General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsDeSantis can now "legally" kidnap people
DeSantis can now grab people off the street and relocate them at will.
So, practically speaking, what's the difference between kidnapping and relocating immigrants and American citizens? I mean immigrants are covered by the Constitution. They have rights. You can't just take them.
Seriously, how is this legal?
Reference link: https://apnews.com/article/ron-desantis-biden-florida-state-government-aa5a860ff3163c8bcdcb8187dfd6f9db
RKP5637
(67,112 posts)of things appearing to think that makes him a manly tough guy and in line for the presidency 2024. The guy is dangerous as hell.
brush
(61,033 posts)a national election. Who's advising this fool?
His little dictator act won't travel.
chicoescuela
(2,647 posts)ymetca
(1,182 posts)has to be greater than simply getting them jobs and housing.
I just got to say --what school indoctrinated him into behaving this way?
Oh yeah, Yale, right? Do they not teach basic human decency there?
I guess not.
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)Florida officials CANNOT "kidnap" migrants. They cannot force migrants to leave the State. The law allows DeSantis to relocate migrants regardless of the State they're in in order to give him cover for the migrants previously flown from Texas. However, none of those migrants was forced to leave, nor does the new law allow anyone to be forced to leave in the future.
angrychair
(11,698 posts)I mean "under false pretense" as in the case of those that got taken to Martha's Vineyard, based on the stories from those immigrants, it was kidnapping by inveiglement. Not sure what happened to that issue and why the fed seems to be letting him do it.
Also, what the law says and what happens out in the real world are very different things.
Still doesn't answer how a state can pass a law to take people from a completely different state and send them to another, completely different state.
brooklynite
(96,882 posts)What it does is allow the State to spend its money moving people from another State to a different State IF THEY CAN BE CONVINCED TO GO. Convincing them to go under false pretenses is unethical; it's not illegal.
KIDNAP (verb): "to take a person away illegally by force"
pnwmom
(110,194 posts)That's what happened to those deposited in Martha's Island. They never consented to going there.
And the fact that this law was passed now doesn't give him RETROACTIVE cover.
edhopper
(37,082 posts)Human Trafficing
angrychair
(11,698 posts)Is incomplete.
kidnapping by inveiglement is kidnapping and has nothing to do with using force. That is what happened, based on reporting, in the case of the people taken to Martha's Vineyard.
Lancero
(3,260 posts)pnwmom
(110,194 posts)scarletlib
(3,560 posts)This state has a lot of serious problems that need to be addressed. Spending money on useless political stunts isnt helping.