Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

KurtNYC

(14,549 posts)
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 04:04 PM Jan 2014

These doctors saids the darndest things -- 100 examples

1. Mary K. says “Have a cigarette – It will help loosen the phlegm”
2. Christine P. says “When my son was diagnosed with ADHD, on top of the medication, the pediatrician told me to get him playing video games to help with his focus!”
3. Greta Q. says “A doctor told me to stop breastfeeding because my breasts belonged to my husband and it was time to give them back.”
4. Mindi E. says “When my son was little we found out her was allergic to dairy. I asked what I could give him instead to make sure he was getting the healthy fats for brain development. She told me French fries.”


http://www.thehealthyhomeeconomist.com/doctors-say-darndest-things-100-examples/

Many more outrageous lines at link.
12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

uppityperson

(115,681 posts)
4. ETA not all of those are bad advice. The people writing them? Good grief.
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 04:32 PM
Jan 2014

A lot of these show how communication between people is mediocre at best and why taking time to make sure your patients understand what you say and the reasoning is very important. Yes, some of these are bad advice, but a lot of them make sense.


Melissa Z. says “OBs nurse told me to stop taking my whole-food based, organic prenatals and to “just go get the ones from Costco”. When I questioned how a synthetic supplement could be better than an organic food-based one- she said “you never know what’s in those”!” -


"organic" vitamins need only a small fraction of it from organic sources.

“After having a C-section, (which if I knew what I know now would not have done) my doctor talked to me for 3-5 hours straight on why I should vaccinate my son. Now mind you I am doped up and she tried to use that to her advantage. She used every scared tactic she could. After I would not budge, she ended the conversation saying that people like me is a threat to her financial security!”


An doctor talked 3-5 hours straight on? Uh. Huh.

Dierdre B. says “Last week my child’s Dr. told me that I should get my kids the flu shot, which didn’t surprise me. Then she told me a child under her care had just died from H1N1, and it was so ironic because he had just gotten the flu shot a couple weeks before. Apparently another person at home who wasn’t vaccinated got the flu and the kid got a megadose of flu germs and it killed him. I’m still scratching my head. Did she just tell me a child died after getting the vaccine, but that I should have my kids get the vaccine too? Um…. No thanks.”


Yes, you can get the flu after getting the shot if you were exposed BEFORE you got the vaccine.

“Skim milk, they don’t need the calories.”


True often, depending on who you are talking about.

Melissa B. says “Before being diagnosed as a Celiac the doctor told me “Don’t worry about it, it will get better when it gets better” this is after not holding down any food down for 3 years straight."


She retained no food for 3 years straight? Breatharian?

“My uncle was just diagnosed with a massive lung tumor and his doctor told him to keep drinking soda and eating sweets because he will need the nourishment during treatment.”


As odd as it may seem, calories are important. Good nutrition is important, but yes, just plain calories are also.

frogmarch

(12,160 posts)
5. "Give her a sip of kerosene for that cough."
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 04:37 PM
Jan 2014

That is what an old doctor in Custer, So Dak once prescribed for my 1-year-old daughter's bronchitis. He said a sip of lighter fluid would work too.

Instead, I drove all the way to Hot Springs to find a different doctor.

laundry_queen

(8,646 posts)
7. I think most people have a list of their own
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 05:31 PM
Jan 2014

God knows I do, especially with regards to pregnancy, birth and kids. Geez some doctors are so stupid.

Although, after reading some of the list, it's not always the doctors that are stupid. Plenty of stupid patients too.

My favorite was a pediatrician who told me to stop breastfeeding my 6 month old because her head was overly large. These were his exact words. "You need to stop breastfeeding, her head is too big for her body."

I knew what he was probably trying to get at - malnourished kids often have large head circumferences as compared with their body because the head will always grow at the expense of the body in children during times of hunger. MY daughter, however, was not malnourished. She was breastfeeding plenty, peeing and pooping plenty, she didn't have any signs of malabsorption (no soft stools or floaty poop), she was super active, already rolling everywhere and dragging herself around. She was also eating jarred fruits and veggies. I had given her rice cereal but she projectile vomited every time she was given any baby cereal so, on my regular doctor's advice, we took her off it. She wasn't even low on the growth charts at that point, she was around the 50th percentile at that time. Never mind baby pictures of her father reveal a skinny baby with a giant head.

The ped was upset when I told him I was not going to quit breastfeeding, even after telling him what I just wrote here. I had plenty of milk and my milk was not the issue. I did continue to get flack for my daughter's weight from other doctors and nurses - she dropped on the growth charts as she got more mobile and active, going from 50th percentile to 15th over a year and then to 5th percentile at 3 years old. Later on, I found out, she was measured against old charts that were 90% formula fed babies and that current charts reflect the differences in growth patterns between bottle and breastfed babies. Breastfed babies often gain quickly in the beginning and then level off, which she had done (born at 25th percentile, 65th percentile at 4 months). Wish I'd have had that chart when my oldest was a skinny baby. She's still very thin and small boned. She's a size 2 at 16. And she still has a big head - but not as big as her sisters' heads...they get that from their dad.

