The Shadow Right
from Jacobin magazine:
The Shadow Right
A familiar progressive narrative in the United States goes something like the following: we could have achieved so much if it werent for the Southern racists, the religious reactionaries, the corrupt billionaires and the undemocratic procedures. There is no question that many American institutions are deeply undemocratic, and purposefully so; it is equally evident that some of those driving the shutdown are, at best, uninterested in the normal democratic practices of convincing others of their views, and, at worst, looking for any means necessary to protect their unjust and unequal privileges. But the recent flurry of effort to decipher just who this right-wing is reproduces a persistent error in the progressive narrative: a failure to address the conservatism of Democrats and the chaos and passivity of the American Left.
For instance, one prevailing question has been why the Republican Party would be willing to engage in apparent anti-business brinksmanship that threatens the stability of global financial markets and draws us closer to another credit crunch? One explanation is that business does not control the Republicans, which is why it can engage in seemingly irrational, ideological political games. Another explanation is that a small group of radicals are acting rationally with respect to their own interests, even if those interests are not the same as the national interest. Michael Lind has made the most persuasive version of this argument, claiming that this is a movement of regional elites or local notables, who find their power threatened by global financial markets and nationalization of social policy. Joe Lowndes reasonably argues this somewhat overlooks the national basis of the movement, and the tacit support of it among the Republican Party as a whole. And Doug Henwood has added the important point that a background class condition for these kinds of political games with American credit-worthiness and the stability of global finance is the increasingly fragmented and short-termist orientation of the capitalist class. .....................(more)
The complete piece is at:
http://jacobinmag.com/2013/10/the-shadow-right/