Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Atticus

(15,124 posts)
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 08:47 AM Feb 2023

I just listened to a discussion of Russian atrocities on MSNBC and one that was mentioned was the

kidnapping of Ukrainian children and transporting them to Russia without their parents.

Yep! Only monsters would take children from their parents, right?

Right?

42 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I just listened to a discussion of Russian atrocities on MSNBC and one that was mentioned was the (Original Post) Atticus Feb 2023 OP
Right? 2naSalit Feb 2023 #1
Yep 3auld6phart Feb 2023 #13
Who learned that from whom? Dirty Socialist Feb 2023 #2
Birds of a feather wnylib Feb 2023 #22
It's an atrocity as old as humanity itself, crossing all cultures sooner or later. Just because it's Hekate Feb 2023 #31
That historical context makes it easier to see what Trump was doing. yardwork Feb 2023 #36
heard timothy snyder the other day- mopinko Feb 2023 #3
he thinks democracy doesn't work because the guy he installed to destroy our democracy LymphocyteLover Feb 2023 #4
well, you have to admit, he found all the chinks. mopinko Feb 2023 #7
There's always "chinks". paleotn Feb 2023 #20
But Putin doesn't understand democracy. yardwork Feb 2023 #35
+1, part of the makeup of democracy is the people who are chosen as heads *WANT* democracy uponit7771 Feb 2023 #19
Yes, to Putin, that makes sense. Per Snyder. yardwork Feb 2023 #34
Not sure what you're implying here about monsters... who else are you thinking of? LymphocyteLover Feb 2023 #5
Maybe the similarities between putin and trump? SouthernDem4ever Feb 2023 #8
Trump. Bluethroughu Feb 2023 #9
He learned about putting kids in cages from Epstein Farmer-Rick Feb 2023 #11
+1, been saying the "P" tape is a tape of MAGA pedophiles. GQP allegiance to TFG isn't that organic uponit7771 Feb 2023 #21
OK, thanks. Yeah, he's done so many awful things I forgot about that LymphocyteLover Feb 2023 #32
The list is endless. It's easy to not remember everything. Bluethroughu Feb 2023 #41
Indeed! I call him the orange anus... among many other things LymphocyteLover Feb 2023 #42
They've been doing this for a long time... BigmanPigman Feb 2023 #6
same; maybe even earlier Evolve Dammit Feb 2023 #25
I would go with earlier. BigmanPigman Feb 2023 #28
Media was talking about this a few months after invasion. Can't tell you which outlet though. Evolve Dammit Feb 2023 #29
There is a long history to this Beastly Boy Feb 2023 #10
yep. thanks for pointing out that there's more stopdiggin Feb 2023 #26
Isn't Stephan Miller............ 90-percent Feb 2023 #12
Not Stephen Miller the former speech writer for Chump FakeNoose Feb 2023 #40
it was a crime against humanity barbtries Feb 2023 #14
Yes, any regime that kidnaps children is criminal. Boomerproud Feb 2023 #15
Aren't kidnapped kids working in slaughterhouses and factories right in in the ole USA? LakeArenal Feb 2023 #37
A rather barbaric way of fixing Russia's demographic spiral. paleotn Feb 2023 #16
From absolutist Czars to dictatorial Soviets to the dictatorship of oligarchs. wnylib Feb 2023 #23
They clearly can't even hear themselves. onecaliberal Feb 2023 #17
Documented war crimes are just one black eye for Russia. rubbersole Feb 2023 #18
I guess those weren't the children raped and tortured whathehell Feb 2023 #24
Right and Russia does have all the monsters republianmushroom Feb 2023 #27
Russia is clearly planning to use the children as hostages to get the parents to pressure cstanleytech Feb 2023 #30
If any region of the RuZZian Federation wants out of the sanctions, secede from it. roamer65 Feb 2023 #33
Putin and company blue-wave Feb 2023 #38
Indoctrination too PostTruth Feb 2023 #39

Hekate

(91,246 posts)
31. It's an atrocity as old as humanity itself, crossing all cultures sooner or later. Just because it's
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 04:35 PM
Feb 2023

…shameful doesn’t make any one perp unique.

Russia and China are both real good at this re-education camp business in the here and now and back in Soviet days. Neither the Tibetans nor the Uighurs want their children taught only in Chinese with books available only in Chinese, yet this cultural genocide continues. In the US and Canada, indigenous tribes didn’t want their children taken off to English-language boarding schools, either.

At least democracies have the means, motive, and opportunity to try to make amends. Dictatorships make it a crime to even notice.



mopinko

(70,470 posts)
3. heard timothy snyder the other day-
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 09:03 AM
Feb 2023

basically said- to putler, tfg, and esp j6, proves democracy doesnt work, and we arent any better than him. that j6 will never be forgotten in russia.

sadly, i think the world agrees. gonna take a long time to live down that black eye.

LymphocyteLover

(5,684 posts)
4. he thinks democracy doesn't work because the guy he installed to destroy our democracy
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 09:17 AM
Feb 2023

was able to screw up our democracy? Genius.

paleotn

(18,041 posts)
20. There's always "chinks".
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:26 AM
Feb 2023

Democracy is messy. Always has been by its very nature. So, it's not fair to compare it to the supposed predictability of totalitarian regimes. But for all its messiness, it works. And J6 was no where near the greatest test our democracy has faced. 600K+ dead Americans in the Civil War can attest to that.

yardwork

(61,860 posts)
35. But Putin doesn't understand democracy.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 05:44 PM
Feb 2023

Snyder is an expert on Putin, Russia, and the history of Eastern Europe. He knows how they think. Unfortunately, there are plenty of Americans ready to go down the same totalitarian route.

