"St. Elmo's Fire" or "The Breakfast Club"?

[Mike03]

Or, as a wild card, "Bright Lights, Big City"?

[MorningGlow]

1. Breakfast Club--no question

Better script, better archetypes, and more hopeful. A classic. SEF--minor classic.

[x-g.o.p.er]

2. Breakfast Club, hands down

Great movie. We either were or knew one of the characters in that movie. Or a combination.

I didn't relate to St Elmo's Fire at all.

[lost-in-nj]

3. breakfast club

heres why




thud......




lost


wait did either one have a "meaning"????


LOL

:hug:

lost

[Alexander]

4. Breakfast Club is timeless. St. Elmo's Fire is too 80s.

C'mon, Demi Moore's depressed because she overcharged her card and all her stuff got repoed?

How on earth are most people supposed to relate to that?

[Sugar Smack]

8. AUGH! St. Elmo's Fire gave me hives-

Wish I could huddle, shivering, in a big, empty room, while my friends tried to break down the door and blowtorch the bars on the window while I just sat there rocking like a spoiled, crazy brat. And when they finally heard me laugh a little bit after my extremely stupid excuse for acting like a nut, say things like, "SHE'S LAUGHING!"

I wish I could talk about peanut butter & jelly sandwiches in a way that would make Rob Lowe come over, sit next to me, and say, "So you wanna have sex, or what?"

Life after college, kids. No, really. :eyes: No. Really.

[SPKrazy]

5. St. Elmo's Fire

awesome movie, awesome

love it

:woohoo:

[enigmatic]

6. Heathers

[Connonym]

7. that was a brilliant movie

Dark and twisty, just how I like it.

[SKKY]

9. "Don't you, forget about me. Don't, don't, don't, don't you, forget about me!"

[Ava]

10. breakfast club

it's one of the few 80's "teen" movies that I like. i actually love that movie!

[fishwax]

11. Definitely The Breakfast Club

[Canuckistanian]

12. Gotta go with BC. St. Elmo's Fire was transparently derivative.

Derivative of what, I'm not at liberty to say...