Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mopinko

(70,268 posts)
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:24 PM Dec 2018

an update on cliffordu, and an appeal to the great du braintrust.

for those who missed previous posts, oldtimer cliffordu was diagnosed earlier this year w als.
he has gone from a strong and vital man to basically a quadriplegic in a few short months. the docs are stunned at the swift decline. the usual course for als is approx 5 years.
the current guess is that he has 3-6 months, tho they have been saying that for 6 months already. nobody really knows.

anyway, i recently visited him for 4 days.
he is in better spirits now that he is out of the va hospital, and into an apartment.
he can talk pretty well, tho he is on mechanical respiratory support that gets in the way. he has an adaptive communications gizmo that allows him to surf the net and type. this took ridiculously long to show up, imho, but he has it now and is feeling much less cut off.

he does still have a lot of muscle mass, unlike other folks that i have seen who are in the final stages of this horror.

being a staunchly honest and self aware person, he is trying to adjust to the idea of letting go of hope. i cant imagine a harder thing for a human to do. even when it is clear that that is the reality.

he has a lot of support from his old friends, many of whom he has gone to great lengths to help through their life struggles. his caregivers are very sweet.

please chime in here w your thoughts and remembrances. he will be reading this.


now for the braintrust thing-
because cliff is a veteran, he is getting va care. it is a presumptive service related disability, even tho he is a viet nam vet and long separated from the service.
this presumption covers all vets, regardless of when and where they served.

according to cliff, 60% of all new cases of als are in vets. their decline is generally much more swift than other victims of this cruel fucking disease.
there are possible explanations for this floating around out there, including that the intense physical activity of service is somehow a trigger. since cliff was quite the buff dude before he became ill, perhaps there is something to this. but studies that i looked at trying to find other populations w similar possible triggers are not conclusive.

here is where the mystery starts making you go hmmmm.

neither cliff nor i have been able to figure out just how the military decided to step up on this.
against a backdrop of the still ongoing fight to cover agent orange disabilities, this seems to have arisen out of the ether.
no lawsuits, no real debate, they just rolled over.

why? how? and what do they know?
as far as i can tell, if they know something, they are not sharing it w the researchers who are racing the clock to find a cure.
tho the va is involved in some drug trials, i have yet to find any research based on any specific knowledge.
if they are sitting on evidence here, that should be a damn crime.

this is a link to the announcement about this. i have found a couple other sources that pretty much just parrot this.
https://fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R41405.pdf

so, dear, amazing du braintrust, please chime in w any info you may have that bears on this.
anything. any little thing.

i will be writing to my senator, the great tammy duckworth, and also john tester.
when i get this written i will post it here so you can share w your electeds, or anyone else that might have info.


and just a word about me, for no real reason.
i have been a hospice volunteer for the last 3 years. i never thought that the things i have learned in this would have such a personal focus, but then we all do or will know someone who is in need of this sort of care.
also, i am inordinately fond of cliff. tho i remember him from his old days here, i did not really interact that much w him. could be cuz i was a mod and he was a good natured lounge troll. lol.
but i found him on fb about a year and a half ago, and have gotten close to him.
as w most of my charges, i find it a privilege to be trusted and allowed into people's lives in these hard circumstances.
i am far away, but will continue to do what i can to support him.

80 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
an update on cliffordu, and an appeal to the great du braintrust. (Original Post) mopinko Dec 2018 OP
My best wishes to Clifford and to you for supporting a friend. LoisB Dec 2018 #1
Hardest thing to do is stay present. It's why meditation focuses on breathing. onit2day Dec 2018 #19
ALS is recognized as military connected per NIH ismnotwasm Dec 2018 #2
I would not be surprised if it was a common secondary cause like alcohol/or drug abuse grantcart Dec 2018 #24
That is so very sad. Alcohol addiction is also terrible. ismnotwasm Dec 2018 #28
Agent Orange DownriverDem Dec 2018 #33
Thanks for the update, mopinko. kcr Dec 2018 #3
Cliffdu tazkcmo Dec 2018 #4
There are lots of chemicals we in the military have been exposed to, heavy metals and petro-based. haele Dec 2018 #5
It was part of the retiree process for my husband - a briefing on ALS. Solly Mack Dec 2018 #6
Please pass on my best wishes to cliffordu! pnwmom Dec 2018 #7
There are several compelling prospective studies that have shown hlthe2b Dec 2018 #8
Best wishes pecosbob Dec 2018 #9
Dear cliffordu lunatica Dec 2018 #10
Mopinko, for you Hekate Dec 2018 #11
Gosh. Sorry to hear that Proud Liberal Dem Dec 2018 #12
It is unlikely the VA could hide a cause of ALS from the global research community jberryhill Dec 2018 #13
thanks for this. mopinko Dec 2018 #70
Please give my regards to Clifford UpInArms Dec 2018 #14
Clifford -- have missed hearing from you here, and am glad you can now at least lurk & maybe more Hekate Dec 2018 #15
Cliffordu, welcome back. Thank you for your service and for sinkingfeeling Dec 2018 #16
Thanks for the update, Mo. Best wishes to Clfford. rurallib Dec 2018 #17
Enjoyed Cliff's posts orangecrush Dec 2018 #18
Clifford had a major event the day after Mopinko's visit grantcart Dec 2018 #20
That had to be terrifying! herding cats Dec 2018 #48
it sounded like water boarding in slow motion. grantcart Dec 2018 #54
Strong, brave cliffordu! Cha Dec 2018 #58
My love goes out to you, Clifford. blogslut Dec 2018 #21
Sorry to hear about cliffordu nahant Dec 2018 #22
Love pouring through to cliffdu backtoblue Dec 2018 #23
.... spanone Dec 2018 #25
Cliffordu, I didn't know you well lillypaddle Dec 2018 #26
I know of two friends who served that died from this rapid onset ALS. mn9driver Dec 2018 #27
yeah, the idea that exercise mopinko Dec 2018 #46
Life is not fair! BlancheSplanchnik Dec 2018 #60
I'm sorry to hear this karin_sj Dec 2018 #29
Clifford, i've Read your posts for years. You're part of our DU community. SharonAnn Dec 2018 #30
All my best to cliffordu! BamaRefugee Dec 2018 #31
I am so very sorry. sprinkleeninow Dec 2018 #32
Sending you hugs, cliffordu. gademocrat7 Dec 2018 #34
All my best Clifordu The Polack MSgt Dec 2018 #35
I'm so sad to hear this. geardaddy Dec 2018 #36
Did a quick search on Bing mgardener Dec 2018 #37
Thank you for this information. H2O Man Dec 2018 #38
I wish Clifford the best ZeroSomeBrains Dec 2018 #39
An interesting article on ALS LiberalArkie Dec 2018 #40
My grandfather had ALS and my mother told me that the hardest BigmanPigman Dec 2018 #41
yup. some cruel shit. mopinko Dec 2018 #45
FWIW Cathy Jordan.. cannabis_flower Dec 2018 #42
'neither cliff nor i have been able to figure out just how the military decided to step up on this' Donkees Dec 2018 #43
the thing is that they are STILL fighting over agent orange, but mopinko Dec 2018 #44
The research links do mention veterans across all conflicts being affected, but the key research .. Donkees Dec 2018 #52
Follow-up to my last post: Donkees Dec 2018 #64
My first offhand thought: Cost of ALS treatment vs Agent Orange Honeycombe8 Dec 2018 #47
They're still researching why ALS presents 2:1 more often in veterans. herding cats Dec 2018 #49
Thank You for that info, herding! Cha Dec 2018 #56
K & R malaise Dec 2018 #50
I'm sorry to learn one of our fellow Du'ers has had such a lousy diagnosis. Vinca Dec 2018 #51
My family has hereditary neuropathies. Potassium and iodine are stripped from most foods now. TheBlackAdder Dec 2018 #53
I always looked forward when Cha Dec 2018 #55
Mahalo, mopinko, for Cha Dec 2018 #57
I'm so sorry. area51 Dec 2018 #59
One of my oldest brothers was a combat Marine in Vietnam. Blue_true Dec 2018 #61
Take care cliffordu. Thank you for bringing forward the als information and discrepancies lunasun Dec 2018 #62
My dad was a vet & I lost him to ALS in 2000. catbyte Dec 2018 #63
Sending a hug to cliffordu democrank Dec 2018 #65
Hello CliffordDU leftofcool Dec 2018 #66
Nam Vet here with some thoughts bluescribbler Dec 2018 #67
Strength & Light to you, cliffordu appal_jack Dec 2018 #68
Best wishes, I miss you here uppityperson Dec 2018 #69
We all had a wide range of vaccinations, we took prophylaxis pills before visiting certain countries Demonaut Dec 2018 #71
You're in my heart, cliffordu. TygrBright Dec 2018 #72
you've probably seen this before - I have no background in this and hope I am diva77 Dec 2018 #73
prolly not. mopinko Dec 2018 #80
Never let go of hope. flvegan Dec 2018 #74
Good vibes sent and thank you for your service, cliffordu! Heartstrings Dec 2018 #75
i am so sorry to hear this sad news orleans Dec 2018 #76
Thanks, mopinko for sharing this information. My best wishes for you both. oasis Dec 2018 #77
I am thinking of you, Clifford, and wishing you peace. Squinch Dec 2018 #78
Hey Cliff, I hope you're having a better day today. If you haven't looked into cannabis, JudyM Dec 2018 #79
 

onit2day

(1,201 posts)
19. Hardest thing to do is stay present. It's why meditation focuses on breathing.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:27 PM
Dec 2018

Breathing is not something you do as much as something you witness but it keeps one present on the here and now. Woody Allen said "...It's not that I'm afraid of death. I just don't want to be there when it happens". Usually we are not conscious when it happens but the fear and acceptance can lead to a barrage of thoughts but it's all in your mind and goes when you stay present. You cannot think when you are focused on your breathing. If only we were brought up this way so it was automatic. Takes practice to stay present and be here now. Hope this brings comfort to your friend. Let go and stay present.

ismnotwasm

(42,020 posts)
2. ALS is recognized as military connected per NIH
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:32 PM
Dec 2018
Some studies suggest that military veterans are about 1.5 to 2 times more likely to develop ALS. Although the reason for this is unclear, possible risk factors for veterans include exposure to lead, pesticides, and other environmental toxins. ALS is recognized as a service-connected disease by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.
.

https://www.ninds.nih.gov/Disorders/Patient-Caregiver-Education/Fact-Sheets/Amyotrophic-Lateral-Sclerosis-ALS-Fact-Sheet

ALS is a horror of a disease. I am sorry to hear about this. Thank you for what you do

grantcart

(53,061 posts)
24. I would not be surprised if it was a common secondary cause like alcohol/or drug abuse
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:36 PM
Dec 2018

As Cliffordu would tell you he had years at the extreme end of alcohol abuse.

It is ironic that the disease would have an impact at a time in his life that he had gotten himself together and was employed in substance abuse treatment centers and spent several hours a day helping people in AA.

ismnotwasm

(42,020 posts)
28. That is so very sad. Alcohol addiction is also terrible.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:44 PM
Dec 2018

Couple it with memories of a horrible war—so devastating.

Younger people are taking more chances with alcohol abuse and subsequent poisoning—-we are seeing more people in their 20’s coming in with fulminate liver failure. There aren’t enough livers to transplant, and far too many people die.

It seems people like Cliffordu are needed more than ever.

DownriverDem

(6,232 posts)
33. Agent Orange
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 04:09 PM
Dec 2018

Storming heaven for him. I lost my brother to lung cancer going to the brain 2 years ago. He was in the Air Force and served in Viet Nam. He worked & rode on the planes that sprayed Agent Orange. After he died my other brother looked into Agent Orange being the cause of his cancer. My sister-in-law applied to the VA regarding his cause of death. She is receiving a monthly benefit, because he falls within the map that the VA has for the Agent Orange service area. Of course she would rather have him back.

kcr

(15,320 posts)
3. Thanks for the update, mopinko.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:33 PM
Dec 2018

I wish I had info to add. If I see anything, I'll contribute. I just wanted to add my message of support for cliffordu

tazkcmo

(7,303 posts)
4. Cliffdu
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:39 PM
Dec 2018

Thank you for all the good you have done for our country and the people whose lives you touched. I hope for your remaining days to be years and filled with happiness.

haele

(12,683 posts)
5. There are lots of chemicals we in the military have been exposed to, heavy metals and petro-based.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:39 PM
Dec 2018

I'm semi disabled myself from exposure to chemicals and the heavy work I used to do, and not looking forward to what I'm going to become over the next ten years. I'm already feeling the damage to nerves in my extremities. But since most of the damage that is occurring is creating a "not sure if it was while you were in the military, or maybe when you worked in the shipyards" dilemma, I'm probably not going to get any help from either the VA or Worker's Compensation.

Single payer would take care of this.

Best wishes to Cliffordu, it's a painful disease - and all your DU friends are with you wherever you decide your life will go.

Haele

Solly Mack

(90,792 posts)
6. It was part of the retiree process for my husband - a briefing on ALS.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:42 PM
Dec 2018

Possible culprits included long term exposure to pesticides and lead, as well as the harsh physical demands on the body. Even trauma.

Not everyone in the military who developed ALS served during a time of war.

We were told they have yet to pinpoint a single cause but are still looking.


Miss you, cliffordu.

Thank you, mopinko. You're a gem.

to both.

pnwmom

(109,006 posts)
7. Please pass on my best wishes to cliffordu!
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:44 PM
Dec 2018

If I learn anything about ALS and vets I'll let you know.

hlthe2b

(102,419 posts)
8. There are several compelling prospective studies that have shown
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:45 PM
Dec 2018

with little doubt that both Vietnam Veterans and WWII veterans were at increased risk for ALS compared to those who did not serve. The increase risk is even higher among WWII veterans, but of course there has been much longer follow up in this larger cohort prior to the "die off" among the aging WWII cohort we see now. It is speculated that with longer follow-up that an increased risk may show up among other veterans as well.

