General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsSplit-Ticket Voting Hit A New Low In 2018 Senate And Governor Races
We went into Election Day with a hypothesis: Most Americans would cast a straight-ticket ballot with some notable exceptions, which well address in a moment. And we decided a good way to test this was to look at statewide races most likely to drive turnout in a midterm election cycle: U.S. Senate and governor contests.
There were 22 states that had races for both the Senate and governor on the ballot this election cycle. And what we found was the same party swept both offices in 16 of the 21 states where each race has been called1, with Democrats capturing both races in 12 states and Republicans doing so in four. Or, in other words, our hypothesis was mostly right most Americans did vote for the same party in their Senate and governors race. But there were five states Arizona, Maryland, Massachusetts, Ohio and Vermont where voters chose a Republican governor and a Democratic senator.
And while we were interested in what happened in these five states (more in a moment), we also wanted to look at every state that had both a Senate and governor race on the ballot to see just how far apart the voting margins were. The idea was this will help us understand how uncommon or common split-ticket voting was in 2018. And we could then situate what happened in 2018 by looking at previous midterms to see if there was a trend in how much split-ticket voting occurred between these two offices. (Spoiler: Split-ticket voting hit a new low.)
To do this, I calculated the difference between the margin of victory in the Senate and gubernatorial races for each state using the Democratic and Republican vote shares in each contest.2 And as the table below shows, Massachusetts had the biggest difference between its vote share margin in its races for Senate and governor. Republican Gov. Charlie Baker won reelection by about 32 percentage points and Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren garnered a second term with a roughly 26-point margin, producing a gap of 57 points. So, in other words, in hyper-blue Massachusetts roughly 25 to 30 percent of voters cast ballots for both Baker and Warren.3 Two other states, Vermont and Maryland, also had very large differences between their Senate and governor races about 55 and 47 points, respectively. Along with Massachusetts, these races all featured relatively popular incumbent Republican governors Phil Scott in Vermont and Larry Hogan in Maryland running in strongly Democratic states that easily reelected incumbent Democratic senators. The popularity and independent streaks of these GOP governors clearly helped them overcome the sharply Democratic leans of their states.
https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/split-ticket-voting-hit-a-new-low-in-2018-senate-and-governor-races/
GemDigger
(4,305 posts)And there was one republican that spent an hour with me and I told her I would have supported her if . this were any other time.