General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsYour dog's food may be linked to canine heart disease
(CNN)The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is warning dog owners of a possible link between certain dog food brands and a serious form of canine heart disease.
The FDA has investigated more than 500 cases of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs eating certain types of food, according to their statement. DCM is a condition that effects a dog's heart and results in an enlarged muscle. Dogs with DCM tire easily, cough, and have difficulty breathing.
When the FDA first alerted the public in 2018 to cases of DCM, the agency didn't mention specific brands; only foods labeled as "grain-free" and containing peas, lentils, other legume seeds and/or potatoes as the main ingredients.
As part of that investigation, the FDA has now identified 16 brands of dog food which had the most frequent reported cases of DCM. The top three brands, according to the FDA, are Acana, named in 67 reports; Zignature, named in 64, and Taste of the Wild, named in 53 reports.
"We know it can be devastating to suddenly learn that your previously healthy pet has a potentially life-threatening disease like DCM. That's why the FDA is committed to continuing our collaborative scientific investigation into the possible link between DCM and certain pet foods," said Dr. Steven M. Solomon, director of the FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/06/28/us/dog-food-linked-to-canine-heart-disease/index.html
Oh, great. We cook for our dogs, but also give them the 4-Health kibble. The research we did said it was one of the highest quality foods. Guess its back to the drawing board. Great Pyrenees have a short enough life span already.
Note: I believe the recall clip on this site is from last year. I couldn't find it anywhere else that is recent.
donkeypoofed
(2,187 posts)And refund or no, it is staying there! I am super choked about this. Mess with my dog and I'll mess with you! Acana is going to get ripped a new one on Monday. Stupid in this case is unforgivable.
Thank you so much for sharing this !
get the red out
(13,462 posts)I know a lot of people who feed it to their dogs. It's had a great reputation until now. I feed Fromm, but "Gold" and not "grain-free". I need to find out if that is ok so long as it isn't grain-free.
Lheurch
(65 posts)I want to see this data correlated with the market share of the brands actually sold. It could be creating some false positives, but also disguising a serious issue with an unpopular but dangerous brand.
Duppers
(28,120 posts)But not our gov't, right?
yonder
(9,664 posts)I wonder if this applies to cats as well?
Drahthaardogs
(6,843 posts)Most cat foods now supplement taurine
Duppers
(28,120 posts)Thank for posting; you may have saved some DUers' babies' lives.
🐕
mahina
(17,651 posts)I dont get the connection between that and legumes. Does anyone else?
Bayard
(22,063 posts)It looks like its from last year, so don't know why its in there. Not connected to legumes.
a la izquierda
(11,794 posts)Hes now dead, of a heart attack. He was just diagnosed in January with a murmur.
mahina
(17,651 posts)Aloha la izquierda.
a la izquierda
(11,794 posts)I was abroad too, which made everything worse.
Polly Hennessey
(6,794 posts)He is eight months old. Is it an over abundance of peas, lentils? Try finding dry food that IS NOT grain free.🤨
leftyladyfrommo
(18,868 posts)Purina, Hills, Eukanuba, Royal Canin. Iams.
Polly Hennessey
(6,794 posts)Might try Eukanuba.
Response to Bayard (Original post)
shanti This message was self-deleted by its author.
Bayard
(22,063 posts)Regardless, my babies are getting whole wheat pasta with their chicken livers and broccoli tonight. That's what I always used to do anyway.
mcar
(42,307 posts)I'm glad our Purina Beneful isn't on the list. My dogs love it.
Drahthaardogs
(6,843 posts)The best Purina products are Pro Plan. I feed it myself along with Canidae to offer variety. Look at the All Life Stages Sport.
Drahthaardogs
(6,843 posts)It narrows the field considerably.
ooky
(8,922 posts)Acana. Said he loved it and dropped off some for my dog to try. I was just about to give it to him as soon as I was out of his current brand to see if he liked it. I sent her a text so she can stop. We are both grateful.
womanofthehills
(8,703 posts)Luckily, he is not a big fan of dried food and I gave him small amts, but now I'm worried. One day he just refused to eat it at all so I switched to another food.
I wonder if the high levels of Roundup (glyphosate) in peas can be part of the problem.
Bayard
(22,063 posts)I'm spending a lot of comparison time on Google. Like I was saying, I may just go back to entirely cooking for my guys. They already get eggs from our chickens every morning.
Here's another short article on grain-free food:
https://news.yahoo.com/grain-free-food-may-linked-dog-heart-disease-172221153.html
leftyladyfrommo
(18,868 posts)now. Purina Eukanuba Hills Iams and z
Royal Canin. Those companies haven't been associated with the heart disease. And they all have qualified staff running trials to be sure their foods are safe.
There are several universities that are running tests trying to find out what the problem is.
Dogs can eat grains just fine. Dogs aren't wolves. Over the last 14,000 years of living with humans they have developed 8 or 9 genes to handle grains. You don't need to feed grain free food.
Once they can pinpoint the problem then you can switch back to whatever food you want.
Duppers
(28,120 posts)We've fed Labs Purina One- Chicken & Brown Rice formula. I asked our Vet less than 3wks ago about it and she said it was fine. (It's $33.50 at Chewy.com for a 31lb bag.) Contains no wheat or corn--we've always avoided those grains because of the GMO factor.
I make veggie soup with a bit of meat and also supplement with a easy fix: I blanched canned green beans, then reheated with homemade chicken stock, which they both also love.
Bayard
(22,063 posts)After spending hours looking at ratings online, some sites say the brands listed above as most frequently associated with DCM, are the the same ones most highly rated on other sites. There are some obscure brands out there that are mentioned as good, but look hard to find and quite expensive--a big factor when you're feeding three 150 lb dogs.
Tons of recipes out there for making your own. 30-40% protein is ideal. I use a lot of boiled chicken, chicken livers, gizzards, along with veges and usually pasta or brown rice. Throw in a vitamin/mineral tablet. There is a new farm store in town that was going to sell mutton/lamb. I may check there for hearts and kidneys (smell terrible while cooking, but very healthy).
I started doing this originally when they were doing a bunch of recalls after finding melamin in various brands, including top ones. I've just gotten lazy lately, and only cooking meat to go on top of kibble.
I'm done with commercial food.......again.
Bettie
(16,095 posts)but it seems like all of the brands listed are the most expensive ones.
We have a Pyr mix...adopted from a shelter, seems the family got a fuzzy little pupper and didn't realize how big and barky he'd get!
get the red out
(13,462 posts)A few of those brands listed have varieties that are NOT grain-free, and not filled up with legumes. I have been feeding Fromm Gold since I first read there might be a problem with grain-free foods precisely for this reason. I am assuming they are discussing the grain-free varieties of these brands, but I wish they would note that if it's true.
We really do need this information clarified. Hopefully that will happen soon.
mnhtnbb
(31,384 posts)At the time she had the surgery to remove the stones, the vet also picked up a heart arrhythmia while she was on the monitor for surgery. Vet told me there was a study indicating that dogs rarely survived beyond 6 months once diagnosed with the arrhythmia. Makes them susceptible for sudden death.
So, she's been eating the urinary formula of canned Royal Canin for 2 years. Yes, the dog that was supposed to be gone within 6 months is still with me 2 years later!
Before the surgery, I had fed her Natural Balance for a couple of years, and Purina prior to that. I wonder if the Natural Balance contributed to her heart problem?
Prosper
(761 posts)We picked Merrick because it never had a call back. Start looking again or .make our own.
MichMan
(11,915 posts)I have been following this issue since last fall. While their has seen some evidence there is a link , no one really understands what the root cause is yet. At this the data indicates that peas. ligumes and pulse ingredients (which were protein substitutes for grains) are contributing to taurine absorption.
Keep in mind that there are millions of dogs and the percentage reported to the FDA with DCM is very low. There are also a few breeds like Golden Retrievers that are genetically predisposed to having heart issues regardless of foods.
I have been feeding Orijen for years and while the % of the suspect ingredients is quite low, I did switch just for my own piece of mind , if nothing else, until the FDA has more definitive information. That being said, I had dogs that lived long lives on Orijen without any heart issues, so to blame it on a particular brand may not be fair.
I suspect that many small companies that produce some of these foods are really taking a hit right now as many pet owners are panicking.
cally
(21,593 posts)I have been feeding my old dog Taste of the Wild. Time to change brands
MichMan
(11,915 posts)Tried both Purina One and also Farmina (Italian) No issues with either one, but ended up changing to Nature's Logic.
It was a very hard decision to go away from Orijen as I had been feeding it to my dogs for over 10 years, and they did very well, but this DCM food scare was driving me crazy. Had to make some kind of change just for my own piece of mind.