My speculation? I think the evidence is pretty overwhelming, even if a causal association has not been shown. Perhaps the military learned from the Agent Orange experience wherein they determinedly decided to fight the lawsuits under the guise of "waiting for more conclusive answers" even after the large long term study results were published. Decades of fighting the association--as the numbers affected piled up-- was a pretty self-defeating approach. What else is going on behind the scenes? Difficult to say. I'd have to say with an all volunteer military force that as evidence of potential harm--beyond what one accepts as risk from combat may be having its impact on recruitment--or perhaps they expect it will.

Here's a link to one of the better studies:
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4604116/

Military Service and Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis in a Population-based Cohort
Marc G. Weisskopf,corresponding authora,b Merit E. Cudkowicz,c and Norman Johnsond
Author information Article notes Copyright and License information Disclaimer

Military service has been suggested to be associated with an increased risk of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), but only one prospective study—of a volunteer cohort—has examined this question.



May I extend my warm thoughts to cliffordu, my sadness that this has happened to him, but my pride in his acceptance and courageous approach to his illness. I am thankful that technology may offer him improved quality of life and the ability to remain engaged with others--including his DU family. I will think of him regularly and hope that my warm wishes might bring a slow down to his progression of symptoms or far better, a halt. Thanks mopinko for letting us know about cliffordu and the opportunity to reach out.

pecosbob

(7,545 posts)
9. Best wishes
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:46 PM
Dec 2018

As a veteran it has long galled me that the VA seems to operate on an adversarial basis, like many government agencies. Their willingness to step up in this case does seem a bit odd, given their reluctance to assume responsibility for a myriad of service related health conditions over the decades.

lunatica

(53,410 posts)
10. Dear cliffordu
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:49 PM
Dec 2018

Hugs to you! You’re a great DUer and I hope you get good information from the qualified DUers here.

 

jberryhill

(62,444 posts)
13. It is unlikely the VA could hide a cause of ALS from the global research community
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 02:56 PM
Dec 2018

If I had to guess, I would bet that, for example, the European Network for the Cure of ALS would be unlikely to cooperate in a scheme by the VA to hide the cause of ALS. They have veterans in Europe as well, and they also have national health care systems with a direct financial incentive to find effective treatments.

mopinko

(70,268 posts)
70. thanks for this.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 10:00 PM
Dec 2018

i am really not a ct person, but i also live in the real world where things are not always as they seem.
the encals is a new thing for me to google, tho. thanks.

UpInArms

(51,285 posts)
14. Please give my regards to Clifford
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:00 PM
Dec 2018

I wish I had any information... but will go and see if I can see anything re the VA and ALS

Thank you for sharing and caring

uia

Hekate

(90,865 posts)
15. Clifford -- have missed hearing from you here, and am glad you can now at least lurk & maybe more
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:05 PM
Dec 2018

Your byline is one I always looked for as part of the DU conversation. We will -- continue the battle for our country's soul, or as one of my early childhood heroes put it: for truth, justice, and the American way.

This is stunning news, and my morning dose of caffeine isn't helping. I'm so sorry to be out of words.

grantcart

(53,061 posts)
20. Clifford had a major event the day after Mopinko's visit
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:31 PM
Dec 2018


Just as he was going to sleep the pillows that prop his head up slipped out and Clifford spent 8 hours struggling not to drown in his own spit and to not panic. It must have been terrifying and Clifford said that he had to battle against panicking and not following asleep so that he could keep pushing his saliva down.

Thank you so much Mopinko for making this trip and letting Cliffordu know how much we all treasure him..

herding cats

(19,568 posts)
48. That had to be terrifying!
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:16 PM
Dec 2018

What a terrible thing to happen right after such a good event.

My thoughts go out to Clifford.

nahant

(93 posts)
22. Sorry to hear about cliffordu
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:34 PM
Dec 2018

Just a ? Did he have any MRIs with contrast? If so you might check out https://gadoliniumtoxicity.com/ for information about the contrast used for MRIs.. I founded a support group for those who have been harmed by the contrast in 2012 and we have grown to over 750 members with more patients applying for membership daily, there is a link to the support group at the above website. I am now in my 11th year of dealing with the effects of having been injected with the gadolinium based contrast and have been on opiods since then. I got my first MRI at the VA and the next 2 at Stanford Medical center after I had been misdiagnosed with liver cancer and made it to the top of the transplant list when I was told I didn't have cancer and wouldn't be getting a new liver..
We have several whom are also suffering ALS and are trying to learn the connection.
Best wishes cliffordu from a fellow vet.

backtoblue

(11,346 posts)
23. Love pouring through to cliffdu
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:35 PM
Dec 2018


Mopinko, thank you for the update on our dear friend. I don't know much about the VA or ALS, but if I come across anything I'll let ya know.

