Sorry Rudy, We're Fed Up; Giuliani Attack Ad (MSNBC/Hardball Contest Entry)

[mrdemocrat78]

Run time: 00:37 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A22Je-wyzL8   Posted on YouTube: July 22, 2007 By YouTube Member: Views on YouTube: 0   Posted on DU: July 23, 2007 By DU Member: mrdemocrat78 Views on DU: 2317

 
Hello, this is my entry into Hardballs Political Ad Contest. I decided to keep this real short, and to the point rather than my normal 3-5 minute ramblings.

I would appreciate any comments or constructive criticism

[WileEcoyote]

1. Keep playing it. It sells well.

Maybe include something like: "Have you had enough of the Republicans yet"?

Or just "Have you had enough"?

[mrdemocrat78]

4. yeah...

but the first screen is "Had Enough"

do you think it's necessary? I figured people would know what I was talking about when they watched it.

[Me.]

5. I Think It Needs A Direct Connection Between Rudy's Words

and the lies of the others. I agree that the 'choir' would understand what you're saying, but it's those who don't already believe that republicans are all liars that you need to reach.

[mrdemocrat78]

6. you know where i can get one?

i couldn't find anything that i could download. i couldn't find any audio of him at all. i was able to "save as target" all the other audio, but i couldn't find anything on giuliani.

if anyone knows where i can get some audio, please, let me know.

[Me.]

7. Don't Know If This Will Help Or If You Can Utilize Any Of These

But here is a link to a group of Rudy quotes on youtube

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pZbBLHBMcOg

[mrdemocrat78]

9. thanks!!!

i found the whole speech on the web. it was from when he addessed the rnc in 2004. i'm sure i'll be able to do something with it. i'll post the link on here when i get finished with it.

thanks a lot!!!!!!!!

the only bad part is now i have to listen to it....

[Mz Pip]

2. I like it

Maybe consider adding a Rudy voiceover comment before the "We don't need another one."

It looks very professional. :thumbsup:

Mz Pip
:dem:

[mrdemocrat78]

3. i tried to find one

i spent hours tying to find something to download, but came up empty.

I'm looking for obama audio too and not finding much

[pacalo]

11. YouTube should have lots of video: rudy guiliani + lies.

[mrdemocrat78]

12. yeah, but you can't download their videos

but like i said i found his rnc speech, and i found a good part. about to post new one on youtube, will post here when it's done

[pacalo]

17. You've done an excellent job, mrdemocrat! I want to see it when you're done. :)

[mrdemocrat78]

18. thanks

i uploaded it to youtube over an hour ago, and it's still not live
i will post it here as soon as it's live

[Johnny Noshoes]

22. You CAN download most videos from YouTube

by using FireFox. I can't say for sure if it works EVERY time but it has most times so far for me. I convert them to watch on a Video Ipod.

[pacalo]

10. I totally agree.

It looks professional but it needs a Rudy comment.

Good job.

[tblue37]

8. There are some Repubs and Independents who favor Giuliani

specifically because they think he is different from all those other socially conservative Republicans, and in fact he is using that supposed difference as his selling point. Those people might think this ad is pro-Giuliani. That last frame might not even register as meaning he would be just like them. You need to tie him more strongly to their lies and corruption. Maybe you could show him supporting Bernard Kerik for Homeland Security chief.

Or maybe use a shot of newspaper headilines connecting Rudy to Kerik and Kerik to the mob, and/or Rudy to the cardinal, his close boyhood friend who was instrumental in covering up child molestation by priests--and even accused of being a molester himself. Rudy has very close ties to people with proven corrupt character.

[123abawd]

13. Looks great!

has msnbc posted it yet?

[mrdemocrat78]

15. no, not yet

[The Wizard]

23. Hi, I'm Rudy Giuliani

and I haven't fucked my cousin in years.

[Bennyboy]

14. I think you missed it...

You should have incldued Rudy saying "thank God our President is George W Bush".

[mrdemocrat78]

16. yeah, i got it

i am just waiting on youtube to go live with it
i have him saying it at the beginning
and then at the end

[girl_interrupted]

19. Think this video on rawstory might help you

WNBC catches Giuliani getting 'tripped up' by 9/11 activist


http://rawstory.com/news/2007/Video_tribute_to_Giuliani_911_lies_0530.html
they even added a song to it "Lies"

Also Video put out by Firefighters (IAFF) http://www.rudy-urbanlegend.com/

Also excellent article on Rudy "Giuliani's mayoral record is complicated " and his claim to having "cleaned up" New York Versus the Police Chief William Bratton, who really deserved the credit, whom Rudy Fired and replaced with that slug Bernard Kerik. http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20070721/ap_on_el_pr/giuliani_mayoral_record_4;_ylt=An8v61DqCM7gv_tnNWvWbpNh24cA

Really liked your video!

[Bennyboy]

20. Good.

That is dammning for sure....

[NewJeffCT]

21. You need some of Rudy's words - maybe the one where he thanks god George W. Bush is prez?

or something else.

[Augdog20]

24. Don't forget the "Urban Legend" video & IAFF is not Democratic

(1) Don't forget: Rudy Giuliani had terrible leadership on 9/11.
See the whole dirty truth in the IAFF's "Urban Legend" video:

http://www.rudy-urbanlegend.com/

(2) Don't believe the Hannity etc smear that the IAFF firefighters' union is Democratic. It has endorsed plenty of Repugs.
Here's the non-partisan Reality of the IAFF, from wikipedia:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Association_of_Fire_Fighters

While the IAFF endorsed John F. Kerry for president in 2004, it has endorsed several Republicans. It endorsed the successful gubernatorial candidacies of Charlie Crist (Florida) and Jim Douglas (Vermont), and it endorsed several Republican candidates for the U.S. House and Senate. Examples of the IAFF's endorsement of Republican incumbents in 2006 include Representatives Curt Weldon (Pennsylvania) and John Sweeney (New York).