Welcome to DU, by the way!
There are, however, a number of complexities that render defunding and starting over an inadequate (and likely actually counter-productive) solution.
Perhaps most significantly, because what police are depends GREATLY upon where you are.
This simple yet often overlooked fact is one of the most significant problems facing the BLM movement, in that where you happen to live can and does greatly influence the reality of dealing with police that you will get to experience. If I'd spent my entire life in the DC Metro area (and had been hiding under a rock and not seen the countless videos of egregious misconduct from many other places around the country), the grievances aired by BLM would likely strike me as largely unfounded, because they don't match that experience of it, where police culture actually is (at least in my experience) relatively well-rooted in actual public service.
But I've also lived in the deep south, and seen with my own two eyes that those grievances most emphatically ARE NOT unfounded. At least not everywhere, and as long as they're founded anywhere, we have important work to do.
I also take some issue with the notion that the race of the officers, or racial composition of the police force, is either the actual problem or the remedy. I've seen LEOs of color behave every bit as unacceptably as the overtly racist white asshole cops, within police forces that WERE overwhelmingly minority.
The actual problem, I think, lies in police culture, which spans race, but varies widely with geography.
Defunding the police sounds good on paper, but it's so dramatically oversimplified and under-explained that most don't even recognize what it actually suggests, which would be far more accurately and productively expressed as deburdening the police. The problem is not that police forces are over-funded, it's that they are dramatically overburdened, thanks in large part to the dismantling of our mental health treatment capacity over the last few decades.
We do need dramatic police reform, but we really must approach it more thoughtfully than looking primarily at such simplistic things as funding levels and racial force composition, because no combination of those two variables will solve the many serious problems that need to be solved.
We need to look much deeper, into things like what powers are afforded police, what responsibilities accompany those powers, what laws are being enforced against whom, how they're being enforced against whom, to what end and to whose benefit, on the basis of what deeper underpinnings, etc.
= new reply since forum marked as read
