General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsO U C H .
Biden's handling of the withdrawal had its flaws. But there is simply no proud way to lose a war to a cult of heroin-dealing child rapists (especially when your side in that war featured no small number of men who fit a similar description).
Link to tweet
?s=20
Budi
(15,325 posts)THE MEDIA 3:15 P.M.
The Media Manufactured Bidens Political Fiasco in Afghanistan Straight news has chosen sanctimony over circumspection.
By Eric Levitz@
America's withdrawal from Afghanistan has yet to cost our nation a single casualty. Evacuations of U.S. citizens and allies from Kabuls airport are proceeding at a faster pace than the White House had promised, or than its critics had deemed possible. Afghanistans decades-long civil war has reached a lull, if not an end.
On the streets of Kabul, order and quiet have replaced rising crime and violence. Meanwhile, the Taliban is negotiating with former Afghan president Hamid Karzai over the establishment of an inclusive government acceptable to all Afghans.
In other words, Joe Bidens withdrawal from Afghanistan has been a disastrous and humiliating fiasco, in the words of the mainstream medias ostensibly objective foreign-policy journalists.
This may be an accurate description of what recent events in Kabul have meant for the president, politically.
The latest polls have shown sharp drops in Bidens approval rating, driven in part by widespread opposition to the way his administration handled its (otherwise popular) exit from Afghanistan.
Yet this political fiasco is not a development that the media covered so much as one that it created.
MORE..
Most truthful written piece, yet.
Media should hang their heads in shame.
kimbutgar
(21,137 posts)He wrote that Afghan culture was notorious for preparing young boys for rape. They would put plugs in to widen the anus and when a boy was just entering puberty they were violated. At first I thought it was ridiculous but when I found an old encyclopedia from the 1950s and in the entry about Afghanistan they mentioned this practice. No wonder they hate women they are all pedophiles because of their culture.
SNIP
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/08/media-bias-biden-polls-approval-afghanistan-withdrawal.html
...All of which is to say:
Ascertaining how much of the heartache in Kabul today derives from imperfections in Bidens withdrawal plan and how much would have occurred under any plausible U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan is no easy task.
It is also a task that the media has felt no obligation to undertake. Mainstream coverage of Kabuls fall and its aftermath has been anything but circumspect.
Attempts to weigh the benefits of Americas withdrawal (e.g., the humanitarian gains inherent to the cessation of 20 years of civil war) against its costs have been rare; attempts to judge Bidens execution of that withdrawal against rigorous counterfactuals have been rarer still. Instead, ostensibly neutral correspondents and anchors have (1) openly editorialized against the White Houses policy; (2) assigned Biden near-total responsibility for the final collapse of the proto-failed state his predecessors had established; and then (3) reported on the potential political costs of Bidens actions, as though they were not actively imposing those costs through their own speculations about just how politically damaging the presidents failures of competence and empathy would prove to be.
brush
(53,774 posts)defeat American troops. Afghan troops laid down without fighting for their own country and the Afghan president fled the country with 160 some stolen millions in his luggage...so of course it's Biden's fault even though trump had 11 months to evacuate after his Feb. 2020 agreement with the Taliban to free 5000 Taliban fighter and leave by May 2021.
Of course he did nothing, nothing that is besides trying to steal an election after he loss and then stage and insurrection against his own government.