Clifford, you are loved and thank you for your service to our country and to our DU home. Catch you in the next life. Peace brother.

lillypaddle

(9,581 posts)
26. Cliffordu, I didn't know you well
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:42 PM
Dec 2018

but I remember you. Wish I had some very wise and comforting words for you right now, but alas ...

This will have to suffice

Dylan Thomas wrote, "Do not go gentle into that good night," but for you, I wish you to go most gently, friend, go gently.

Jackie

mn9driver

(4,428 posts)
27. I know of two friends who served that died from this rapid onset ALS.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:44 PM
Dec 2018

We all served in the Navy in the 1980s and early 1990s. They were in their late 50s when diagnosed and they went very fast, between 6 months and a year. Before that, they were very healthy and stayed in shape.

mopinko

(70,268 posts)
46. yeah, the idea that exercise
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:12 PM
Dec 2018

can f you up this way is just mind boggling.
cliff was in great shape, 6 pack and all, when he got sick.
he was starting to train for a cross country bike ride when it all went to shit.

BlancheSplanchnik

(20,219 posts)
60. Life is not fair!
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 07:23 PM
Dec 2018

I wish I had helpful info or anything to lift your spirits, cliffordu. I hope you have much comfort and support.

karin_sj

(812 posts)
29. I'm sorry to hear this
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:51 PM
Dec 2018

Best wishes to you, cliffordu. I'm sure that the knowledgable and caring people here will give you valuable information and support.

SharonAnn

(13,780 posts)
30. Clifford, i've Read your posts for years. You're part of our DU community.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 03:51 PM
Dec 2018

May you have the best of care during this time.

sprinkleeninow

(20,268 posts)
32. I am so very sorry.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 04:07 PM
Dec 2018


Alcoholism. A family member. I have understanding. Especially that of a veteran.

Truly, I am remembering him in my prayerful intercession. 🕯

mgardener

(1,822 posts)
37. Did a quick search on Bing
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 04:48 PM
Dec 2018

Go to National Institute of Health
Several articles on the website are about Vets and ALS.

It is incredible number of Vets affected.

H2O Man

(73,637 posts)
38. Thank you for this information.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 04:55 PM
Dec 2018

I've long considered Cliffordu to be one of the finest people I've known on this forum. Although he and I have never met in person, he is the type of guy who I'd be fully comfortable with at my home. And I'd love for my children to know him. If circumstances allow for it, I'd love to be in direct contact with him.

ZeroSomeBrains

(638 posts)
39. I wish Clifford the best
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 04:56 PM
Dec 2018

I can only imagine having to come to terms with a terminal illness. Life isn't fair sometimes.

LiberalArkie

(15,730 posts)
40. An interesting article on ALS
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 05:00 PM
Dec 2018

Sept. 9, 2002 -- Ever since the career of baseball great Lou Gehrig was cut short by ALS, the disease has been forever linked to elite athletes. But a new study suggests that slim, athletic individuals may actually be more likely to develop diseases that gradually erode muscle strength, such as ALS.

Diseases that affect the nerves that control muscles -- including ALS -- are called motor neuron diseases. Researchers found that people who had always been slim were more than twice as likely to develop motor neuron diseases than those who were heavier. And varsity athletes were 1.7 times more likely to develop these diseases later in life.

For the study, researchers compared 279 people with motor neuron disease to a similar group of 152 people with other diseases that affect the brain and nervous system. The results appear in the September issue of Neurology.

According to the CDC, only about 14% of the general population participated in physical activities and even fewer reach the level of varsity athletics. But the study authors found 38% of their patients with motor neuron diseases had been varsity athletes, compared with 27% of the comparison group.

More

https://www.webmd.com/fitness-exercise/news/20020909/athletes-lou-gehrigs-disease

Comment: I put into the category "Athlete" those in WW2 and Vietnam etc. They certainly had to constantly exert themselves.

BigmanPigman

(51,640 posts)
41. My grandfather had ALS and my mother told me that the hardest
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 05:20 PM
Dec 2018

part is that victims of the disease are mentally normal and aware of what is going on 100%. They know exactly what is happening and their body just gives out on them. It is so sad and frustrating. She told me that research is looking into radiation and other environmental factors. My family contributes to ALS research.

Many environmental factors are suspect in ALS. Possible toxins include:
Beta-methylamino-l-alanine (BMAA)
Smoking
Toxins: metals, solvents, radiation and electromagnetic fields
Warfare
Exercise
Pesticides
Viruses
http://www.alsa.org/research/focus-areas/environmental-factors/

mopinko

(70,268 posts)
45. yup. some cruel shit.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:10 PM
Dec 2018

cliff is in there, same as always.
at least he could feel me holding his hand, even if he could barely approximate squeezing it back.

