Krugman: Temporary Tax Cuts For The Rich? No.

[ProSense]

Temporary Tax Cuts For The Rich? No.

Greg Sargent notes the growing number of Republicans suggesting a “compromise” in the form of temporary extension of high-end tax breaks, and urges Democrats not to take the bait. His argument is essentially political: Republicans are obviously aware that they’re in a fix, and Democrats shouldn’t help them out.

But there are reasons beyond partisan maneuvering to reject any deal here.

First, temporary tax breaks for the rich are stunningly bad economic policy. As I tried to explain, basic economic theory — Milton Friedman’s theory! — tells us that affluent taxpayers are likely to save the great bulk of a transitory tax break. And bear in mind that while a 2-year extension wouldn’t increase debt as much as a permanent extension, it would still be much more expensive than measures like aid to the unemployed and to small businesses that would do far more for the economy, yet spent months held up in Congress because of alleged concerns about the deficit.

Second, this is obviously — obviously — a setup. The whole point is to avoid a vote on the middle-class tax cuts while Democrats control the House; when and if Republicans regain control, they can refuse to let anything but a full extension reach the floor. So the goal is actually permanent extension; what they’re offering isn’t a compromise, it’s a trap.

So just say no.

[madinmaryland]

1. Paul Krugman has been absolutely correct in all of his predictions of what

will happen.

[golfguru]

2. Marginal Tax rates Vs. Unemployment in various countries

Country, Tax rate, Unemployment

High Tax Countries
------------------
Belgium 55% 9%
Germany 52% 7%
France 50% 10%
Hungary 49% 10%
Sweden 48% 9%
Italy 46% 9%

Low Tax Countries
-----------------
S.Korea 17% 3.7%
Mexico 18% 5.5%
New Zealand 20% 7%
Japan 27% 5%
Australia 28% 5%
Switzerland 29% 4%

[damonm]

3. Admiral Ackbar says:

[Phx_Dem]

5. LOL!

[Phx_Dem]

4. They've had more than their share of tax cuts over the past 10 years with

and the economy got nothing in return except a huge recession. They can sit on on their embarrassingly huge bonuses and cry like babies. Fuck 'em.