I request your learned opiinion of these opinions (from
CBS Sportsline; JP = Jay Privman, MW is Mike Watchmaker):
BROTHER DEREK 7-2 Best Beyer: 108 Cecil Peacock, D.Hendricks, Alex Solis
JP: Considering how well he usually works, Monday's drill was a cut below.
MW: Getting the feeling that people are jumping off his bandwagon.
LAWYER RON 5-1 106 Est. of James Hines, Jr., R. Holthus, J. McKee
JP: Continues to win races, but slow final time of Arkansas Derby is a bit of a concern.
WM: Concern would be stronger for me if he hadn't already proven he can run fast.
BARBARO 6-1 103 Lael Stables, M. Matz, E. Prado
JP: Horses race less frequently these days, so five week break doesn't bother me.
MW: By Derby day, he will have raced only once in 13 weeks; that bothers me.
SWEETNORTHERNSAINT 10-1 109 J. Balsamo and T. Theos, M. Trombetta, K. Desormeaux
JP: For one who's never been down this road, Trombetta has made the right moves.
WM: He's fast, and he's learned to sit off the lead in his last two races. Dangerous.
BOB AND JOHN 12-1 102 Stonerside Stable LLC, B. Baffert, G. Gomez
JP: Much better when he has a target, and he'll have plenty of targets in the Derby.
MW: It's funny, everyone thinks he's a deep closer, but he's never won from way back.
A. P. WARRIOR 15-1 101 Stan Fulton, J. Sherreffs, C. Nakatani
JP: Fast becoming my wise-guy horse; think he'll take a big step forward off last race.
WM: Jay is not alone, others are lining up behind him as well. A potential underlay.
POINT DETERMINED 15-1 103 Beverly and Est. of Bob Lewis, B. Baffert, R. Bejarano
JP: Will be trying to make amends for his Daddy's puzzling flop five years ago.
MW: Unlike his sire, he has more than just two preps coming into this year's race.
SINISTER MINISTER 15-1 116 Lanni, Moody and Schiappa, B. Baffert, V. Espinoza
JP: Shades of War Emblem: private purchase, very fast, has highest Beyer fig.
WM: But will he enjoy the soft fractions like War Emblem did when he won in 2002.
STEPPENWOLFER 20-1 94 Robert and Lawana Low, D. Petiz, R. Albarado
JP: Got plenty of pace to set up his late run, but was still second-best to Lawyer Ron.
MW: With his running style, a lot of people will be on him to get a piece at Churchill.
BLUEGRASS CAT 30-1 99 WinStar Farm LLC, T. Pletcher, J. Velazquez
JP: Has not made any progress from last year; very disapointing in his final prep.
WM: Considering he went backwards from Tampa to Keeneland, I agree with Jay.
JAZIL 30-1 97 Shadwell Stable, K. McLaughlin, F. Jara
JP: Expected fast pace will help his chances, but strikes me as kind of a plodder.
MW: They walked home in the Wood. Then again, they might walk home in this, too.
SUNRIVER 30-1 97 Aaron and Marie Jones, T. Pletcher, jockey undecided
JP: Needs a couple defections on the earnings list to get in; Pletcher wants to run.
WM: Also has a five week layoff to deal with; but he'll be five times the price of Barbaro.
KEYED ENTRY 40-1 110 Starlight Stable, T. Pletcher, P. Valenzuela
JP: Don't see how this race can set up for a speed horse with distance questions.
MW: Might try to rate like he did in the Gotham; the distance is a big issue, however.
PRIVATE VOW 40-1 96 Mike McCarty, S. Asmussen, S. Bridgmohan
JP: Improved in second start of the year, but still seems a cut below the very best.
WM: Even with improvement, I don't see him ever beating Lawyer Ron in a fair race.
SACRED LIGHT 40-1 99 Amerman Racing Stable, D. Hofmans, A. Gryder
JP: Stumbled badly at start of SA Derby; may not have enough earnings to get in.
MW: Throw out his last race. If he is able to start, he has some appeal as a closer.
SHARP HUMOR 40-1 102 Purdedel Stable, D. Romans, M. Guidry
JP: When discussing pace of Derby, he should be near the top of the list. Very quick.
WM: So is Sinister Minister, and neither colt is good for the prospects of the other.
SHOWING UP 40-1 100 Lael Stablee, B. Tagg, C. Velasquez
JP: Showed quality to win Lexington in stakes debut, but Derby is much tougher.
MW: Agreed. This colt has a bright future, but Derby may be too much, too soon.
CAUSE TO BELIEVE 50-1 98 Peter Redekop, J. Hollendorfer, R. Baze
JP: Pace in Ill. Derby did not suit his style; wants to sit back and make one run.
WM: Well, the pace in this should be to his liking; just doubt he's good enough.
DEPUTY GLITTERS 60-1 102
JP: Poor effort in Wood, suspect form in Tampa puts him way down on my list.
MW: It is difficult to be enthusiastic about his chances off a final prep like that.
STORM TREASURE 60-1 95
JP: Was only one to make up any ground in Blue Grass, but no match for winner.
WM: Only Sinister Minister ran a jump in Blue Grass; somone had to be second.
FLASHY BULL 80-1 94
JP: Like Bluegrass Cat, he just does not seem to have made progress from 2 to 3.
MW: No one would have thought it after they finished 1-2 in the Remsen.