In Jury Selection for Hate Crime, a Struggle to Find Tolerance (Marcelo Lucero case)

[alp227]

by Manny Fernandez, NY Times

RIVERHEAD, N.Y. — Over the last several days, Justice Robert W. Doyle has heard the typical excuses from potential jurors. One woman mentioned her husband’s medical problems. Another woman complained about her back.

But other prospective jurors, seeking to be excused, have brought up larger issues in the judge’s Long Island courtroom.

A young woman said that her father, a mechanic, has a “huge opinion about illegal immigration,” and that his views on the subject have “become my opinions as well.” A man told Justice Doyle that his house was broken into by illegal immigrants while he was sleeping, a fact that he said would affect his ability to be fair and impartial.

And there were those who took a different view, like the bank worker who said that because her husband is of Mexican and Italian descent, she might have difficulty being fair. And the woman who explained that most of the clients in her job are illegal Latino immigrants.

“I don’t think that because of that they should be killed,” she told Justice Doyle.

The prospective jurors were being asked to sit in judgment in the case involving the killing of Marcelo Lucero, a 37-year-old Ecuadorean immigrant stabbed to death in November 2008 in Patchogue, more than an hour’s drive from Manhattan.

Mr. Lucero was attacked by seven teenagers who, the police said, had made a sport out of assaulting Hispanic men, calling it “beaner hopping.” Mr. Lucero’s death prompted widespread outrage and exposed racial tensions in Patchogue, where a number of Latinos came forward after the attack to describe muggings and assaults that had them living in fear.

Read more: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/09/nyregion/09patchogue.html?partner=rss&emc=rss&pagewanted=all

(sigh) It's gonna be a long long lonnng road to find a bunch of fair-minded citizens to deliver justice. The NY Supreme Court obviously can't allow "they took our jobs" types or Minutemen or people who have extreme empathy with illegal immigrants. I sure hope that the prosecutors in this case will work as hard as they can to put away the people behind this senseless (and racist of course) killing. Oh yeah, the president signed a hate crimes bill last year; let's see if that can do any good.

[ProgressiveProfessor]

1. Have to wonder about those who feel that way but are not speaking up

It only takes one to hang a jury...