General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsThe Magistrate
(95,247 posts)"Don't watch the mouth, watch the hands."
progressoid
(49,988 posts)My brother voted for Nader once. Was he a wretch too?
The Magistrate
(95,247 posts)Last edited Wed Jul 28, 2021, 04:36 PM - Edit history (1)
Nader in 2000 served as the left auxiliary of the Republican party, and anyone who supported him gave active assistance to Bush the Lesser and Cheney.
That's just a fact.
"So much of left-wing thought is a kind of playing with fire by people who don't even know that fire is hot."
progressoid
(49,988 posts)I suppose Gore losing FL had nothing to do with the
308,000 registered Democrats who voted for Bush, compared to less than 24,000 who voted for Nader.
Or the butterfly ballot.
Or 87000 illegally purged voters.
Or Katherine Harris
Or the Supreme Court
Or
The Magistrate
(95,247 posts)If you know anything at all about political life, you will be aware that twenty years ago in southern states there were a great many 'legacy' Democrats who maintained the registration they grew up with and occasionally still voted Democrat for local offices, but hadn't cast a vote for a Democrat running for national office since Reagan. You might complete your display of deliberate ignorance by trying to claim Nader was just the guy to woo southern Reagan Democrats back to support for progressive policies, but I doubt you will.
Polling within a year of the time indicated about two fifths of Florida Nader voters wouldn't have voted for anyone else, while a similar proportion would have voted for Gore were the election held sans Nader, and the last fifth would have voted for Bush. The net is Nader cost about 20,000 votes, more than enough to outweigh the usual shenanigans you recite. The matter would never have come near the Supreme Court.
Here is the thing you really ought not try to dance around. Voter purges, even odd ballots, are dirt normal election techniques, they occur in all elections. Priced into the market already, as the saying goes. A widely recognized third party candidate attacking the Democratic candidate from the left is not a usual factor. Where there is an unusual result, and an unusual factor is present, the likelihood the latter is the reason for the former is overwhelming. This a pin Green party candidates cannot wriggle off of, no matter how hard they try. Anyone who doesn't wake up each morning in a whole new world understands this, it's right up there with object permanence as a basic analytical tool.
progressoid
(49,988 posts)Pointing out that Nader wasn't the sole reason for Florida is not obtuse. It's enlightening.
If you know anything at all about political life, you will be aware many political experts cite the butterfly ballot and the final blow to the Gore campaign.
Others say he lost Florida before voting even started by his mishandling of the of the Elian Glonzalez affair.
"Walter Mebane Jr. and Jasjeet Sekhon employed a multinomial model to estimate its effect on the Florida outcome and concluded that it led to a net swing of roughly 50,000 votes from Gore to Bush."
Still others cite the decision to distance himself from the still popular Bill Clinton and the successes they had.
Lets not forget seniors. By 51-47 percent, Gore lost the over-65 vote in Florida. Bush got 67,000 more senior votes than Gore. Had Gore simply broken even with this constituency, he would have won.
And white women typically voted Democratic in Florida, or split evenly. Gore lost them to Bush by 53-44 percent. Had he gotten 50 percent of these votes, he'd have added 65,000 votes to his total.
Etc.
But yeah, it's easier to blame Nader. I didn't vote for Nader but my brother did. He was a life long Democrat, Union leader and educator (he also supported Biden in '08). He wasn't a wretch.
The Magistrate
(95,247 posts)Good of you to provide one....
"Say something once, why say it again?"
mcar
(42,307 posts)to not actively campaign in contested states.
Red Mountain
(1,732 posts)'legacy' Democrats. There are far more I haven't had that conversation with.
'We're registered Democrats.......but not like that'.
Verbatim.
Hekate
(90,674 posts)
her real party cant cut it. I do not trust her.
dalton99a
(81,474 posts)She is just using the Democratic Party
Phoenix61
(17,003 posts)progressoid
(49,988 posts)Phoenix61
(17,003 posts)So no, I wouldnt call her a Democrat in good standing.
question everything
(47,476 posts)brooklynite
(94,520 posts)Its official! Sen. Nina Turner is running for Congress. Shes running for the seat vacated by Rep. Marcia Fudge, who Joe Biden has chosen as secretary of Housing and Urban Development. The Peoples Party isnt on the ballot in Ohio yet so she will have to run as a Democrat, but we cant think of anyone better to win that seat and bring a friend of the Peoples Party to Congress.
Movement for a People's Party
Hortensis
(58,785 posts)to defeat Democrats by leaving the party, thus helping tRump and the rabid antitax, antigovernment Republicans take over? Her "kind of Democrats" helped elect conservative extremists who are determined to root progressivism and liberalism out of government.
Her "kind of Democrat" rejected all the plans Democrats in congress and state houses had for national healthcare, climate action, housing, pharmaceuticals, and equal pay and protections, and hundreds of other issues.
If we were all "Turner's kind of Democrat," our liberal progressive government would be dead and buried.
Progressivism is not just a factional label or the torch that some use for setting political fires -- it's a real way of governing ourselves to create the very real blessings we depend on every day of our lives. If we don't protect them, we will lose them.
oasis
(49,381 posts)Cha
(297,190 posts)Joe Biden..
Sanders Campaign Co-Chair Nina Turner Rips Biden: Choosing Between Him and Trump is Like Eating From a Bowl of Sh*t
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100213815901
I don't want to know.. I already know.
Autumn
(45,066 posts)Im a #MedicareForAll Democrat
Im a #GreenNewDeal Democrat
Im a #PROAct Democrat
Im a #RaiseTheWage Democrat
mcar
(42,307 posts)unless I can get elected that way.
Crunchy Frog
(26,579 posts)If she won't, then everything else is kind of meaningless.