Trumka (AFL-CIO President): Senate Bill As Is Will Die In The House

[depakid]

The head of the most powerful union group in the country said on Thursday that the Senate version of the health care bill will not survive a vote in the House without substantial changes.

Richard Trumka, president of the AFL-CIO, told the Huffington Post that both he and his members are "extremely disappointed" with the compromises conservative Democrats extracted from Senate leaders. Rather than formally opposing the bill, he expressed confidence that it will change before passage

"If the Senate bill in its current form went to the House it would go down," he declared. "I can tell you this," he added. "The plan as it currently is would not get much support from the American worker unless it is improved.

"So that is another line they are going to have to deal with. Speaker Pelosi I think will adequately represent everybody involved. And I think that is a better model for a bill."

In separate statements on Thursday, both Trumka and SEIU President Andy Stern expressed similar concerns with the Senate bill: That without a public option for insurance, and with a provision that taxes high-end health care plans that cover many union members, the bill doesn't create enough competition and lacks an equitable source of revenue.

There is a growing private consensus among union officials that they will have to give up hopes of expanded government-run insurance (if they haven't already) in exchange for replacing the Senate's revenue provisions with the one adopted by the House -- which relies on increasing taxes on the wealthy.

"A progressive tax structure is very, very important," said Trumka. "But so is a public option. And I'm not willing to negotiate right now and jettison any one of those because I think they are both important items. "I'm not willing to declare dead," he added.

Asked about the seeming willingness of progressive Democratic Senators Russ Feingold (Wisc.), Tom Harkin (Iowa) and Sherrod Brown (Ohio) to do just that, Trumka replied: "So what? So what?.... What are they saying in the House? Nancy Pelosi isn't saying this is dead, that's dead? Everything is dead? Has the House said that? No. There are two chambers involved here.... What I'm saying is we are not ready to stop fighting and we are going to improve this bill because it is inadequate as presently constituted."

Trumka repeatedly stressed that the union community is unwilling to take the consider the Senate bill a done deal. He noted that, as a union leader in the coal mines, he once got President George H.W. Bush to sign into law a health care package for his members. He also referenced his beloved Pittsburgh Steelers and Franco Harris's "Immaculate Reception" as a means of underscoring that the unexpected, last minute victory isn't necessarily impossible.

More: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/12/17/trumka-senate-bill-as-is_n_396542.html

[roguevalley]

1. give me union people any day. I was one for my whole working life-

NEA, AFT, Teamsters, Bartenders and Restaurant workers union and AFSCME. IBEW and others are in my family. Go, Trumka. Make them change or pay.

[Ildem09]

2. Im SEIU

Andy Stern is a badass too. I worked with the Purple Crew on health care reform in Southern Indiana this summer

[Bullet1987]

3. Let's wait for the cheerleaders to come in and

throw unions under the bus now. I wish more unions would come out against the Bill. It's sad to see people like Kerry shill for it not too though. Democrats don't know the division they're causing within the Party over this.

[ProSense]

4. "throw unions under the bus now"

You mean the way people threw them under a bus for opposing the Wyden bill?

[Ildem09]

5. some people

just dont like the fact that Labor Unions are the true backbone of the Democratic Party. No unions no Democratic Victory simple as that

[levander]

6. Yes, exactly that way!

.