General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsShow of hands, how many adults here enjoy comics...
... and at the same time are well adjusted, progressive and relatively intelligent?
This is in reference to the silly Bill Maher statement and the associated thread here.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=11442370
sfwriter
(3,032 posts)And I enjoy Maher.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)but don't always agree with him. Nor should we. It's not like he is a voice for liberals. He's a comedian and often has worthwhile things to say.
TheBlackAdder
(28,193 posts)no_hypocrisy
(46,101 posts)It bolstered my reading ability and I loved the artwork. I graduated from Dennis the Menace to Superman to Creepy to Mad Magazine.
I still am pissed at my father for making me throw them out.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)the love of reading.
murielm99
(30,739 posts)with low reading ability. It kept them engaged and it worked.
Later, I tried it as a literacy volunteer. It worked with the right sort of student.
I read comics all the way through grad school, and into my late twenties. I did it as an escape.
I haven't read any comics lately. Maybe I should.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)and not just super hero stuff.
LakeArenal
(28,817 posts)If that extends further in their life great.
Just keep reading.
WhiskeyGrinder
(22,337 posts)Captain Stern
(2,201 posts)Seems to me, maybe Mr Maher should step back, and make sure he's as self-aware as he thinks he is.
There are more than a few people that feel exactly the same way about television that he feels about comic books.
Also, they guy intentionally had sex with Ann Coulter.....Nuff Said.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)Dipped in Clorox concentrate.
Stargazer09
(2,132 posts)Yuck. No. Shes so hateful! Why would anyone willingly do that? (Rhetorical question. I really dont want to know.)
obamanut2012
(26,076 posts)Not just, oh, not my thing, but really snarky and judgemental.
jcgoldie
(11,631 posts)This needed a second thread.
meadowlander
(4,395 posts)If you're not interested in the thread, don't post in it.
jcgoldie
(11,631 posts)Bill Maher gives a voice at times to some pretty shitty characters like milo yiannopoulos because he's stuck on his political incorrectness thing... for that sort of thing he deserves pretty scathing critisism in my opinion. He's also a pretty strong progressive voice on some issues and reaches a lot of people. I think crying because he made fun of adults reading comic books sort of reinforces his point.
meadowlander
(4,395 posts)And I'm sorry but Stan Lee was a stronger progressive voice than Bill Maher will ever be and reached a far larger audience. XMen sold over 270 million copies and that doesn't include the audiences for the films. Real Time has an audience of about 2 million. Stan Lee was writing comic books about inclusion, tolerance and the dangers of fascism back in the 60s when Bill Maher was still a snot-nosed kid trying to get a peek up the hot teacher's skirt.
To attack Stan Lee and his fans on the occasion of his death with some poorly reasoned, easily disproven bullshit linking comic book enthusiasm with the decline in reading habits and the election of Trump is irresponsible dickishness and absolutely Maher deserves to be called out on it with as many threads as DU sees fit.
At least Maher is doing it for the publicity. What's your excuse for defending him?
lunatica
(53,410 posts)Im 70 years old and a college graduate who has read the classics. I am bilingual having lived in another country as an American citizen for over 25 years. I appreciate the subtle differences in the two distinct cultures I was brought up in and I consider myself a world citizen and I know the cultural importance of comic books in countries where illiteracy is high. I also know how important
it is to read something youre interested in and how it helps your literacy abilities. I was happy when my kids read comic books.
And Stan Lee ALWAYS preached and promoted the highest human qualities and the noblest ones too. Super heroes were always the good guys. Always.
lunatica
(53,410 posts)Thats pretty evident.
Do you feel superior now?
jcgoldie
(11,631 posts)What in the hell are you talking about? I had no idea what a sensitive issue this was obviously. Enjoy.
treestar
(82,383 posts)And it got people disagreeing but that is not vilification.
treestar
(82,383 posts)In posting multiple thread that gets others to complain about it.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)was in reaction to the DUers who agreed with Maher about comic readers somehow having stunted mental growth.
obamanut2012
(26,076 posts)Iggo
(47,552 posts)shanti
(21,675 posts)but not superheroes. i liked richie rich, little audrey, wendy, little dot, little lotta, archie and veronica, etc. as a young kid/tween. i didn't collect them though. But I was/still am an inveterate reader of everything.
Bill Maher's remarks about comics didn't bother me, but his slagging off of the couple with the rare facial deformity (moebius syndrome) did. He didn't get a lot of positive response for it either.
meadowlander
(4,395 posts)I'm not a huge comic book fan but I can appreciate what Stan Lee has done for the progressive zeitgeist. I do also like video games, fantasy novels, Star Trek and lots of other things that the self-righteous of the world might decide are not sufficiently "grown up"... while they piss their time away drinking, watching sports, shopping for useless crap, recreational grooming and complaining about their terrible relationships.
