General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI don't recall the name of the movie and I don't remember the plot, but one scene made
a lasting impression on me.
In a workingman's bar, two groups began arguing about what music should be played on the jukebox. One man from each table stood and confronted each other as one confidently told the other something like "Don't mess with me or you'll regret it!" He then made menacing arm gestures, lept up and dramatically shouted "KARATE!" as he landed on the floor.
The other man shrugged, broke a chair over the guys head and, as he looked down at him crumpled on the floor, quietly said "chair!" Fight over.
Sometimes simple direct action is preferable to and more effective than the more elaborate and nicer-sounding alternatives.
highplainsdem
(49,044 posts)scene probably conveys what you mean:
rubbersole
(6,735 posts)PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,906 posts)Apparently Ford was not feeling well that day, and essentially said, Fuck it, and pulled the gun.
My sister worked for George Lucas at the time, and that's what she told me.
highplainsdem
(49,044 posts)Nobody will say who said what, Damon said at the roundtable, chiming in.
Somehow, somebody said, Ive got this gun, why dont I just use it?' Marshall recalled.
Whoever the instigator, the idea got the ball rolling quickly. After lunch, we did three shots, and we were two days ahead of schedule, and its the biggest moment in the movie, said Marshall.
That sounds too vague about whose idea it was. Ford was the only person on set who'd've said "I've got this gun" instead of "Indy's got this gun."
PoindexterOglethorpe
(25,906 posts)Alas, she is no longer with us so I can't ask her.
No matter what, I'll stick with whatever the official version is.
highplainsdem
(49,044 posts)explanation is here:
https://www.businessinsider.com/harrison-ford-reddit-ama-2014-4
Btw, neither of those versions seems to be exactly what I read years ago, somewhere. My vague recollection was that it had said Ford had the flu, and I don't remember having read anything then about another whip-fight scene having seemed redundant. But these were two of the articles that turned up tonight, and I can't recall where I first heard about the scene not following the script.
MyOwnPeace
(16,940 posts)sounds like one I'd like to watch!
And, YES, sometimes the 'simple' is the best.......
CoopersDad
(2,198 posts)I tried the Google.
The Google failed me.