|
Compare And Contrast: Hillary And Obama's Votes On Iraq
By Greg Sargent and Eric Kleefeld
Since the comparison of the Iraq positions over the years of Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama is one of the hottest issues of the campaign, we thought it would be useful to post a comprehensive comparison of all of their votes on everything relating to the Iraq war.
So here it is: A massive compilation of Iraq-related bills -- and the votes by Hillary and Obama on them, side by side -- beginning in early 2005, when Obama first joined the Senate.
Of the total of 69 votes we compiled -- some significant, some not -- it turns out that the two differed on only one. You'll see that one in bold on our chart. But let us be clear: We are not posting this to suggest that their earlier difference at the start of the war -- their most important difference -- should in any way be overshadowed by these similarities. For many, that difference will remain paramount -- for good reason. We just wanted to add factual grist to what is but one component of the debate.
As you can see, Clinton and Obama have voted the opposite way on only one vote on our list: The confirmation of General George Casey to be Chief of Staff for the Army, held just this past February. Hillary voted against confirmation, while Obama voted to confirm.
Additionally, please don't hold it against us if we missed any important votes. No agenda here, readers. If we did, let us know, and we'll add it immediately. Herewith, our full chart of Iraq votes after the jump.
VOTE
CLINTON OBAMA
DESCRIPTION SR38, #4, 02/07/05 Y Y A resolution commending the people of Iraq on the January 30, 2005, national elections. HR1268, #89, 04/12/05 Y Y Motion to Waive Sec. 402, S. Con. Res. 95 (108th) "Emergency designation" Re: Murray Amdt. No. 344, As Modified; To provide $1,975,183,000 for medical care for veterans. HR1268, #90, 04/12/05 Y Y Motion to Waive C.B.A. Re: Murray Amdt. No. 344, As Modified; To provide $1,975,183,000 for medical care for veterans. HR1268, #93, 04/13/05 N N Byrd Amdt. No. 367; To reduce by $36,000,000 the amount appropriated for "Military Construction, Army", with the amount of the reduction to be allocated to funds available under that heading for the Camp 6 Detention Facility at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. HR1268, #96, 04/18/05
Y Missed Vote
Byrd Amdt. No. 464; To express the sense of the Senate on future requests for funding for military operations in Afghanistan and Iraq. HR1268, #103, 04/19/05 Y Y Motion to Invoke cloture on HR 1268, As Amended; Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Tsunami Relief, 2005 HR1268, #104, 04/20/05 N N Motion to Table Coburn Amdt. No. 471; To reduce appropriations for the Iraqi embassy to reduce outlays expected to occur in fiscal year 2007 or later. HR 1268, #109, 04/21/05 Y Y H.R. 1268 As Amended; EmergencySupplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Tsunami Relief, 2005 HR1268, #117, 05/10/05 Y Y H. R. 1268 Conference Report; Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Tsunami Relief, 2005 S1042, #199, 06/21/05 Y Y Warner Amdt. No. 1314 as Modified; Toincrease, with an offset, amounts available for the procurement of wheeled vehicles for the Army and the Marine Corps and for armor for such vehicles. S1042, #205, 07/26/05 N N Motion To Invoke Cloture On S. 1042; National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2006 HR 2862, #228, 09/14/05 Y Y Motion To Suspend Paragraph 4, Rule XVI RE: Dorgan Amdt. No. 1670; To establish a special committee of the Senate to investigate the awarding and carrying out of contracts to conduct activities in Afghanistan and Iraq and to fight the war on terrorism. HR2863, #247, 10/05/05 Y Y Is the Amendment No. 1955, as modified,germane to H.R.2863; To authorize appropriations for fiscal year 2006 for military activities of the Department of Defense, for military construction, and for defense activities of the Department of Energy, to prescribe personnel strengths for such fiscal year for the Armed Forces, and for other purposes. HR2863, #248, 10/05/05 Y Y Motion to Waive C.B.A. re: Bayh Amdt. No. 1933; To increase by $360,800,000 amounts appropriated by title IX for Other Procurement, Army, for the procurement of armored Tactical Wheeled Vehicles for units deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and to increase by $5,000,000 amounts appropriated by title IX for Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Defense-Wide, for industrial preparedness for the implementation of a ballistics engineering research center. HR2863, #252, 10/05/05 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on H.R. 2863;Department of Defense, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations to Address Hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, and Pandemic Influenza Act, 2006 HR2863, #254, 10/07/05 Y Y H.R. 2863 As Amended; Department ofDefense, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations to Address Hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, and Pandemic Influenza Act, 2006 HR3058, #259, 10/19/05 Y Y Motion to Suspend Rule XVI, Paragraph 4 Re: Dorgan Amdt. No. 2078; To establish a special committee of the Senate on war and reconstruction contracting. S1042, #309, 11/08/05 Y Y Levin Amdt. No. 2430; To establish a national commission on policies and practices on the treatment of detainees since September 11, 2001. S1042, #316, 11/10/05 Y Y Dorgan Amdt. No. 2476; To establish a special committee of the Senate to investigate the awarding and carrying out of contracts to conduct activities in Afghanistan and Iraq and to fight the war on terrorism. S1042, #318, 11/10/05 Y Y Kerry Amdt. No. 2507 As Amended; To require reports on clandestine facilities for the detention of individuals captured in the global war on terrorism. S1042, #319, 11/10/05 N N Graham Amdt. No. 2516; Relating to the review of the status of detainees of the United States Government. S1042, #322, 11/15/05 Y Y Levin Amdt. No. 2519; To clarify andrecommend changes to the policy of the United States on Iraq and to require reports on certain matters relating to Iraq. S1042, #323, 11/15/05 Y Y Warner Amdt. No. 2518; To clarify andrecommend changes to the policy of the United States on Iraq and to require reports on certain matters relating to Iraq. S1042, #325, 11/15/05 Y Y Levin Amdt. No. 2519; To clarify andrecommend changes to the policy of the United States on Iraq and to require reports on certain matters relating to Iraq. S1042, #326, 11/15/05 Y Y S. 1042 As Amended; National DefenseAuthorization Act for Fiscal Year 2006 HR2863, #359, 12/19/05 Y Y Motion to Proceed to the Conference Report toAccompany H.R. 2863; Department of Defense, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations to Address Hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, and Pandemic Influenza Act, 2006 HR1815, #360, 12/19/05 Y Y Motion to Proceed to Conference Report to Accompany H.R. 1815; National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2006 HR2863, #364, 12/21/05 N N Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Conference Report to Accompany H.R. 2863; Department of Defense, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations to Address Hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, and Pandemic Influenza Act, 2006 HR2863, #366, 12/21/05 Y Y H.R. 2863 Conference Report; Department of Defense, Emergency Supplemental Appropriations to Address Hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico, and Pandemic Influenza Act, 2006 HR4939, #101, 04/27/06 Y Y Byrd Amdt. No. 3709; To express the sense of the Senate on requests for funds for military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan for fiscal years after fiscal year 2007. HR4939, #103, 05/02/06 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on H.R. 4939;Emergency Supplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Hurricane Recovery, 2006 HR4939, #112, 05/04/06 Y Y H.R. 4939 As Amended; EmergencySupplemental Appropriations Act for Defense, the Global War on Terror, and Hurricane Recovery, 2006 S2766, #168, 06/13/06 Y Y Frist Amdt. No. 4208; To express the sense of Congress that the United States Armed Forces, the intelligence community, and other agencies, as well as the coalition partners of the United States and the Iraqi Security Forces should be commended for their actions that resulted in the death of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the leader of the al-Qaeda in Iraq terrorist organization and the most wanted terrorist in Iraq. S2766, #170, 06/14/06 Y Y McCain Amdt. No. 4242; To require regular budgeting for ongoing military operations. S2766, #172, 06/15/06 N N Santorum Amdt. No. 4234; To authorize, with an offset, assistance for prodemocracy programs and activities inside and outside Iran, to make clear that the United States supports the ability of the people of Iran to exercise self-determination over their form of government, and to make enhancements to the Iran-Libya Sanctions Act of 1996. S2766, #174, 06/15/06 Y Y Motion to Table McConnell Amdt. 4269; To require the withdrawal of the United States Armed Forces from Iraq and urge the convening of an Iraq summit. S2766, #176, 06/20/06 Y Y Dorgan Amdt. No. 4292; To establish a special committee of the Senate to investigate the awarding and carrying out of contracts to conduct activities in Afghanistan and Iraq and to fight the war on terrorism. S2766, #177, 06/20/06 N N McConnell Amdt. No. 4272 As Modified; To affirm the Iraqi Government position of no amnesty for terrorists who have attacked U.S. forces. S2766, #178, 06/20/06 Y Y Nelson (FL) Amdt. No. 4265; To express the sense of Congress that the Government of Iraq should not grant amnesty to persons known to have attacked, killed, or wounded members of the Armed Forces of the United States. S2766, #181, 06/22/06