Also have two masters degrees, a good job and read at least a book a week.
nolabear
(41,963 posts)I dont say that to say how cool I am but those professions both respect comics a great deal. Comics are archetypal stories. I learned about a lot of kids via hearing about their comic book heroes. Adults too sometimes. As numerous people have said about Stan Lee, he made the weird kids feel special. That was Marvels genius. It was about people. Good stories are about people.
And as I said about Bill Maher, Sometimes the enemy of my enemy is a dick.
brettdale
(12,381 posts)CALVIN AND HOBBES
Beartracks
(12,814 posts)=======
Hekate
(90,681 posts)Blue Owl
(50,362 posts)And don't have any problem with those who make a hobby out of reading/collecting/creating them.
They're pretty much an art-meets-literature form IMHO.
Chill out, Bill Maher -- no need to make this political! If you don't like 'em, then don't read 'em...
Rizen
(708 posts)they must be a bad influence :p
Javaman
(62,530 posts)I post Monday thru Friday. Come on over and have fun!
BTW I'm 55
edhopper
(33,579 posts)Didn't know we had one.
JHB
(37,160 posts)...but yes.
blueinredohio
(6,797 posts)First Speaker
(4,858 posts)...and as a kid, Stan Lee saved my sanity more than once. He was the one adult who really understood me. I finally gave up Marvel because I felt they were, and are, deliberately trying to alienate their old fans, and I felt disrespected. But I still read things like Maus, and From Hell, and Watchmen...
edhopper
(33,579 posts)Marvel and DC a while ago too. Having grown up on them like you.
But there is still a lot excellent graphic literature out there.
Miles Archer
(18,837 posts)I read all of the John Byrne stuff, but it hasn't aged well. Plus, in "real life," Byrne is beyond curmudgeonly and insensitive (he shared some thoughts on Christopher Reeve's passing that I won't share here).
But Jim Lee, and all of his clones, pretty much killed off my interest in Marvel. I enjoyed Lee's work initially...some pretty amazing stuff...but when everyone adopted that style, it bored the hell out of me.
I was "in" from Fantastic Four #1 onward. My favorite artists were Jack Kirby, Steve Ditko, John Buscema, and Gene Colan.
Once those artists started backing off and Marvel became the house of Byrne and Lee, I'd had enough.
But I still love the old books. I have 1731 digital comics on my laptop...pretty much all of the favorites I named above.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)I agree with you about the older marvel artist. But now there are many worthwhile non-superhero comics being published.
Crutchez_CuiBono
(7,725 posts)play'd in Americana. Got to be in the mood for one. Older ones are preferred.
at140
(6,110 posts)That was many moons ago, I think the series I liked was called Jiggs?
Going back to middle school years I loved peter pan & roy rogers comics.
Now as a senior, I do not read comics.
elleng
(130,895 posts)but a good friend with a very bright little boy allowed him to 'read' comics when before he'd been TAUGHT to read, and he taught himself, with COMICS! (This 35+ years ago.)
Dorian Gray
(13,493 posts)believe of all this shit Maher says, this is what makes people lose their shit.
I've read some graphic novels. It's not a regular thing. I can enjoy them, but I'm not passionate about them.
Wintryjade
(814 posts)Jarqui
(10,125 posts)I've had little interest in reading them in decades.
I enjoyed some of the movies that came from comic books.
My interests were elsewhere.
Trying to link comic book reading to some grade of politics is a bizarre leap.
It is an outlet. So is golf, romance books, astronomy, gardening, music, art, etc, etc.
I've enjoyed the odd Maher 'new rule' or joke but this commentary of his is off the mark.
pdxflyboy
(675 posts)Petosky Stone
(52 posts)after Bill Watterson quit contributing.
Wellstone ruled
(34,661 posts)pre 1955. Wow,kid brother said I had about a thousand,every Cowboy and Cartoon Character known at the time. Used to trade the Kids in my small town,when you trade one new one for ten already read ones,what a deal. Kid Brother gave all of these Comics to the School Library in the early sixties.
Hekate
(90,681 posts)Have not yet picked up John Lewis' books about the civil rights era. We also have Doonesbury 40th Anniversary and the Calvin & Hobbes collection 3 volume collection in hardcover.
Sometimes the combination of art and text deepens the experience enormously.
I have not warmed to either Neil Gaiman's Sandman nor Jim Butcher's Dresden Files. I am a fan of Gaiman's books in text form -- same with the Dresden Files.
