"The most important environmental liability of
nuclear fission is neither the routine nor accidental emissions
of radioactivity, but the deliberate misuse of nuclear facilities
and materials for acts of terrorism and war."
- John Holdren, Assessing Environmental Risks of Energy
John Holdren is President Obama's science advisor.
Despite the million-year waste disposal problem,
the mining, milling, and tailings,
the meltdowns, leaks, and venting,
nuclear weapons are still the most important environmental problem with nuclear energy.
http://ajph.aphapublications.org/cgi/reprint/71/9/1046.pdfAssessing Environmental Risks of Energy
PETER H. GLEICK, MS, AND JOHN P. HOLDREN, PHD
AJPH September 1981, Vol. 71, No. 9
<snip>
The most important environmental liability of
nuclear fission is neither the routine nor accidental emissions
of radioactivity, but the deliberate misuse of nuclear facilities
and materials for acts of terrorism and war.
<snip>
where the aim of the assessment is to tally up the total environmental
costs associated with an energy source, or to compare the
environmental costs of one energy source with another, it is
essential that all the fuel-cycle steps and associated subsystems
and activities be included for every energy source that
is being considered. It is surprising how often this elementary
principle of consistency has been neglected in published
assessments. A striking example was the widely publicized
risk comparison of renewable and nonrenewable energy
sources by Inhaber which included the occupational hazards
of materials acquisition and facility construction in the
risk totals for the renewable sources but omitted these
hazards in the totals for the nonrenewables. A less transparent
example of the inconsistent-boundary syndrome is the
much-cited calculation that a coal-burning power plant produces
a greater radiation hazard than does a properly
operating light-water reactor, owing to the coal plant's
release up the stack of uranium and thorium present as trace
contaminants in the fuel. This conclusion follows from
drawing the system boundaries so that they include the main
source of radionuclide emission in the coal fuel cycle (the
power plant) but exclude the activities in the nuclear fuel
cycle (mining, milling, reprocessing) that account for 90 per
cent or more of the routine emissions caused by nuclear
generation of electricity.
<snip>