NYT Editorial: The Wrong Balance on Civil Liberties & Misuse of "National Security Letters"

[The Cleaner]

Following the dastardly attacks of 9/11, it was evident that the nation had to do some careful thinking about the proper balance between national security and civil liberties. Instead of care and balance, sadly, the Bush administration immediately lunged to claim extraordinary, and largely unnecessary, new powers. Aided by a compliant Congress, the administration repeatedly tried to shield the resulting intrusions on people’s rights from meaningful scrutiny, even by the courts.

Recently, however, a federal district judge in New York declared unconstitutional one notorious outgrowth of the Bush team’s approach: the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s overreliance on informal demands for information, called national security letters, to obtain private records from telephone and Internet companies, banks and other businesses without a court warrant.

The decision by Judge Victor Marrero struck down 2006 revisions to the Patriot Act that expanded the bureau’s power to use national security letters, and a 1986 law that first authorized such letters. The recent provisions not only compelled companies to turn over customers’ records without a warrant, but forbade them to tell anyone what they had done, including the customers involved. The authority of the courts to review challenges to the gag rule was extremely limited.

Judge Marrero took proper umbrage at the attempt to tightly confine the courts’ authority and to silence recipients of national security letters without meaningful judicial review. He declared that the measure violated both the First Amendment and the principle of separation of powers. The deference that the law required courts to give to the executive branch, he stated, could amount to “the hijacking of constitutional values.”

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/16/opinion/16sun3.html?_r=1&th&emc=th&oref=slogin

[indepat]

1. 9-11 gave junior much more than his trifecta: it gave him his excuse to shred

much of the Constitution and thereby make a mockery out of any utterances from the administration about freedom, liberty, or justice. And tens of millions of Amurikans eat it up, most of the MSM shill, and the compliant Congress rubber-stamps in violation of their individual oaths of office which raises the specter of the system being too corrupted to be fixed.