General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsMy 600 lb. Life
Has anyone watched the show, "My 600 Lb. Life." Is it possible fast food can cause this type of weight gain? What are they putting in this food? Is it hormones? I've never seen anything like this in my lifetime.
WhiskeyGrinder
(22,329 posts)Like what?
lunatica
(53,410 posts)PupCamo
(288 posts)lunatica
(53,410 posts)Did you mean to reply to my thread?
catbyte
(34,376 posts)Century America. It is pretty sad.
PupCamo
(288 posts)thank you
lunatica
(53,410 posts)MFM008
(19,808 posts)food can be an addiction.
Food is an addiction. But, if you go back just a couple of decades, very few people were over 300-400. It was very rare.
MFM008
(19,808 posts)It wasnt seen...
Bernardo de La Paz
(49,001 posts)If the body doesn't get the nutrients it needs, it will crave food.
While it is craving food, if the body is fed empty calories, it won't get the nutrients it needs. So it craves food.
While it is craving food, if the body is fed empty calories, it won't get the nutrients it needs. So it craves food.
While it is craving food, if the body is fed empty calories, it won't get the nutrients it needs. So it craves food.
....
Shell_Seas
(3,333 posts)I've seen people on there talk about eating over 10,000 calories a day (or more)...as part of their normal diet....while being bed-ridden, because of their health problems related to obesity.
It's not just what they are eating, but how much of it they are eating...
ginnyinWI
(17,276 posts)If they are bedridden, they can't get the food by themselves. Not even to go to the door to collect pizza delivery. So who is enabling the person to consume so much food?
If this were my task, I'd immediately substitute vegetables and fruits for everything they were eating. No fat, no starch. As much as they wanted, cooked or raw.
Ms. Toad
(34,069 posts)the family dynamics are ineresting - and in some instances, the 600 lb person is very emotionally abusive, and doing somethign like substituting veggies and fruits (or refusing to get calorie dense junk food) is a trigger.
True Blue American
(17,984 posts)Much like drugs or alcohol they have an enablor.
Seen a few lives destroyed in real life by enablors who think continuing to help a person they are being kind. They are not but justify the same way people justify Trump.
milestogo
(16,829 posts)Usually a family member or friend. The obesity doctor always brings this up, because that dynamic has to change or the weight loss surgery is useless.
The other thing I always wonder, is how do they afford so much excess food? Most of these people are unable to work so they are living on disability, which doesn't give you much of a stipend. Food is expensive. How do they do it?
Raven
(13,890 posts)600-700 pounds overnight. I think it is a terrible vicious cycle...the more weight you gain, the less you exercise, the more sedentary you get.
malaise
(268,969 posts)I simply can't understand how people reach that size
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)It is ten times easier to find fried food of all types down here than it is to find a shop that sells good soup and salad. But go to almost any part of the WestCoast, NYC, Northern Virginia, Boston, Pittsburgh, it's fairly to find soup and salad places.
get the red out
(13,462 posts)I am not into the burnt-fried food so I have found it hard to eat out in certain parts of the state (Kentucky), like where I grew up back in the hills.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)I developed an affinity for salads early on, around 11 or 12. I was regularly ridiculed for liking "rabbit food". It was so hard to find a salad bar, until I went to college, there I found salad bars that were good and discovered that a sandwich could be something other that white bread, greasy meat, cheap cheddar cheese and lots of mayo.
get the red out
(13,462 posts)I went to college in 1982 and loved the salad bars at restaurants. The were better back then with more veggies and not solely based on May-laden goop.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)malaise
(268,969 posts)Per capita KFC sells the most chicken in Jamaica and while we do have obesity problems, I have never heard of or seen anyone weighing 600lbs. At what point does a person pause and say OK something is wrong here.
Guess we have more home cooking.
Please note that I am not attacking persons with medical conditions that lead to overweight.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)downing a lot of other stuff. That seem more that having medical issues that cause excess weight, though the two could be related for some people.
The thing that bothers me where I live are the number of overweight very young children.
malaise
(268,969 posts)I watch the food channels and seriously carnival food would give me a heart attack
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)It may be related with parents being stressed economically and needing to hold down jobs. There is no time for a parent to get home and prepare a nutritious meal that takes three-four hours, so they go with faster meals or buy pre-made food, both of which will likely have more sugar, starch and fat.
malaise
(268,969 posts)but a nutritious meal does not have to take three to four hours.
janterry
(4,429 posts)50 Shades Of Blue
(9,985 posts)They overeat as a form of protection. I think they're all using food as an escape from reality - even though it just makes things worse. Many also have overweight family members, and sometimes there is a "feeder" spouse who enables the bingeing so the overweight one can't/won't stray. There are a whole lot of factors involved.
Initech
(100,068 posts)There was this one guy who weighed 650+ pounds and pretty much sat naked in his room and played video games all day. He mentioned that his enabler in his food addiction was his father who also weighed over 500 pounds. So there is that.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)is an image that need to be quickly scrubbed from one's brain.
Initech
(100,068 posts)Sanity Claws
(21,847 posts)Anyone who had to work, grocery shop, cook, clean up after themselves and do all the other things one does day-to-day would be doing enough exercise to avoid such a tremendous weight gain. They may be obese without enablers but never reach the point where they couldn't walk anymore.
kskiska
(27,045 posts)fierywoman
(7,683 posts)I believe it is addictive. Some people have a craving for it. They will spend $25-30 for one order.
fierywoman
(7,683 posts)Blueplanet
(253 posts)Cheetos and Lays potato chips are delicious. No one can eat just one.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Croney
(4,659 posts)The morbidly obese person has (1) a food addiction, (2) emotional problems since childhood, and (3) an enabler who gets the food to them.
The filming has started because they have agreed to see Dr. Nowzardian and work toward weight loss surgery. Sometimes it works. Putting a person on a 1200-calorie-a-day diet after they've been used to 10-20,000 a day is hard. If they fail, he sends them to psychotherapy and that usually helps.
I like to watch the actual surgery. The robotics are amazing.
I've read that many of them gain the weight back because they can't keep to a low-calorie diet. Some do succeed though.
Blueplanet
(253 posts)and yet they can live. The human body is something that boggles the mind.
DeminPennswoods
(15,286 posts)for most the family is also heavy although not usually as much as the person featured on the show. Dr Now tells his patients that only about 5% of morbidly obese people keep the weight they've lost off, so the odds are long. But there's also a "what happened" sequel series that continues to follow the lives of the people on the original show and most seem to be keeping their weight off.
catbyte
(34,376 posts)weight that the doctor wouldn't do her final skin removal surgery until she gained a bit. I've seen her on YouTube and she looks great. She's kept it off almost 4 years. She also ditched her enabling, unenthusiastic husband. I think that helped, too.
On edit: I just googled her and she lost 525 pounds.
Croney
(4,659 posts)Some have masses I can't imagine living with.
TheBlackAdder
(28,189 posts).
It got so bad, I've switched over to a Keto diet, and I have lost 12lbs in 2 weeks, down to 235lbs.
On this thing, I virtually have no desire to eat, but there is that Keto Flu you get the first week cutting over to it.
.
robbob
(3,528 posts)Im doing the Keto diet also and have lost 20-30 lbs. Im not strictly counting my carb intake, so my weight loss has been slow, but I DO feel more energy and I fill up a lot quicker. And, I have NO problem with the diet itself; last night was grilled salmon with oven roasted veggies; absolutely delish! Maybe tonight will be a slow roasted pot roast surrounded by root veggies! Getting hungry thinking about it!
Id say the hardest gap to fill is snack foods. No chips, corn or other, nothing to dip in my guac, no sugars...its hard to find no carb snacks! And, keto advocates tend to smother everything in cheese and creamy sauces, and Im trying to cut down on dairy. Im not 100% sold on the health benefits of a strict keto diet, and once Im happy with my weight I plan to introduce foods I consider healthy but are strictly forbidden on keto (fresh fruits, brown rice, whole grain pasta), but just keep them to a minimum.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Setting up a simple home gym works wonders, if you are budget conscious, you can set one up for maybe $150 tops. I have had one for several years and love it.
robbob
(3,528 posts)Strained my back last year, inflaming the sciatic nerve leading to throbbing pain down my right leg all the way to my ankle. Pain like Ive never experienced! So every other day I try to spend an hour doing stretching and strengthening routines to try and get things functioning normally again.
This year, at age 59, I got into downhill skiing, something Ive only dabbled with in the past, but am enjoying tremendously! What a great way to pass the winter! In the spring Im back to golfing (no cart, Ill walk thank you), which, if Im being honest, is how I hurt my back in the first place.
Im learning that the secret of enjoying life as we get older is directly related to staying healthy, which of course includes diet, weight, staying fit, flexible and healthy!
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)BTW, when you start practicing for golf, try a hockey-shot type swing on your drives and irons. I had to do that a few years ago when I had a nerve issue near a hip. My scores actually got better, from mid 80s to low 80s. You will be surprised by how well the swing works. It takes pressure off your back and hips and have your shoulders do more work.
Ms. Toad
(34,069 posts)it's all about the carb count. Berries (strawberries and blueberries), watermelon, and cantoloupe are staples for most folks eating keto. Brown rice is less common, but can be eaten in very small quantities as part of an otherwise minimally carb diet.
robbob
(3,528 posts)And I knew I was not being accurate even as I wrote it. The thing is, I cant wrap my mind around this whole counting carbs concept (I mean, really? Do I have to weigh every bite of food before I put it in my mouth?), so if I know things contain sugar or carbs I just try to avoid them.
Ms. Toad
(34,069 posts)If your goal is (1) to control diabetes via eating low enough carbs to keep your blood glucose in the normal range or (2) you are fanatical about staying in ketosis.
I'm in the former category - and for about a year weighed everything I ate, closely tracked my blood glucose, so I could see how many carbs I could eat without exceeding normal levels. By now, I don't have to weigh everything because I have enough experience that I no longer need to.
(I'm not a fan of the just eat ketogenic and the weight will fall off bandwagon - it ignores the reality that the way a ketogenic diet works is because the fats make you feel more satiated. If your eating is driven by not feeling satiated, it generally works. But if that is not the driver, and weight is the reason you are following a ketogenic diet, you have to count something. Carbs, calories, points, etc.)
I have a scale at work, one at home, and one of those is a travel scale so when I travel I take it along with me (although there is less need now).
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)I chose to work out. Did around 90 minutes yesterday and 60 early this morning. May take tomorrow off as a lay day or cut down to 40 minutes, either works.
I try to stay away from diets, but respect that other people can make them work. I learned to stay away from dieting after having a Twix-rage incident a few years back. I was on a low sugar, low Carb, high vegetable, high protein diet. My head was a little heavy all the time, but I kept it up. My weight was great. One day a low battery on my car stalled me at an auto mechanic's shop. The guy didn't have many appetizing snacks so I bought a Twix bar given no other decent choice. I remember thinking that I would bite off a little of one bar and throw the rest away. But when I ate the tiny amount my brain went, ummmm, this is sooo good, so I ate the rest of the candy while the mechanic got my car ready, but still on my hate sugar routine, I refused to buy another bar right away. By the time the mechanic got my car ready, my head felt alert and great, I had more energy and my mind could not get off Twix bars. On my drive home I had to pass the grocery store that I regularly shopped at, so I figured that I would go it and buy a twelve-pack box of Twix candy and eat it over maybe the next two or three months. I got home and opened the box and ate one pack, long story short, within an hour I had eaten 10 of the 12 packs and I felt super great, at the moment a bell went off in my head about dieting that rings until this day.
get the red out
(13,462 posts)I am all for people doing things to improve their health, but we get dietary bandwagons going and sometimes it doesn't work so well for some individuals.
fleur-de-lisa
(14,624 posts)especially the patients who have enablers bringing them sacks of food when they have become immobile and can't get it for themselves.
It's also pretty clear that some of them are clueless about nutrition.
Aristus
(66,328 posts)You hear stories on these shows that talk about the subject eating 10 Big Macs for lunch, washing it down with 2 liters of Coke, and then a gallon of ice cream for dessert.
Aside from being a huge amount of food, the soda is sweetened with High Fructose Corn Syrup, which, in addition to just being bad for you, suppresses the secretion of a hormone called leptin, which is what makes you feel full after the stomach has stretched to a certain extent. Without leptin to tell your brain that you're full, you keep eating and eating and eating.
Also, the family members who continually bring these huge amounts of food their house-bound, and often bed-ridden, loved ones bear a certain amount of the blame.
Vinca
(50,269 posts)is going to be magic that will suddenly make them lose weight without changing their habits. Others seem to be trapped by their enablers (who are often also people with severe weight problems). The show really brings it home that obesity begins and ends with emotional eating. It's almost impossible to overcome the addiction that develops.
Runningdawg
(4,516 posts)If an anorexic won't eat because of her emotional problems she gets: IMMEDIATE EMERGENCY attention, a team of Drs, therapists and nutritionists working for her, in-patient care paid by insurance, a whole variety of drugs to encourage her to eat and any surgery that is necessary to correct her condition.
Apply the same care to morbidly obese patients and watch the problem all but disappear.
fleur-de-lisa
(14,624 posts)hack89
(39,171 posts)it is in fact extremely hard and many times treatments fail.
As for the morbidly obese, there are treatments (My 600lbs Life details most of them). And they fail many times too.
Mental illness is very hard to treat because you are depending on mentally ill people to make consistently rational choices.
Runningdawg
(4,516 posts)Are the patients given appetite suppressing drugs or drugs for depression and or anxiety? Are they enrolled in a physical rehab program? Do they visit with a dietician weekly? How many therapy session a week do they attend? Are there support groups for their families? Are they sent to inpatient 21 day addiction programs before or after surgery?
OR do they have the surgery, get wished the best of luck and are forgotten about?
get the red out
(13,462 posts)That is shown on the show.
Runningdawg
(4,516 posts)kskiska
(27,045 posts)that specializes in gastric bypass or lapband surgery. Even after such surgery, many of the patients relapse and gain the weight back. One recent show featured a woman who had relapsed for several years and wanted a second surgery. The doctor was skeptical about whether she even qualified or had the willpower to lose the weight.
Maru Kitteh
(28,340 posts)People need to look up "The Biggest Loser Study" and educate themselves a bit about the disorder of obesity. HINT - it often has absolutely nothing to do with "willpower."
Mariana
(14,856 posts)Deciding that weight-loss surgery isn't appropriate for an individual is not "shaming" them. It's a medical decision based on many factors, one of which is the patient's history and the ability to comply with the doctor's instructions.
Maru Kitteh
(28,340 posts)Implying a deficit of character is shaming.
phylny
(8,380 posts)I wish there was a drug to help me. I'm desperate. I feel like I'll never be normal again.
Thank you for your compassionate answer.
Maru Kitteh
(28,340 posts)my MD about trying prescriptions for the component drugs, bupropion and naltrexone, separately. $10/ea per month. It's worked for me. The milligrams and formulation of course are not identical to the brand name, but this combination has allowed me to drop to a healthier weight without abject misery and pain. When I was on it before, it was easy to maintain my healthy weight and I anticipate the same results this time as well.
Of course it doesn't work for everyone and some people cannot take it, like those on narcotic pain control, history of seizures or uncontrolled high blood pressure. All I'm really trying to say here, is never give up, and I hope you find your answer someday soon.
phylny
(8,380 posts)Thank you!
Sneederbunk
(14,290 posts)Therefore, I do not watch.
Runningdawg
(4,516 posts)FloridaBlues
(4,008 posts)smirkymonkey
(63,221 posts)When you start out like that, it's much easier to continue to have weight problems throughout the rest of your life. When I was growing up (1970's) we were all thin and tiny, there was only the occasional heavy person. Now it's not uncommon to have a third or more of the class with a weight problem (of varying degrees).
kskiska
(27,045 posts)there was usually only one or two overweight student in a classroom, and very rarely a morbidly obese student. We didn't have fast food back then, just a few hot dog stands, and families ate dinner at home every night.
GumboYaYa
(5,942 posts)Sodas, cookies, candy...anything with refined sugar is absolutely horrible for you and should be avoided at all costs. https://academic.oup.com/advances/article/8/3/412/4558122
And it is everywhere. Try eliminating refined sugar from your diet, it is almost impossible unless you eliminate all processed food from your diet.
Doodley
(9,088 posts)given a slightly unpleasant flavor.
Mariana
(14,856 posts)Doodley
(9,088 posts)Mariana
(14,856 posts)The producers? What possible motivation would they have to intentionally make their food products less appealing?
Doodley
(9,088 posts)Codeine
(25,586 posts)Welcome to Tonys, Home of the Slightly Unpleasant Flavor!
I mean seriously, Arbys has that niche covered.
NickB79
(19,236 posts)My wife and I watch that show quite often. The portions they eat are huge.
Codeine
(25,586 posts)consumed in large quantities multiple times a day will make a person obese. Nothing to do with hormones or any other hidden villain, just too much food eaten too often.
Most of those folks have massive depression or anxiety issues and use food to make themselves feel better. Unlike other forms of self-medication it can be hard to overcome food issues because one cannot simply avoid food completely like one could do with opiates or alcohol.
A friend of mine had bariatric surgery to lose weight. Two years later he had managed to stretch his stomach so much he was gaining all of his old weight back, and more. His eating habits will kill him before he reaches sixty.
Ms. Toad
(34,069 posts)An excess of roughly 3900 calories over what your body needs for its essential functions + movement = a pound of weight gain.
Thyroid disease can make it harder to maintain/lose weight. Fast food tends more calorie dense (so it's easier to get to the 3900 excess calories), because sugar and fat are added to make less-tasty processed junk more tasty.
catbyte
(34,376 posts)Have you seen the amount of food they consume per day? I watched an episode a week or two ago, and she had a supersized triple cheeseburger, fries, large shake plus chicken nuggets. Then she was still hungry and her boyfriend ordered at least three large pizzas, wings, and bread sticks. And that was just one meal.
What I don't understand is how they can afford all that fast food. It's expensive as hell, yet she explained her lack of weight loss on the fact that healthy food is "expensive." I wish the ones who really want help the best. Addiction is a nasty thing to overcome.
Raine
(30,540 posts)sure fast food can do it but too much of any food can do it too. Most all of those people have emotional problems (most of the women were molested as children or raped at some point) that caused them to find comfort in food and eat and eat and eat.
Different Drummer
(7,614 posts)My personal opinion is that fast food is like many other things--okay in moderation. Many of the people in this show don't seem to show moderation in their eating.
Response to Blueplanet (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed