I respect people on both sides of this debate

[many a good man]

There are compelling reasons to be both pro- and anti-surge.

There's no doubt the world can't let Pakistan fall to the evil maniacs. It sure would be nice if the U.S. of A. could become known for helping people instead of killing them...

[C_Lawyer09]

1. A 1,000 times thank you

For acknowledging that this argument, while extremely polarizing is not a simple argument.

[many a good man]

2. I wish immediate withdrawal was no-brainer right answer

If it were I think Obama would have chosen it.

Unfortunately our post-WWII track record inspires nothing but pessimism. That's the problem. We all wish we could feel proud for country. I've been waiting all my life.

[C_Lawyer09]

3. So do I, So do I

You're a good guy

[mzmolly]

4. I feel the same. Though I think we'd be better off leaving ASAP.

At least we have some kind of plan to get the H out.