Donkees

(31,481 posts)
43. 'neither cliff nor i have been able to figure out just how the military decided to step up on this'
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 05:53 PM
Dec 2018

It seems that events in the 1991 Gulf War are the key to their ''stepping up on this''




The recent study builds on research published in 2003 that showed there was a two-fold increased risk of ALS among 1991 Gulf War veterans.To gather this information, researchers screened medical files at Veteran Affairs and Department of Defense hospitals nationwide in search of patients with ALS or other motor neuron diseases. They also advertised a toll-free telephone number for Gulf War veterans to call if they had been diagnosed with ALS.

Now, researchers at Duke, Durham Veterans Affairs Medical Center and UC are taking it a step further and are conducting studies to find possible exposures these veterans had while deployed to the Persian Gulf area that may be the cause of the outbreak.

"We want to find out if there are specific areas where the soldiers moved through," Horner says. In addition, he says researchers are looking at the contributions of specific incidents--for example, the demolition of the munitions dump at Khamisiyah, Iraq, that released a low level of nerve agent, and smoke from the oil well fires--to the heightened risk of the disease in soldiers.

"With this information, we may be able to discover what caused the ALS outbreak and hopefully prevent similar instances from occurring in the future," Horner says.

The study is being published in the July issue of Neuroepidemiology.

Other researchers involved in the study include Steven Grambow, PhD, Cynthia Coffman, PhD, Jennifer Lindquist, Eugene Oddone, MD, and Kelli Allen, PhD, all from the Durham VA Medical Center and Duke University Medical Center, and Edward Kasarskis, MD, PhD, from the Lexington VA Medical Center and University of Kentucky, Lexington.

This study was funded in part by the U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs and the Department of Defense.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/06/080606084113.htm


The Institute of Medicine (IOM) has issued a new report from experts supporting an association between military service and later development of ALS. Published reports reviewed by the experts show up to a two fold increased risk of developing amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS, also known as Lou Gehrig’s disease) among veterans deployed in the Persian Gulf War of 1991.

http://web.alsa.org/site/PageServer?pagename=ALSA_Veterans_Risk



Best wishes to cliff

mopinko

(70,268 posts)
44. the thing is that they are STILL fighting over agent orange, but
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:00 PM
Dec 2018

they just rolled over on this. i agree the epidemiology is pretty clear cut. it is obviously the right thing to do.
it just makes me wonder that they did the right thing without being forced to. that is the point.

and it's not just gulf war vets. it is across all conflicts, and even those who didnt serve in a theater of war.

Donkees

(31,481 posts)
52. The research links do mention veterans across all conflicts being affected, but the key research ..
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:28 PM
Dec 2018

that many are working on now, seems to be centered on events in the 1991 Gulf War. I just highlighted the excerpts that I thought might answer your question. I'll see what else I can find...

Donkees

(31,481 posts)
64. Follow-up to my last post:
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 08:10 PM
Dec 2018
I mentioned that the ALS research was mainly focused on the 1991 Gulf War. It led to the VA Secretary accepting the research in 2001 ...

ALS and GWV
Timeline

• Dec. 2001 – VA Secretary Anthony Principi
announced connection between Gulf War service
and ALS, conferring full disability and survivor
benefits to Gulf War Veterans with ALS.


In 2006 the research findings were extended, and in 2008 the VA Secretary established ALS as a 'Presumptive Compensable Illness'


ALS and all Veterans
• 2005 – Prospective study reports increased ALS
mortality for veteran (n=281,874) vs. non-veteran male
population (n=126,414) (RR=2.24, CI: 1.12-2.09)
(Weisskopf et al., Neurology 2005)
• Nov. 2006 – Institute of Medicine report concludes
“limited and suggestive evidence of an association
between military service and development of ALS”.
• Sept. 2008 – VA Secretary James Peake announces ALS
a service connected condition for all affected veterans
with ≥ 90 day service.

https://www.va.gov/gulfwaradvisorycommittee/docs/ALSMeekins.pdf




ALS outbreak among Gulf War veterans likely has common cause, says leading researcher

http://www.91outcomes.com/2010/06/study-gulf-war-chemicals-cause-mood.html











Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
47. My first offhand thought: Cost of ALS treatment vs Agent Orange
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:14 PM
Dec 2018

Without doing research, my first thought was that there might be a big difference in the cost of treating the effects of Agent Orange vs. ALS.

