General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsLie repellent phrases for use on Republicans
Who told you that? (Forces them to point the finger at someone or admit they made it up themselves.)
Give me an example. (Forces them to be specific and enter the fact-based realm where they are often helpless.)
Can you show your work on that answer? (Lets you see that they didn't give due diligence, or made a dumb mistake in their work, or even reported a lie when their work showed them the true answer.)
...
Are there others?
Phoenix61
(17,025 posts)Use it all the time on FB. Seems to be pretty decent troll repellent.
Disaffected
(4,574 posts)for republican trolls, UFO believers and alternative medicine advocates.
onecaliberal
(32,991 posts)I could see my questions were making her think about it. I asked her to give me an example of it happening in classrooms. She was unable to give me even one example. Like everything else coming from the GQP nothing they say can hold water. Very easily debunked.
blm
(113,131 posts)Ocelot II
(115,976 posts)What do you know about your sources, and why do you trust them?
But seriously, I don't think anything will work on a lot of them. People get emotionally invested in what they believe to be true, and the harder you challenge them the more they dig in. Nobody wants to be proven wrong, and if especially if someone has acted in accordance with erroneous beliefs, accepting that those beliefs were incorrect can be so uncomfortable and embarrassing that they will try harder than ever to avoid changing their minds.
The Magistrate
(95,264 posts)As someone said: "You can't reason a man out of a view he didn't reason himself into."
I do enjoy an approach along the lines of 'Hey, if you were right, sweetheart, you'd be dead in a swamp.'
gulliver
(13,205 posts)...it increases the odds that they'll accept the truth, imo. For Republican leaders, the underlying assumption is that they know they're lying. They've more than lost the presumption of good faith. So they're fair game and cornering them is not only satisfying but almost a duty.
For others, especially friends and family, I think the assumption should always be that they were misinformed or trusted someone they shouldn't trust in the future.
lame54
(35,345 posts)Or is that where your graphs and charts are?
Mister Ed
(5,948 posts)GoodRaisin
(8,933 posts)My favorite.
Jilly_in_VA
(10,045 posts)That's my favorite, followed by "And fox and Breitbart don't count."
Atticus
(15,124 posts)"If they put your (source's) brain into a bumblebee, it would fly backwards and land upside down in a tar pit!"
Rorey
(8,445 posts)I get my news from legitimate news sources, not entertainment television like FoxNews and the like.
marble falls
(57,479 posts)Before I respond, you tell me who really won the November election.
Better to live in fear than to die in stupidity.
From which University did (MT Greene, Matty Gaetz, Ron Johnson, etc.) get their immunology education?
The 'where did you hear that' is a great showstopper. Shut my loud mouth brother up. He's threatened to send his son to live with us, said he was sounding too much like my wife and myself. He's a good kid, and I got a good room for him, anytime!
FSogol
(45,582 posts)Leith
(7,814 posts)It's a true public service.