|
What multiculturalism is in practice is postmodernism; then we have 300,000,000 television channels and everyone lives on a different channel. People who watch the same TV shows can communicate. Part of what makes it "work" in the US is that the country is pushing the envelope on the flexible labor meme. Then that flexible labour has to travel and move 1000's of miles to stay employed. THis constant movement of population creates fundamentally 2 classes. There are the "locals" and the "incomers". Locals live within 10 miles of where they were born, have never left, and often descend from a genetic stock of locals who haven't left either.
Incomers are everyone else, and as long as the locals stay vastly outnumbered, and do not have any race, religious or ethnic differences, there seems little friction. But when the incomers are very small in number, then there becomes a lot of problems with multiculturalism, especially in welfare states where "locals" are paid to sit in their houses than move to get a job elsewhere. Then you get pockets of angry white men who can't accept the more cosmopolitan habits of their travelling peers. And as these local pockets develop over centuries, much as in the american south, they systemically attack the cosmopolitian as a threat to their parochialism.
They believe in a theory that you can make a social or political problem exogenous, by banning it. They try things like banning gays, cannabis, dance clubs, free sex and all these liberties that "appear" not to be part of the parochial life. But then the truth is not so simple, and often when a person in a locals area, discovers they are gay, they leave and join the incomers elsewhere, usually in major city where everyone is an incomer, and there are no local tyrants.
But many european countries are suffering a tyranny of the locals... switzerland, britain, germany where parts of the country are soooo stagnated in terms of population movement, that people are sometimes referred to by the name of where they live... as if the geography has grown in to their soul like a tree. So the locals are only a problem if they are uneducated, poor and unemployed, but that is too often the case in the housing estates across europe.
But this parochial/cosmopolitain, metrosexual/redneck, city-states/rural suggests that the rural local is a lesser creature, one that is focused on earthly kingdom, ego, worldy power and business. The red state blue state purple state fact of multiculturalsm... but if the red states were really all red, and the blues really all blue, then you have rather a divided nation, not multiculturalism. That is what i've observed in europe, just as there is not the immigration to offset the heavy navel gazing selfishness, the puerile immaturity that lashes out with violence at what it does not understand. And so you get riots and social unrest when the integration of multiculturalsim is not comprehensive. Then you get what is seen in europe today, people saying "multiculturalism has failed." It only works if the blood flows in the veins, like red platelets, the individual citizens intermix, travel and see the whole country as "their local"... but when the blood just sits in the body and does not move, as often in the unemployed welfare state, the body is like a corpse, and the red blood cells become anemic.
Your optimism about multiculturalism is founded in your own cosmopolitan nature. If you can put yourself in the shoes of a "local", someone who's so attached to place, they would rather be a king in a small pool than discover there is an ocean out there. If you shrink a grinch heart 3 sizes too small, you get a republican, you get a collapsed localist with all the generosity of a shrew. (metaphor not animal). If you shrink your heart down to the racist size of the little minds that hate multiculturalsim, in to the lens of homophobia, misogyny, and paranoia about liberality and the enlightenment, from that shrunken space, you can see that the greater world, the majority of the world's population, is there. You are lucky beyond measure to be educated, in good health, in a free country, with economic means to self determination. All war is class war. The local/incomer friction is the seat in every conflict today, and you reflect on the bottom line.
|