Peanut Butter: Regular or Chunky?

[Mayberry Machiavelli]

[HereSince1628]

1. That really depends on what I am doing with it.

Sometimes the chunks just seem wrong. As in my peanut butter shakes.
I also think creamy is a better choice in sweet potato soup.

[terrya]

2. There's nothing like a pb&j with CHUNKY peanut butter.

[Mayberry Machiavelli]

3. It appears that the country, or at least DU, is evenly split on the

"smooth/chunky" issue.

[Sannum]

4. Other: It depends on what you're making

Oh my god, Whole Foods has the most wonderful organic peanut butter! It was the perfect combination of the two and it doesn't have any added sugar or chemicals. Soooo much better than ol' Jif! It is fresh, so you buy it by weight. You have to eat it quick because there are no preservatives, but that is the thing that makes it so good!

When I was a kid, for about a year I would only eat something if it had peanut butter. I still have the occasional meal of "Peanut Butter on a Spoon:9...