Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

pstokely

(10,528 posts)
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 01:50 AM Dec 2022

The Case for Wearing Masks Forever

https://archive.vn/UXqc1#selection-867.0-899.14
Last December, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced that it was shortening the recommended isolation period for those with covid-19 to five days. Getting exposed to the virus no longer meant that people needed to quarantine, either, as long as they were fully vaccinated and wore a mask. It was a big moment, and it occurred just as the Omicron variant was surging. Mindy Thompson Fullilove, a professor of urban policy and health at the New School, was livid.
Fullilove, who is Black, has spent her career studying epidemics: first aids, then crack, then multidrug-resistant tuberculosis. She has seen how disease can ravage cities, especially in Black and working-class communities. From the beginning, Fullilove was skeptical of how the federal government handled the coronavirus pandemic. But these new recommendations from the C.D.C., she said, were “flying in the face of the science.” Not long after the announcement, she sent an e-mail to a Listserv called The Spirit of 1848, for progressive public-health practitioners. “Can we have a people’s CDC and give people good advice?” she asked. A flurry of responses came back.

What emerged was the People’s C.D.C.: a ragtag coalition of academics, doctors, activists, and artists who believe that the government has left them to fend for themselves against covid-19. As governments, schools, and businesses have scaled back their covid precautions, the members of the People’s C.D.C. have made it their mission to distribute information about the pandemic—what they see as real information, as opposed to what’s circulated by the actual C.D.C. They believe the C.D.C.’s data and guidelines have been distorted by powerful forces with vested interests in keeping people at work and keeping anxieties about the pandemic down. “The public has a right to a sound reading of the data that’s not influenced by politics and big business,” Fullilove said.

No one is in charge of the People’s C.D.C., and no one’s expertise is valued more than anyone else’s. The problems of “the pandemic and its response are rooted in hierarchical organizations,” Mary Jirmanus Saba, a filmmaker and one of the volunteers, told me. Roughly forty people come to each weekly meeting, but many more are involved. (This spring, after a few of the group’s organizers published a manifesto of sorts in the Guardian, several thousand interested people reached out, Fullilove said.) The group sends out a weekly Weather Report—put together by a team composed, in part, of doctors and epidemiologists—summarizing data about transmission rates, new variants, and death rates. They’ve published explainers on testing, masks, and ventilation, among other topics, typically with a call to action: call the White House, call your congressperson, demand free tests and treatment for all. On their Web site, they recently posted a guide for safer gatherings, which recommends that all events be held outdoors with universal, high-grade masking. The organization has nearly twenty thousand followers on Instagram, and it prides itself as a resource for various groups, including people who are immunocompromised and want to find a way to protect themselves and activists who are trying to lobby their local government for more covid restrictions.
20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Case for Wearing Masks Forever (Original Post) pstokely Dec 2022 OP
Sounds like my kind of site Tetrachloride Dec 2022 #1
it's The New Yorker Celerity Dec 2022 #2
I was thinking of the science at the Peoples CDC Tetrachloride Dec 2022 #8
Paragraphs, please. 3catwoman3 Dec 2022 #3
geezer eyes Skittles Dec 2022 #4
Ordering up an ass kicking for SKITTLES! Yes indeed! madinmaryland Dec 2022 #14
I don't mind wearing a mask, Mr.Bill Dec 2022 #5
Two shots and a booster. Wore a mask as a government job requirement. SlimJimmy Dec 2022 #7
No kidding. Warpy Dec 2022 #9
It almost seems as if every single person on the planet PoindexterOglethorpe Dec 2022 #10
You might be healthy enough to be asymptomatic Warpy Dec 2022 #13
I honestly doubt I've had it at all. PoindexterOglethorpe Dec 2022 #15
Actually, the vaccines were advertised as being able to prevent Covid. SlimJimmy Dec 2022 #17
Yeah, they were, but the virus was mutating very quickly Warpy Dec 2022 #20
I've said since mid pandemic that I'm a mask guy for life now. ZonkerHarris Dec 2022 #6
I havent been sick except once in 3 years. joshcryer Dec 2022 #16
I hope one day not to have to Meowmee Dec 2022 #11
Post removed Post removed Dec 2022 #12
I've tested positive just once since March 2020 EnergizedLib Dec 2022 #18
This was the weirdest article to read, mocking the people while grudgingly acknowledging that they WhiskeyGrinder Dec 2022 #19

Celerity

(43,402 posts)
2. it's The New Yorker
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 02:01 AM
Dec 2022
https://www.newyorker.com/news/annals-of-activism/the-case-for-wearing-masks-forever

snip

I called Tom Frieden, who led the C.D.C. during the Obama years, to see what he made of the People’s C.D.C. He had never heard of the group before I got in touch, but he took a look at their materials ahead of our call. He praised the organization’s guide to self-protection for immunocompromised people, and agreed that some of their recommendations, like universal masking in times of high covid spread, were good ideas in theory. “But is that going to happen? Absolutely not,” he said. The next best thing is to try to get people vaccinated and boosted and to increase access to high-quality masks and Paxlovid. “If you’re giving recommendations that no one’s going to follow, that’s not only nonproductive,” he said. “It’s counterproductive, because that undermines your credibility.”

