DHS wants "unlimited subpoena authority" to unmask (online) ICE critics

[SamuelTheThird]

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/01/instagram-user-fights-dhs-for-the-right-to-post-ice-sightings-anonymously/


The US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is fighting to unmask the owner of Facebook and Instagram accounts of a community watch group monitoring Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) activity in Pennsylvania.

Defending the right to post about ICE sightings anonymously is a Meta account holder for MontCo Community Watch, John Doe.

Doe has alleged that when the DHS sent a “summons” to Meta asking for subscriber information, it infringed on core First Amendment-protected activity, i.e., the right to publish content critical of government agencies and officials without fear of government retaliation. He also accused DHS of ignoring federal rules and seeking to vastly expand its authority to subpoena information to unmask ICE’s biggest critics online.

“I believe that my anonymity is the only thing standing between me and unfair and unjust persecution by the government of the United States,” Doe said in his complaint.

[cbabe]

1. Unmask. Irony much?

[Maru Kitteh]

2. Hey ice Goons! FUCK. yoU. I curse your lungs for permitting gas exchange.

I harbor resentments against your colon for not twisting. Your mom still wants to give you up for adoption.

[Jack Valentino]

4. Their moms wish they could 'retroactively abort' them !

and so do I

[IcyPeas]

3. You first...

[yellow dahlia]

5. We wondered when this would happen.

[sakabatou]

6. DHS: We're against the First Amendment.