General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsFallows: Your False-Equivalence Guide to the Days Ahead
Two big examples of problematic self-government are upon us. They are of course the possible partial shutdown of the federal government, following the long-running hamstringing of public functions via "the sequester"; and a possible vote not to raise the federal debt ceiling, which would create the prospect of a default on U.S. Treasury debt.
The details are complicated, but please don't lose sight of these three essential points:
As a matter of substance, constant-shutdown, permanent-emergency governance is so destructive that no other serious country engages in or could tolerate it. The United States can afford it only because we are -- still -- so rich, with so much margin for waste and error. Details on this and other items below.*
<snip>
As a matter of journalism, any story that presents the disagreements as a "standoff," a "showdown," a "failure of leadership," a sign of "partisan gridlock," or any of the other usual terms for political disagreement, represents a failure of journalism*** and an inability to see or describe what is going on. For instance: the "dig in their heels" headline you see below, which is from a proprietary newsletter I read this morning, and about which I am leaving off the identifying details.
<snip>
In case the point is not clear yet: there is no post-Civil War precedent for what the House GOP is doing now. It is radical, and dangerous for the economy and our process of government, and its departure from past political disagreements can't be buffed away or ignored. If someone can think of a precedent after the era of John C. Calhoun, shown above in Mathew Brady's famous portrait, let me know.
<snip>
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/09/your-false-equivalence-guide-to-the-days-ahead/280062/
Pretzel_Warrior
(8,361 posts)rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)BlancheSplanchnik
(20,219 posts)Thanks!!
Yeah, I've been nauseated for a while now at the "journalistic" habit of falsely equalizing the blame.
cali
(114,904 posts)and as Fallow's points out the false equivalency we're seeing is disgraceful bullshit.