|
Edited on Sun Oct-28-07 10:39 AM by alcibiades_mystery
The whole myth of the "Sad Sack Red Sox" so cherished by their fans is of relatively recent vintage, despite the long drought, spanning mainly from the late 1970's until the early part of this decade. True, many younger Red Sox fans knew only this fanciful concoction, and the sports writers (and marketers) knew how to spin that yarn for dollars. Similarly, the Yankee Powerhouse legend is really a piecemeal operation, coming in spurts in the 30's, 50's, late 70's, and late 90's. Don Mattingly (Yankees, 1982-1995) never even SAW a World Series as a player. He saw a playoff series only in his final year, when the Yankees squeaked in to the playoffs only to be beaten by the Mariners. This was really the birth of the modern Yankee era, which is the only one people are really talking about when they invoke the so-called "Evil Empire." Of course, the economics of the sport were changing, and the big market teams were the first to grasp and exploit that. The Red Sox were on board soon after, and the last six years have pretty much played the same marketing and recruiting game as the Yankees did in the mid-to-late 90's, before the front office started writing Big Checks for Old-Timers (was there ever a player less suited to pitch in New York City than the worn out hillbilly Randy Johnson?).
So essentially there are two competing narratives at play:
1) The fanciful marketing gimmick that is the "Red Sox Nation" - a put upon group of righteous losers finally made good. Needless to say, this is the most attractive narrative in our culture (Horatio Alger written in sports: the Karate Kid Redux), which is why so many suckers cling to it like grim death.
2) The hard economic narrative, which makes a mockery of the first.
What we see on these boards is the comical clash of these stories. If you remind Red Sox fans that their team is very much like the Thing They Have Hated (tm), they'll do two things: first, they'll tell you that they REALLY REALLY KNOW that the Red Sox are a Powerhouse Team and not the Lovable Losers of Yore (tm). Then they'll call you an asshole for bringing it up. Needless to say, it doesn't make a bit of sense to do BOTH: if they know it, they shouldn't be the least upset. But they get upset because of the sheer preciousness of Narrative 1, even while Narrative 2 is manifest.
|