I used to like 10c comics when I was a little kid, but a dime was a lot of money at that age, so I read the neighbor-kid's stash. MAD was transgressive and fun, throwing in enough adult references to keep me engaged. When I moved on it was to science fiction written for adults. I was an early and fluent reader -- all comic books were certainly more engaging than Dick and Jane, which bored me to tears.
As an adult I have met several people who came to the US as kids who spoke no English, but instead French, Dutch, or Spanish, and they all credited comic books and afternoon cartoons for their ability to learn English quickly and fluently. All college grads, like me.
JHan
(10,173 posts)Hekate
(90,681 posts)Coventina
(27,119 posts)Bill Maher is a pseudo intellectual trying to sound smart.
Fail.
JHan
(10,173 posts)Thomas Hurt
(13,903 posts)but I am not a fan that collects.
Maher is being a d*ck.
Different Drummer
(7,615 posts)haele
(12,653 posts)Well written comic books can use both art and words to express emotions, as well as the standard tropes to be found in every good bit of literature out there.
For many people who are more visually oriented, comic books can be as mentally expansive as any classic story out there.
Haele
SeattleVet
(5,477 posts)Grew up on Mad, Sick, Cracked, Crazy, CarToons, SurfToons. Eventually graduated to the National Lampoon,The Realist, and a few others.
Wound up with a pretty good collection of Fritz the Cat, The Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers, Zap!, Bijou, and even Howard the Duck (man, talk about something *subversive*!!!)
These were the influences that shaped my rather warped sense of reality...which, in this age of tRump, turns out to be a pretty good place to live!
Iggo
(47,552 posts)yardwork
(61,608 posts)My first comic book was Wonder Woman. My mother bought it for me when I was four. We were in the train station in Chicago in the middle of the night. It was snowing. I couldn't read it but it was a comfort and diversion on a scary night.
Bill Maher is an ass. That is all.
Cha
(297,211 posts)That's quite a memory you have of your first comic book, Wonder Woman!
Netflix has 2 seasons of "Riverdale" available.. it's based on the Archie series. It's quite good.. according to me.
So I still enjoy it only on the screen these days.
yardwork
monmouth4
(9,700 posts)yardwork
(61,608 posts)I've seen them twice.. waiting for the 3rd season.
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Cha
(297,211 posts)If you have Netflix and the time.. you should check out the series "Riverdale".. it's well written and it has Archie, Betty and Veronica!
lunamagica
(9,967 posts)Adrahil
(13,340 posts)Love the Sandman books by Gaiman.
I admit to reading a lot of Star Wars comics (Star Wars is MY childish thing)
But not into the superhero genre, really.
I'm a 52 year old married with kid systems engineer with a Masters degree so I seem to be "adulting" just fine.
And ya know what? I still play D&D occasionally. Of the 7 players, 4 have PhD's, 2 have Masters, and one a BS. All gainfully employed with families and own our own homes. HOW do we do it??
I have no patience for snobs.
Dyedinthewoolliberal
(15,574 posts)phleshdef
(11,936 posts)marlakay
(11,465 posts)TDale313
(7,820 posts)And yes, I am an adult who enjoys comics.
exboyfil
(17,863 posts)I collected them with my dad. I don't collect anymore, but I still read through the library. My daughter doesn't read them, but she enjoys seeing the movies with me. I just gave my nephew 10 bankers boxes of 70s and 80s comics. I probably could have made some cash on them, but he likes to read them, and it is like handing off a legacy. I am 55. An engineer with 2 Masters degrees, and I read about 8 fiction and two non-fiction books a month.
Brother Buzz
(36,427 posts)I went straight form Mad Magazine to underground comix, and never really got into the conventional comic scene.
R Crumb was the bomb.
Oh, when I was stationed overseas, I discovered Asterix. I hoofed it down to an English bookstore every month to purchase the next installment.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)especially since it emerges from the great EC legacy.
And European comics are great as well.
We are talking about graphic story telling, not just Marvel and DC superheroes.
Stargazer09
(2,132 posts)Comics are fun to read. Im not obsessed, but Ill buy a series if the story is good.
My dyslexic daughter discovered that reading comic books is fun, and that helped her decide that reading real books can be worth the effort. Im definitely grateful for that.
betsuni
(25,519 posts)So what. I live in Japan and I HATE manga and animation. Hate it. Guess I'm an asshole too, because I have an opinion.
JonLP24
(29,322 posts)Personally it doesn't even crack the list of top 25 worst things Maher has said.
