertson's, Tom Thumb, Kroger, Minyards and Central Market in Fort Worth. Oh Yeah, Carnival and Fiesta two big Mexican chains

and some small chain called Sav A Lot...

[lavenderdiva]

29. man, oh man... what a selection!

we have Kroger, Randall's, Rice Epicurean, HEB, Central Market, and Fiesta, and Walmart. Unfortunately, no Albertson's. They completely pulled out of Houston back in 2002, I think. There was one about a half-mile from my house, and I liked shopping there. When Walmart expanded their grocery stores, they pulled out. Lucky you!

[yellowdogintexas]

34. I even forgot that we have WalMart and Target with grocery

departments in them....
Tom Thumb is our version of Randall's I think. Isn't Randall's owned by SAfeway?

But what the hey, you got Central Market, just like us. We do not have your basic HEB ...yet. I keep hearing rumors they plan to invade the MetroPlex soon.

Albertson's couldn't make it in Nashville either, according to my friends up there. But it is thriving here. Guess we just like to eat a lot in Fort Worth

[loudestchick]

25. Simply Jif w/ Smuckers Simply 100% Fruit Blackberry Spread on Honey Wheat

[really-looney]

27. You need Fluff, Fluff, Fluff.........

To make a

[SmileyBoy]

36. FLUFFERNUTTER!!!!!

Those are good, too.

[seemunkee]

28. Jiff smooth There is no other

The nuts in chunky get stuck in the IV.

[Magrittes Pipe]

31. Natural, unsweetened peanut butter.

No jelly or marshmallow fluff.

Just peanut butter and toast. Or good bread. But with good bread, I usually prefer Nutella.

[VelmaD]

32. Jif chunky and blackberry jelly...

on wheat bread. Preferably the Hytop blackberry jelly you can only get in northeast Texas. Yummmmmmmmmm. :)

[Touchdown]

33. Peter Pan creamy

Grilled or griddled (like a grilled cheese sandwich).

I just don't get the rip off that is "chunky" peanut butter. Why pay full price for PB that's only half done?:shrug:

[SmileyBoy]

35. Creamy, Jif, and Smuckers Strawberry Jelly.

:9

[Sanity Claws]

37. Adams -- the real peanut butter

I love Adams -- it's a brand made only with peanuts, no corn syrup or other stuff. It really is good.
I like my peanut butter plain on a rice cake (can't eat wheat) or with banana. Yummy!