N N Kerry Amdt. No. 4442; To require the redeployment of United States Armed Forces from Iraq in order to further a political solution in Iraq, encourage the people of Iraq to provide for their own security, and achieve victory in the war on terror. S2766, #182, 06/22/06 Y Y Levin Amdt. No. 4320; To state the sense of Congress on United States policy on Iraq. S2766, #183, 06/22/06 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on S. 2766; JohnWarner National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 S2766, #186, 06/22/06 Y Y S. 2766 As Amended; John Warner National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2007 HR5631, #225, 08/03/06 Y Y Boxer Amdt. No. 4858; To prohibit the use of funds by the United States Government to enter into an agreement with the Government of Iraq that would subject members of the Armed Forces to the jurisdiction of Iraq criminal courts or punishment under Iraq law. HR5631, #233, 09/06/06 N N Motion to Table Kennedy Amdt. No. 4885; To include information on civil war in Iraq in the quarterly reports on progress toward military and political stability in Iraq. HR5631, #236, 09/07/06 N N Motion to Table Menendez Amdt. No. 4909; To prohibit the use of funds for a public relations program designed to monitor news media in the United States and the Middle East and create a database of news stories to promote positive coverage of the war in Iraq. HR5631, #237, 09/07/06 N N Motion to Table Schumer Amdt. No. 4897; To make available up to an additional $700,000,000 for Drug Interdiction and Counter-Drug Activities to combat the growth of poppies in Afghanistan, to eliminate the production and trade of opium, and heroin, and to prevent terrorists from using the proceeds for terrorist activities in Afghanistan, Iraq, and elsewhere, and to designate the additional amount as emergency spending. HR5631, #239, 09/07/06 Y Y H.R. 5631 As Amended; Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2007 HR4954, #243, 09/13/06 Y Y Motion to Waive CBA Re: Reid Amdt. No.4936;To provide real national security, restore United States leadership, and implement tough and smart policies to win the war on terror. S3930, #254, 09/27/06 Y Y Levin Amdt. No. 5086; In the nature of a substitute. S3930, #255, 09/28/06 Y Y Specter Amdt. No. 5087; To strike the provision regarding habeas review. S3930, #256, 09/28/06 Y Y Rockefeller Amdt. No. 5095; To provide for congressional oversight of certain Central Intelligence Agency programs. S3930, #257, 09/28/06 Y Y Byrd Amdt. 5104; To prohibit the establishment of new military commissions after December 31, 2011. S3930, #259, 09/28/06 N N On Passage, S. 3930 As Amended; Military Commissions Act of 2006 HR5631, #261, 09/29/06 Y Y H.R.5631 Conference Report; Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 2007 Petraeus Conf., #33, 01/26/07 Y Y Confirmation Lt. Gen. David H. Petraeus, U.S. Army, to be General SCR2, #43, 02/01/07 N N Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Motion toProceed to S.Con.Res.2; A concurrent resolution expressing the bipartisan resolution on Iraq. S470, #44, 02/05/07 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Motion toProceed to S. 470; A bill to express the sense of Congress on Iraq. Casey Conf., #45, 02/08/07
N Y Confirmation Gen. George W. Casey to be Chief of Staff, U.S. Army S574, #51, 02/17/07 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Motion toProceed to S.574; A bill to express the sense of Congress on Iraq. SJR9, #74, 03/14/07 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on the Motion toProceed to Consider S. J. Res. 9; A joint resolution to revise United States policy on Iraq. SJR9, #75, 03/15/07 Y Y S. J. Res. 9; A joint resolution to revise United States policy on Iraq. SR107, #76, 03/15/07 Y Y S. Res. 107; A resolution expressing the sense of the Senate that no action should be taken to undermine the safety of the Armed Forces of the United States or impact their ability to complete their assigned or future missions. SCR20, #77, 03/15/07 Y Y S. Con. Res. 20; A concurrent resolutionexpressing the sense of Congress that no funds should be cut off or reduced for American Troops in the field which would result in undermining their safety or their ability to complete their assigned mission. HR1591, #116, 3/27/07 N N Cochran Amd. No. 643; To strike language that would tie the hands of the Commander-in-Chief by imposing an arbitrary timetable for the withdrawal of US forces from Iraq, thereby undermining the position of American Armed Forces and jeopardizing the successful conclusion of Operation Iraqi Freedom. HR1591, #117, 3/28/07 Y Y Motion to Invoke Cloture on H.R. 1591; U.S. Troop Readiness, Veterans' Health, and Iraq Accountability Act, 2007 HR1591, #124, 3/29/07 Y Y Biden Amdt. No. 739; To appropriate an additional $1,500,000,000 for Procurement, Marine Corps, to accelerate the procurement of an additional 2,500 Mine Resistant Ambush Protected vehicles for the Armed Forces. HR1591, #125, 3/29/07 Y Y Is Section 431 of the Senate Language to H.R. 1591 Germane?; In the nature of a substitute. HR1591, #126, 3/29/07 Y Y H.R. 1591, As Amended; U.S. Troop Readiness, Veterans'
|