Mr.Bill

(24,300 posts)
5. I don't mind wearing a mask,
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 02:09 AM
Dec 2022

in fact I've gotten quite used to it. I also don't mind any vaccinations if my doctor recommends it.

But I doubt we will ever see more than 20-30% compliance with those things, because they have made it a partisan political issue.

SlimJimmy

(3,180 posts)
7. Two shots and a booster. Wore a mask as a government job requirement.
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 03:10 AM
Dec 2022

Still contracted covid. You'll have to do more to convince me to "mask forever."

Warpy

(111,267 posts)
9. No kidding.
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 04:22 AM
Dec 2022

I was vaxed and masked when I caught my breakthrough case--at the hospital. It wasn't terrible.

The vaccines are working as advertised for most of us, if we get breakthrough cases, they are mild.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(25,861 posts)
10. It almost seems as if every single person on the planet
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 05:01 AM
Dec 2022

will need to get Covid before it goes away.

I'm vaccinated and twice boosted. No covid so far, but I'm amazed at how many like me still get it. Almost makes me wonder why we bother to vaccinate and boost.

Sigh. And I'm essentially the most healthy person I know. Never get sick. Don't bother with the influenza vaccine -- and I'm not about to suggest you skip it, this is just me -- haven't had flu since something like 1975.

Covid has taught us that individual immune systems vary widely, wildly.

Warpy

(111,267 posts)
13. You might be healthy enough to be asymptomatic
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 04:23 PM
Dec 2022

or you had such a mild case you blew it off as allergies or just a mild case of sniffles. That's how the vaccine works fmost people.

However, it is going to be with us for the foreseeable future, so we might as well get used to the idea.

I get sick with everything, and I get really sick with it. My breakthrough case was a mild, 2 day nuisance. I can live with that easily, which is why I'm not going to cling to masks and social distancing. Occasional illness is a fact of life for most of us and most of us will get only a mild one when a new Covid strain blows through town.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(25,861 posts)
15. I honestly doubt I've had it at all.
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 05:38 PM
Dec 2022

For one thing, I don't get out and about very much. I generally don't bother with a mask anymore, and I'm rarely in any kind of crowds.

SlimJimmy

(3,180 posts)
17. Actually, the vaccines were advertised as being able to prevent Covid.
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 10:40 PM
Dec 2022

That's why I received one to begin with. When I contracted Covid, I spent three days in the hospital with Covid induced myocarditis. Not exactly a mild case. Five months later, I'm still fighting mild chest congestion. So, although I'm pleased your case was mild, but that's not always true. I have to be honest here. Even if offered, I probably won't get a 2nd booster.

Warpy

(111,267 posts)
20. Yeah, they were, but the virus was mutating very quickly
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 11:45 PM
Dec 2022

as it raced through unprotected people across the planet.

It has prevented most serious illnesses except in high risk people (obese, diabetic type II, COPD, advanced age). I call that a win.

As the mutation rate slows, perhaps we will get a vaccine that completely prevents illness. However, I think it will be like the flu, periodic vaccines needing to come out as the damned thing mutates.

This is how science works, new information comes out and new conclusions are reached. People want certainty, they should stick to religion.



joshcryer

(62,276 posts)
16. I havent been sick except once in 3 years.
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 05:50 PM
Dec 2022

And I attribute it solely to masks. The one time I got sick I was in a household with a lot of people who had sickness and they gave it to me (masking in such an environment would've been pointless).

Meowmee

(5,164 posts)
11. I hope one day not to have to
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 05:14 AM
Dec 2022

But with how stupid people are here and with actual science being trashed long ago, I am not optimistic about it here. It’s amazing how so many have forgotten all of those who lost their lives due to malfeasance and who don’t care about those still dying.

Ty for telling us about this group.

Response to pstokely (Original post)

EnergizedLib

(1,895 posts)
18. I've tested positive just once since March 2020
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 10:53 PM
Dec 2022

I wear my mask to this day, rarely ever shake hands with people and have all my shots.

It works.

WhiskeyGrinder

(22,355 posts)
19. This was the weirdest article to read, mocking the people while grudgingly acknowledging that they
Sat Dec 31, 2022, 11:04 PM
Dec 2022

do actually have a point.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Case for Wearing Mask...