If he said comic books are kid stuff and left it alone would be one thing but he goes on to blame it on society's ills and Trump on comics. A lot of people compared him to
betsuni
(25,519 posts)This is true.
JonLP24
(29,322 posts)I dont think its a huge stretch to suggest that Donald Trump could only get elected in a country that thinks comic books are important.
You mention Japan I hear comic books are important. So US and Japan are the only 2 countries Trump could get elected because of comic books? If he left out that last line it would still be a silly OP-ed but inserting Trump into his point made a huge hole in his logic.
Besides he was picking on some poor person's reddit post that was expressing their favorable opinion of Stan Lee.
Edit: the post I'm responding to here originally said this "How does he blame society's ills and Trump on comics?"
Japan is ruled by conservatives, the LDP, and it has nothing to do with manga. What are you even talking about?
JonLP24
(29,322 posts)I dont think its a huge stretch to suggest that Donald Trump could only get elected in a country that thinks comic books are important.
Comic books are important in Japan right? Maher thinks Trump can only get elected in a country that thinks comic books are important. Are comic books important in Japan? Could Trump get elected in Japan?
If you don't understand what I'm talking about it is because Im using Maher's logic.
Maybe Trump ruling the US has nothing to do with comic books.
treestar
(82,383 posts)Americans is debatable. The relationship to the election of an idiot to the presidency is laughable.
yardwork
(61,608 posts)There's a lot more than manga. Read Maus, for instance.
Mad magazine just ran a devastatingly on-target strip about school shootings.
Howard Zinn published a comics version of his History of the U.S., making important historical facts that are usually whitewashed in schools highly accessible to many readers who would not have read his entire book.
And Maher's remarks were in the context of disrespecting somebody who had just died.
phleshdef
(11,936 posts)treestar
(82,383 posts)Vs an opinion on people. You did not judge the people who like them with your statement.
Bill Maher will live. He knows he stirred up shit and loves it.
But if you said those that do read and like them are mentally stunted you would be.
(I know you are not saying that, but Maher did)
meadowlander
(4,395 posts)Also bringing it up in response to someone dying.
cagefreesoylentgreen
(838 posts)Wendy Pinis ElfQuest helped me through a dark time when I was struggling with my sexuality and gender, with its message of inclusion and acceptance.
From there I discovered comics like Hellblazer, Sandman, and Transmetrpolitan, and a few other titles that didnt use LGBT people for cheap laughs. That was less common than you think in the 80s and 90s.
I still read comics, but I dont have time or physical space to deal with long boxes. I get them all digitally on my Kindle.
MurrayDelph
(5,294 posts)during the protest against child detention, I stood next to Wendy Pini (Well, she stood; I was on a scooter,).
I not only read comics, I'm friends with many of their creators. I attended the funerals of Jack Kirby and Len Wein (even though by then, I'd moved over 1000 miles away from L.A., and my wife add I had to drive 1000 miles overnight to attend).
Some of this shit from Maher reminds me of when Johnny Carson did a week-long bit about 3D, which culminated in Johnny coming onstage wearing 3D glasses. At the desk, Johnny looked at the glasses he'd been given, which were a promo for a 3D comic Jack Kirby had produced. They used the phrase "Jack Kirby: King of the Comics." Well, as far as Carson as concerned he was King of the Comics. So Johnny launched into a tirade "'Jack Kirby: King of the Comics'? They should call him King of the Con-men" and proceeded to use the phrase "Jack Kirby: King of the "Con -men" several times that show.
(He apologized profusely on his next show after being corrected).
Bill Maher can be funny at times, but also has a long history of bad-mouthing those who disagree with him. I stopped watching because I got tired of his "all religions are bad but Islam is especially evil" shtick. If someone wants to believe for their own purposes, I don't care, as long as they don't make me follow their views (which also applies to Maher's militant atheism).
If I want to enjoy comics, and miss Stan, Jack, and my friend Len (whose death not only "broke" the Internet, it "swamped" Forest Lawn, who didn't have enough room for all the cars), who does it hurt? These men all helped bring light and joy into the world, which will never be said about Maher.
cagefreesoylentgreen
(838 posts)His Asian jokes arent jokes, and whitesplaining them is not in any way helpful. Hes a part of those would get outraged over similar jokes directed at blacks and Hispanics, but Asians are fair game.
Im Chinese American, fwiw.
JustABozoOnThisBus
(23,340 posts)Does that mean I'm less well-adjusted, progressive, and relatively intelligent? I think I'm still progressive.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)without reading comics as well. But it helps.
obamanut2012
(26,076 posts)I still read them, and very much other forms of media stemming from comics/graphic novels.
malaise
(268,994 posts)Back in the 70's a cousin's wife (who was an academic in a Communications' Institute) gave me a book written by two Chileans called How to Read Donald Duck. It changed my thinking. I always hated Tarzan, but as someone in a developing country I became more aware at the subtle and not so subtle messages.
I read the comics with purpose after that and found Stan Lee's characters refreshingly progressive.
Maher is an insensitive moron. I rarely watch his show.
Maeve
(42,282 posts)It's the movies, too. I haven't picked up a comic in years, but I've seen all the Marvel and most of the DC movies, watching for Stan Lee's cameo in the Marvel ones (will miss him) and hitting the superhero section at Universal parks....
No one is going to make a ride dedicated to the Bill Maher experience, I'll tell you that
cwydro
(51,308 posts)Even as a child, I preferred books.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)it's fine if you don't want to read them. But to consider them something to "outgrow" diminished the medium.
There are many comics and graphic novels that are not geared to young people and as fully adult in their content as other media.
treestar
(82,383 posts)But can enjoy them. I read kids books that kids in my family read. I read several mangas that my nieces had a couple weekends ago.
peekaloo
(22,977 posts)Bill Maher likes being a dick. He enjoys getting a rise out of people.
elocs
(22,574 posts)When Spiderman and the Fantastic Four came out, that was in the heyday of my comic book collecting. I'm sure I once had the first Spiderman comic but sometime in my teen years all of my comics disappeared. Thanks mom!
ismnotwasm
(41,979 posts)Not a superfan, but I love Hellblazer Sandman Bitch Saga and of course, Preacher I tend to like comics with a beginning and end, so Im planning on reading Black Panther. A few others. The worlds of superheroes makes me feel like Id have to start at the beginning so I actually did this with Swamp Thing, didnt get too far though.
Suggestions welcome
cagefreesoylentgreen
(838 posts)FX is currently filming a live-action adaptation with Bryan K. Vaughn directly involved. If you liked Saga, you may like Vaughns earlier work in Y.
ismnotwasm
(41,979 posts)There are so many to choose from, and as a relative late comer I get a little lost
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)... so I can certainly see how "comics" would be enjoyable by adults.
Is Bill Maher under some impression that all "comics" are the same as Richie Rich, or Archie and Jughead?
ProudLib72
(17,984 posts)The series loosely follows the doings of a single cell of The Invisible College, a secret organization battling against physical and psychic oppression using time travel, magic, meditation, and physical violence.[2]
For most of the series, the team includes leader King Mob; Lord Fanny, a transgender Brazilian shaman; Boy, a former member of the NYPD; Ragged Robin, a telepath with a mysterious past; and Jack Frost, a young hooligan from Liverpool who may be the next Buddha. Their enemies are the Archons of the Outer Church, interdimensional alien gods who have already enslaved most of the human race without their knowledge.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Invisibles
Devil Child
(2,728 posts)Hoyt
(54,770 posts)Iggo
(47,552 posts)I loved Mad Magazine. And basically, that was back when I enjoyed Marvel comics, too.
I don't begrudge anyone for their continued or newfound love of something I thoroughly enjoyed for many years.
eleny
(46,166 posts)mulsh
(2,959 posts)wife and most of our friends. No disputing Stan Lee's importance to the craft, art form, and comics industry.
We are not particular fans of Marvel comics, favoring writers like Neil Gaiman, Warren Ellis, Garth Ennis, Elaine Lee.
There are many great writers and artists out there writing and drawing some amazing "sequential art" to use Will Eisner ( The Spirit and namesake of "the Eisner" award for comics.)
Mr. Mahr is amusing but I've found on subjects such as religion his ignorance is his guiding light. To make the ignorant claim he has made about comics and comic fans reveals how little he knows about this subject. He is not alone.
For many years I tried to get my oldest friend, a college professor, to read The Sandman series by Neil Gaiman. My friend takes an even dimmer, more ignorant view of comics than Bill Mahr. One day a few years ago he called cross country to tell me about a "marvelously inventive writer and his book "Neverwhere" At which point I directed him to the writer's works list and to the listing for Sandman. He's seen the error of his way there but it nearly didn't happen.
LakeSuperiorView
(1,533 posts)That said, I had often wondered why Hollywood hadn't gone with some great stories that had already been story boarded for them. I enjoy the Marvel and DC movies and series. IMO, Marvel has done much better with movies and DC much better with series.
TNLib
(1,819 posts)But I enjoy reading and collecting comics.
Bill Maher can be clueless at times. I think Obama enjoyed comics as well.
edhopper
(33,579 posts)pwb
(11,263 posts)Hotler
(11,421 posts)back in 1969-1970.