I believe in democracy and I agree with you that it's messy, but that makes us resilient.

uponit7771

(90,380 posts)
19. +1, part of the makeup of democracy is the people who are chosen as heads *WANT* democracy
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:25 AM
Feb 2023

... and the people actually choose them.

Neither of those existed with TFG and MAGA

yardwork

(61,860 posts)
34. Yes, to Putin, that makes sense. Per Snyder.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 05:40 PM
Feb 2023

I trust Snyder on how Putin thinks. So far, he's been right.

LymphocyteLover

(5,684 posts)
5. Not sure what you're implying here about monsters... who else are you thinking of?
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 09:18 AM
Feb 2023

clearly Russia is an evil terrorist state and taking children is a war crime

Bluethroughu

(5,219 posts)
9. Trump.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 09:26 AM
Feb 2023

Remember, he removed them from their parents and put them in cages.

Mililani had worn a jacket that said, "I don't care, do you".

uponit7771

(90,380 posts)
21. +1, been saying the "P" tape is a tape of MAGA pedophiles. GQP allegiance to TFG isn't that organic
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:27 AM
Feb 2023

... and they're bold AF being against abortion, democracy and social security.

Beastly Boy

(9,647 posts)
10. There is a long history to this
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 10:05 AM
Feb 2023

It probably goes further than I am aware of, but this was a long standing practice in the Ottoman empire. If you've heard of Janissars, they were the elite warriors in the Ottoman army. They were overwhelmingly made up of Christian children kidnapped at an early age from conquered territories and raised as Muslims, given the best care and military education to become the most loyal defenders of the Empire.

This is what Putin is trying to emulate. It is far more sinister than just separating children from their parents. It is a tool to rule an empire. The problem with putin is, there will be no empire to rule when Ukrainian children grow up.

stopdiggin

(11,466 posts)
26. yep. thanks for pointing out that there's more
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 12:00 PM
Feb 2023

layers to this than the simple cruelty of 'stealing children.' (although there's plenty of debasement to point to right there)

90-percent

(6,838 posts)
12. Isn't Stephan Miller............
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 10:50 AM
Feb 2023

Isn't Stephan Miller. the former child cruelty tsar for the TFG administration, now a overpaid consultant to pooty-poot? Or was pooty-poot advising him while he was in the mango Mussolini administration?

Biden has reunited about 600 families that had their children kidnapped by the United States of America. Has Tucker eviscerated him for this overwhelming act of kindness yet?

-90% Jimmy

FakeNoose

(33,042 posts)
40. Not Stephen Miller the former speech writer for Chump
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:28 PM
Feb 2023

That Stephen Miller is still in Washington kicking up as much trouble as he can. He's heading up America First Legal, which he says is the right wing's answer to the ACLU.

Here's his website, but don't spend too much time there: https://aflegal.org/

And for heaven's sake don't donate any money!

barbtries

(28,835 posts)
14. it was a crime against humanity
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:07 AM
Feb 2023

when trump did it as well, you are correct.

will justice ever even come close for those families - hm. who?

paleotn

(18,041 posts)
16. A rather barbaric way of fixing Russia's demographic spiral.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:20 AM
Feb 2023

And since when has Russia, in its various forms, ever given a shit about basic human rights? Like never.

It seems the evolution of liberalism (inalienable rights, equality under the law, etc.) just never took in Russia like it did the West for various reasons. The Russian view of such things seems stunted. If you look at it from the view that Russian government is still a medieval regime, their actions begin to make sense. This is something you'd not be surprised of from Ivan the Terrible. They've not evolved much beyond that.

wnylib

(21,906 posts)
23. From absolutist Czars to dictatorial Soviets to the dictatorship of oligarchs.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:42 AM
Feb 2023

Russians don't like democracy.

rubbersole

(6,802 posts)
18. Documented war crimes are just one black eye for Russia.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 11:24 AM
Feb 2023

The immanent collapse of the Russian economy and being the world's biggest pariah state will be pootie's legacy.

cstanleytech

(26,390 posts)
30. Russia is clearly planning to use the children as hostages to get the parents to pressure
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 04:22 PM
Feb 2023

their government to agree to the Russian terms for peace if the want their children back.

roamer65

(36,749 posts)
33. If any region of the RuZZian Federation wants out of the sanctions, secede from it.
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 05:18 PM
Feb 2023

That should be the requirement for removal of sanctions, breakaway and become an independent republic.

The sanctions should become the vehicle for the breakup of the RF.

blue-wave

(4,390 posts)
38. Putin and company
Sat Feb 25, 2023, 05:57 PM
Feb 2023

are genocidal butchers. War crimes trails MUST be held. Open the courts at Nuremberg and dust off the gallows.

Kick in to the DU tip jar?

This week we're running a special pop-up mini fund drive. From Monday through Friday we're going ad-free for all registered members, and we're asking you to kick in to the DU tip jar to support the site and keep us financially healthy.

As a bonus, making a contribution will allow you to leave kudos for another DU member, and at the end of the week we'll recognize the DUers who you think make this community great.

Tell me more...

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I just listened to a disc...