8 planets or 12

[mduffy31]

...make up your goddamn minds people, I've got a life to lead here!

[Floogeldy]

1. One planet, dude.

One.

:web:

[MiniMandaRuth]

2. For a moment, I thought that was the Woohoo smiley.

And that he wouldn't move...

[pokerfan]

3. It's opinionated and subjective

But I think Pluto is closer to a Kuiper belt object than it is to a planet. So we have eight planets, IMO: four rocky ones close in and four gassy ones farther out.

[hyphenate]

4. I'd rather give the

smaller 'roids a chance to be big and call them ALL planets. Instead of 8, we'd have 12--big whoop.

[baldguy]

5. 30

[El Fuego]

6. I have to go with 8

Because it won't stop at 12! Every friggin' ice rock out there is going to want to be in the planet club.

[tjwmason]

7. The final decision has been made.

Gustav Holst, "The Planets" doesn't have Pluto or any of these over-grown asteroids as movements...thus 8.

[swimboy]

8. Moderator, please move to Classical Music Forum.

}(

[tjwmason]

9. How did I guess

that you would be the one to reply to that post? :eyes:

:loveya: