The Incredible Shrinking Mayor of New York
Politico
New York City mayoral elections in recent decades often involved big personalities for better and for worse debating issues that were equally big, even existential. But after this years race, New York feels like a shrinking city, diminished in purpose and common feeling.
It is almost impossible to describe just how scattered, mediocre and insipid this eight-candidate Democratic primary has been. Petty criticisms and personal scandals abound. The current leader on the left, Maya Wiley, has seen her legitimacy questioned because her longtime partner contributed money to have a private security car patrol their neighborhood after a brutal mugging put him in the hospital. Kathryn Garcia stands accused of not being Hispanic. Serious questions have been raised as to whether Eric Adams or Andrew Yang even lives in the city they wish to govern. One-time frontrunner Scott Stringers effort tanked after he was accused of groping a friend 20 years ago and a waitress 30 years ago. Dianne Morales campaign staff unionized and promptly went on strike, though like a ghost ship her campaign continues to run TV ads.
What former Mayor David Dinkins once called the gorgeous mosaic of New York seems to have shattered, with each candidate grabbing for a shard. Adams has his Hasidic faction, Yang has his. Adams and Wiley wrangle for support from Black voters. Ray McGuire has the Upper East Side, Garcia the Upper West.
No doubt the byzantine format of ranked-choice voting, in which voters are asked to pick their top five candidates in order of preference, has contributed to the confusion. The new system provides a sort of instant run-off that saves some money, while all but ensuring that the winner will be someone who was not the first choice of a majority of voters.