The Ruling:
http://media.nbclocalmedia.com/documents/Valley+Swim+Club+Ruling+Press_Statement_9_22_2009.pdfRace was a factor in the banning of 56 minority students from the Valley Swim Club in late June, according to the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission (PHRC).
The state board ruled late Tuesday there was probable cause that the private Huntington Valley, Pa. organization "refused and denied" the campers' ability to use the facilities "due to the child's race."
-----
In a 33-page affidavit, the commission details a previously unknown confrontation between a woman who made racial comments about the children and the camp's director.
Club member Michelle Flynn and Creative Steps director Alethea Wright had a heated argument after Flynn asked another club member "What are all of these black kids doing here?" She continued: "I am scared they might do something to my child and they might steal some of my stuff," according to documents.
Flynn and Deborah Mindel, both elementary school teachers, said she knew several of the children from her school and alleged that one had stolen a cell phone before. The PHRC found no evidence that the incident had previously occurred at the school, according to Mildenberg.
http://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/breaking/State-Rules-Swim-Clubs-Actions-Were-Racially-Motivated-60455437.htmlIn one e-mail to another Valley Club official, board member George Whitehill wrote, "Race is an issue since every e-mail of complaint mentioned race, although stating that, race had nothing to do with the complaint. It only takes one out of the 120 parents to make this an issue, and at no cost to them."
The Human Relations Commission report said the club had 155 paid membership in 2009 and 179 in 2008, none held by an African-American.
Additionally, the report noted that when Valley Club tried in 2009 to expand its membership by recruiting in areas outside its township - Lower Moreland, which has a 0.8 percent black population - mailouts were "mainly directed at areas with overwhelmingly Caucasian populations" including Rhawnhurst, Fox Chase and Churchville.
The more-diverse townships of Cheltenham and Abington, like other nearby areas with "significant African-American populations," the report says, were passed over.
http://www.philly.com/philly/news/breaking/20090922_State_rules_Montco_pool_discriminated_by_banning_campers.html