Oh yeah, that and I'd never be able to birth a baby vaginally (after a C-section with my first), that my pelvis was just too small and deformed. Had my 2nd vaginally 3 years later. Her head was quite a bit bigger too. So much for my crappy pelvis.


Ack! I nearly forgot - the absolute BEST one, bar none, was when I was 7 years old I ended up with a horrible ingrown nail in my thumb that became extremely infected, only we didn't know it was the nail at first because my entire thumb swelled up and oozed green pus. The doctor told my parents that I must be sucking my thumb too much. My parents declared I had never sucked my thumb in my life, not even as a baby and the doctor said I must be doing it in private and that my parents were likely in denial. WTF? 2nd opinion revealed an infected ingrown nail (DUH) and a course of antibiotics and a lancing and cleaning relieved the infection.

KurtNYC

(14,549 posts)
8. with the internet I think a lot more doctors are getting second guessed by their customers
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 05:42 PM
Jan 2014

and they hate it but it is MY body or MY kid so with apologies I am going to continue to ask questions. I have had the luxury of going to a doctor who I went to school with so I can say anything to him.

Taking my dogs to vets has taught me how wrong yet confident a doctor can be. One told me that my male had Lyme disease. I said "he has had the vaccinations" so he runs a blood test. Negative for Lyme so he says "the test is wrong" and shoots him with penicillin and makes me pay for 2 months of antibiotics. Then the vet points to my female and asks "what about him? why is he here?" I said that's a female. 2 minutes later, "what about HIM?" 2 days later the symptoms were back and I went to my regular vet -- strained left front wrist, probably from jumping and landing or rough play with his sister.

It has taught me that I need to be my own advocate when dealing with health care pros.

The Magistrate

(95,264 posts)
9. One Of My Grandsons, Sir, Had An ADHD Diagnosis
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 06:00 PM
Jan 2014

It was observable over time that playing video games did help him learn to focus, and helped him get the hang of reading as well....

KurtNYC

(14,549 posts)
10. as I re-read the list I see more than a few that seem to
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 06:40 PM
Jan 2014

be simply a blunt and unexpected way of addressing an issue.

The Magistrate

(95,264 posts)
11. It Kind Of Surprised Me, Sir, To See It Happen
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 06:42 PM
Jan 2014

But it did get him used to sitting in one place and concentrating, and in many of the games, in the set up and equipping phases, he had to make sense out of text and type, or he could not play....

Heddi

(18,312 posts)
12. how much is "doctors say" vs "Kook moms hear what they want to hear?"
Wed Jan 15, 2014, 08:06 PM
Jan 2014

I'm an RN.

I have had conversations with patients. Full on detailed conversations about diet, nutrition, medications, treatments. With the MD in the room. The patient then goes to "repeat" what we just said and it's like they were listening to a completely different conversation. No, I never said that. No, I didn't say that, either. Neither did the Dr.

I've heard MD's tell patients something...I'm going to give you a medicine for your blood pressure,...something innocuous. I go in teh room to give BP med, patient says "oh he just told me he was going to give me a medicine for my red and swollen leg and my headache." No, he didn't.

Are people lying? I think the mom's at that website are. Or they're exaggerating to make a pretty stupid point about how AWWFUUULLL doctors are and how SUPER DUPER HIPSTER SMART they are.

Most patients, though, hear what they want to hear. Or what they think they should hear. Hour long conversations about death and dying, hospice and code status....like it never happened. "So mom's gonna be okay, then?" NOOOOO WE JUST TOLD YOU MOM IS DYING AND THERE IS NO CURE FOR HER DEATH.

The kooks at that website, though. Jesus christ. What a joy they must be to live with.

As for the woman who was "OMG! My totes stupid OBGYN asked what BIRTH CONTROl i wanted after she TIED MY TUBES THE WEEK BEFORE omg! What a tard...." Had dearheart read anything other than facebook blogs about mommyhood, she'd do a bit of research and realize that depending on the type of "tube tying" (hint: there's more than one method of tubal ligation, and sometimes they're not "tied", they're cut, or burned, or have little tubes that block up in them), that there is a healing period that one must go through before the tubes are TOTALLY tied. So asking what BC a woman wants to be on while her tubes may still be functional enough to cause an egg to travel down that winding path isn't stupid. It's good medicine. It's what a doctor SHOULD ask.

But "I Know better than them" mommy doesn't know that. All she knows is that she's TONS smarter than a specialist MD, who spent at least 4 years in undergrad, 4 years in med school, and another 4-7 years in their specialty. I mean, if you read it on Pinterest or facebook or a random blog, it's true. Unlike the things you hear from licensed professionals who spend nearly 2 decades training for their speciality....

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»These doctors saids the d...