Agent Orange causes or may cause a variety of serious conditions (including neurological), and can be passed down to future generations, causing all sorts of things, including defects. I found a site that said the cost to the U.S. for Agent Orange related conditions is about $1.7 Billion a year.

I didn't see a US cost for treating ALS, but if ALS progresses quickly, it's possible that the cost for treating ALS is much less for the country than for Agent Orange, esp if it is passed down to future generations.

It seems to me that the country would fight much harder against accepting the blame and cost for a much more expensive syndrome (or whatever Agent Orange related conditions are called).

Cost may have nothing to do with it, but it's the first thing that occurred to me.

Second, it's the horror and shame that the US itself used the Agent Orange and would therefore be to blame for all the suffering and deaths. That's not the case with ALS, apparently.

herding cats

(19,568 posts)
49. They're still researching why ALS presents 2:1 more often in veterans.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:21 PM
Dec 2018

That there's a link is at least now accepted, in a large part, thanks to the ALS association. They fought long and hard to get it covered for our vets!

This is a decent write up about the process which lead up to the decision.

https://www.mdedge.com/rheumatology/article/44900/lupus-connective-tissue-diseases/va-treat-any-veteran-als-regardless

malaise

(269,219 posts)
50. K & R
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:21 PM
Dec 2018

A good friend's son died from ALS two months ago. The deterioration was heartbreaking. He was medical,doctor but he worked I the labs.

Vinca

(50,318 posts)
51. I'm sorry to learn one of our fellow Du'ers has had such a lousy diagnosis.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:25 PM
Dec 2018

All the best to cliffordu. I can't imagine your journey, but it sounds like you can be very proud of where you've come so far. Sorry I'm out of the "braintrust" category. The connection between military service and ALS is interesting and if there is anything there I'm betting Tammy Duckworth can find it.

TheBlackAdder

(28,227 posts)
53. My family has hereditary neuropathies. Potassium and iodine are stripped from most foods now.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:32 PM
Dec 2018

.


There are a bunch of things that can improve and delay nerve and brain synapse damage, and special care needs to be taken to make sure we are getting the right amounts of them. Prolonged periods of low potassium, calcium, B-Vitamins, Magnesium, etc can cause a near-permanent degradation in these functions. I've had the father of a boss die in the hospital because he had no potassium in his body and they did not catch it. The levels given are probably low-safe hospital guideline amounts, which is OK for an average person in the hospital, but not for someone with nerve or neuro issues.


Unless you get and eat a lot of iodized salt, which is not found in packaged or restaurant foods, and you don't eat a pile of bananas every day... by pile a dozen or so, you are probably potassium deficient, running at the bare minimums of USDA/NIH guidelines.


Iodine, which is a cancer inhibitor, is now replaced with bromine, a known cancer inducer. Bromine is so bad, it was actually pulled from orange sodas, in the form of Brominated Vegetable Oil. Just that small amount can be detrimental to most, but again, with neuro issues, it's even worse.


Just my two cents.

.

Cha

(297,799 posts)
55. I always looked forward when
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 06:55 PM
Dec 2018

I saw a cliffordu post! You made a enduring and endearing impression.

You're a fellow President Obama supporter!

Love you So Sorry you're having to go through this, Cliff

Thank Goodness you have such Good Friends to help.

Cha

(297,799 posts)
57. Mahalo, mopinko, for
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 07:00 PM
Dec 2018

your update on cliffordu. So glad you were able to go and see him in person to be there for him

Blue_true

(31,261 posts)
61. One of my oldest brothers was a combat Marine in Vietnam.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 07:31 PM
Dec 2018

He was a member of a forward gunnery crew, these days they are called shot and scoot. His unit went deep in the jungle to blast away at Viet Cong with big howrizers.
Because of their position, they often got sprayed with Agent Orange, near the end of his life he opened up about being covered with the stuff and their equipment and guns being covered with it, all that they had to clean up. When he came home from multiple tours, he tried to return to college, but could not handle it. His physical health (including loss of muscle mass) and mental health deteriorated very rapidly, within 15 years he was dead.

I recently talked to a Marine Vet and Vietnam combat veteran. His health has slowly deteriorated over years, he walks now with assistance and is in and out of homelessness (he is ok now).

People don't know what Vietnam vets have gone through and how shamefully our government has dealt with their illnesses.

catbyte

(34,484 posts)
63. My dad was a vet & I lost him to ALS in 2000.
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 08:04 PM
Dec 2018

My sweetie also lost his wife of 34 years to ALS in 2013. It's the cruelest fucking disease on the planet. I lost my dad 6 months after his diagnosis, but Rick's wife lived at home for 6 years after diagnosis. The ALS Association was a great help to my dad, mom, and me, as well as to Rick and his wife. Their help and suggestions allowed Rick's wife to be cared for at home. My dad had lung issues to begin with, so that's where it attacked my dad. He refused a respirator, so it was very fast. If you haven't contacted them, please do. I wish I could help in some way. I'm so very sorry.

bluescribbler

(2,123 posts)
67. Nam Vet here with some thoughts
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 09:10 PM
Dec 2018

I was Navy, served on a destroyer and a guided missile frigate. My service involved two cruises in the "hostile fire zone" of the Tonkin Gulf. Naval Gunfire Support off the coast and working with carriers as they conducted bombing raid over the North. No big deal, right? I didn't get shot at. Didn't earn a Purple Heart or a Bronze Star.

A few years ago, I was "between jobs". Couldn't afford COBRA. I decided to apply for VA health care. I knew the drill. When I enlisted, I was promised "free health care for life", but the GOPukes had changed the rules. Now, in order to qualify, you had to have a service related disability, have a Purple Heart, or be a former POW. I didn't think I'd qualify, but I filed any way, because, why the hell not? They can't take away my birthday. The worst they can do is to say no.

Imagine my surprise when my claim was approved! I was told that because I had served "in country" I was eligible due to possible exposure to Agent Orange. Mind blown here. I doubt that any of the shells we carried and fired on targets on shore carried Agent O range, much less that I was exposed to the contents of any of the shells.

But then I got to thinking. I had heard a report on the news which clicked my brain into overdrive. Think about it. Navy ships don't carry large stores of fresh water. In the old days of sail, they needed to. Not any more. Both of the ships on which I served took water from the sea, fan it through their evaporators, and converted into fresh water for the boilers, for drinking, for cooking, and for washing.

Where did our fresh water come from, and where did the Agent Orange go after it had been sprayed on the jungle? Is it possible that the Agent Orange, after being sprayed on the jungle, migrated through the soil into the creeks, streams and rivers into the waters of the Tonkin Gulf, there to be consumed by the sailors who needed their morning coffee? It seems like a reasonable thing to me.

So, maybe, there's more to this Agent Orange bullshit than the government is willing to tell us. Wouldn't be the first time.

Demonaut

(8,931 posts)
71. We all had a wide range of vaccinations, we took prophylaxis pills before visiting certain countries
Fri Dec 14, 2018, 10:00 PM
Dec 2018

I wish you the best, Clifford, stay strong long, in the mind.

diva77

(7,664 posts)
73. you've probably seen this before - I have no background in this and hope I am
Sat Dec 15, 2018, 01:33 AM
Dec 2018

not posting misleading rumors; maybe just consider it as a possibility??

it was in responses to an article:
https://www.care2.com/causes/why-is-lou-gehrigs-disease-closely-related-to-veterans.html

Stewart S.4 years ago

Guys,

It's the Pulsed Doppler Microwave Radars used by the military causing neurological damage and oxidative stress. Same reason the natives around the Guam radar/missile base have 50-100 times the rate of ALS/Motor Neuron disease. The pulsed microwave doppler radars are damaging all biology. Each pulse is up to 3,000,000 watts of microwave radiation. We have chronic wasting disease and prion disease around Cape Canaveral radar/missile base/indian river lagoon as well as White Sands Missile Bases. Miltary Radars, Weather Radars and FAA radars. The government is now pulsing >600,000,000 watts of microwave radiation over our heads and reflecting thru our bodies 24/7. The 2.0 - 6.0 GHz Frequency range from these radars now has over 20 studies showing that it is bad for biology. Research @ darkmattersalot
SEND

--------------------
best wishes for Clifford and hugs to both of you

flvegan

(64,419 posts)
74. Never let go of hope.
Sat Dec 15, 2018, 01:40 AM
Dec 2018

Kudos on the reality, "i was a mod and he was a good natured lounge troll, lol"

That's good DU.

JudyM

(29,293 posts)
79. Hey Cliff, I hope you're having a better day today. If you haven't looked into cannabis,
Sat Dec 15, 2018, 11:16 AM
Dec 2018

maybe it could be helpful. Here’s one study that just came out a couple days ago, using the most commonly used pharmaceutical preparation in case you aren’t in a state where cannabis is legal: https://www.medpagetoday.com/neurology/generalneurology/76938

I’m often immersed in reviewing natural medicine research, and am continually struck by how cannabis helps with so many issues... it feeds our bodies’ endogenous homeostasis system (“endocannabinoid system”) as well as helping through other mechanisms. A friend with MS finds it extremely helpful for spasticity and generally feeling better.

Here’s a favorite quick med research update website with ALS plugged in: https://www.sciencedaily.com/news/health_medicine/amyotrophic_lateral_sclerosis/

I remember you here and will be holding you in my thoughts and wishing you peace, ease and comfort.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»an update on cliffordu, a...