Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

xchrom

(108,903 posts)
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 08:31 AM Feb 2014

The Christian Right's Bizarre Delusions of Persecution

http://www.alternet.org/christian-rights-bizarre-delusions-persecution



Christian conservatives feel aggrieved and they want to be heard. The problem is that their specific grievance---that everyone else hurts their feelings by not admitting we’re inferior---kind of sounds, well, hard to sympathize with. They need something snappier, a reason to claim that they are being oppressed by “anti-Christian bigotry”. The only problem with that is that in a majority Christian nation, most people are actually pretty accepting and even admiring of Christianity. Even if they disagree with right wing Christianity, they don’t do so because it’s Christian but because it’s conservative. Being a Christian is a privileged position in American society; that makes it really hard to claim you’re being oppressed.

Inevitably, then, the temptation to fudge starts to seep in, to exaggerate slights or invent paranoid conspiracy theories about how not getting enough praise and accolades for being Christian is an attempt to shove them out. But when that doesn’t work, well, sometimes it helps to deliberately provoke a situation where someone pretty much has to confront you, so that you can lie and say it’s because you’re a Christian. Indeed, it’s starting to become a pattern that goes something like this:

1) Enter into a community that is, by its nature, inclusive of people of various faiths and beliefs.

2) Break some common rule everyone is expected to follow.

3) Get corrected or punished for breaking the rule.

4) Squeal about how it’s because you’re a Christian and they’re bigots and oppressors.

5) By the time the truth gets out, your story will be an urban legend spread far and wide, and your fellow conservative Christians will never really know the facts.

The recent uproar over the best song Oscar nominee that was shortly dropped from the nominee list after it was released is a classic of the form. The Christian right press is up in arms, claiming that the Oscars are exhibiting an “ anti-Christian bias” by yanking the nomination for the title song for the movie Alone Yet Not Alone. The movie, besides being one of those D-list evangelical films made for very little money that barely touches the theaters before making most of its money on the church screening circuit, appears also be a stomach-turning apologia for the racism Europeans exhibited towards Native Americans during the 18th century. Regardless of the content, however, the song was booted because the composer, Bruce Broughton, broke the Academy rules by exploiting his knowledge of who was voting in the category and using that knowledge to alert over 70 of them that he was the composer. He denies it was campaigning, but it’s hard to imagine that there’s any other way to interpret an email that says it is a “request for your consideration”.
33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Christian Right's Bizarre Delusions of Persecution (Original Post) xchrom Feb 2014 OP
Indeed. Laelth Feb 2014 #1
I like "nothing in particular". coldbeer Feb 2014 #8
If you're not a theist, you're an atheist. That's what nothing is. valerief Feb 2014 #11
If you do not believe in "anything in particular" by definition you are an atheist. Moostache Feb 2014 #14
Except that atheism has turned into a belief system starroute Feb 2014 #22
I disagree. Atheists affirmatively don't believe. I'm in the meh crowd. Shrike47 Feb 2014 #27
If you don't believe what they believe, YOU have attacked them. JoePhilly Feb 2014 #2
My sect is the only chosen one! Your god is false! ChairmanAgnostic Feb 2014 #3
Methodist: A Baptist who wears a suit and tie to breakfast. marble falls Feb 2014 #10
Fugg 'em malaise Feb 2014 #4
The Myth of Christian Persecution SecularMotion Feb 2014 #5
"X-tians" identify with persecution because it makes $$$ for them. Moostache Feb 2014 #16
I do not remember being taught to think of myself as a persecuted Christian. I was taught that I jwirr Feb 2014 #23
Bruce Broughton cheated, his testimony is his lack of ethics. Bluenorthwest Feb 2014 #6
That's qualifications for being a deacon Mopar151 Feb 2014 #19
Their views were summed up by a recent bumper sticker kairos12 Feb 2014 #7
Sign Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2014 #13
"God Hates Everyone but ME - so if you'll be MY friend, I'll tell Him you're okay..." haele Feb 2014 #29
Right. It's a Protection Racket. Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2014 #30
Not to mention a classic abusive relationship theHandpuppet Feb 2014 #32
+ underpants Feb 2014 #9
Despite the careful exclusion of any of the deluded that might give the author some money, Egalitarian Thug Feb 2014 #12
Agreed 100%... Moostache Feb 2014 #17
I actually had an evangafundie tell me... Adrahil Feb 2014 #15
If they would do something useful -- oh, like helping people Politicub Feb 2014 #18
This is an important issue and needs much more exposure. Thanks for posting. mountain grammy Feb 2014 #20
I'd go out of my way to help a Christian following in the footsteps of Jesus. raouldukelives Feb 2014 #21
It's their breathlessly gullible rumor mill being used as a political tool JHB Feb 2014 #24
I'm a Christian and I'm sure as hell not persecuted Tree-Hugger Feb 2014 #25
They have been doing it for thousands of years Major Nikon Feb 2014 #26
If my fellow Christians in this nation want to see persecution there are plenty of places hrmjustin Feb 2014 #28
same pattern as the rich who think they're persecuted--maybe it's an echo-chamber effect? MisterP Feb 2014 #31
I have seen a great deal of this delusion Gothmog Feb 2014 #33

coldbeer

(306 posts)
8. I like "nothing in particular".
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:20 AM
Feb 2014

I do not feel like an atheist and I do not
feel agnostic. "Religion" to me is like
the "American People". Nothing.

valerief

(53,235 posts)
11. If you're not a theist, you're an atheist. That's what nothing is.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:46 AM
Feb 2014

It isn't what the theists tell us it is.

Moostache

(9,897 posts)
14. If you do not believe in "anything in particular" by definition you are an atheist.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:51 AM
Feb 2014

Atheism is NOT a belief system. It is a lack of belief in a deity.

Do you believe in Zeus? Apollo? Ra? Allah? Jehovah? Yahweh? Krishna? Thor? Odin? Isis? Osiris?
No? Congratulations, you've reached the age of reason and you are most likely an atheist regardless of labels or names others try to use.

The only reason so many people maintain the stereotype of "atheist = child molesting freak in a trenchcoat exposing themselves on dark streets" (and the subsequent aversion to be associated or named as "atheist&quot is that so many people shrink from the label as if the stereotype were true.

I have not believed in "gawd" or gods since I was little more than a child and realized that the stories of Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny bore about as much reality as those of Noah or Abraham or Jeebus.

But, if it makes you happy to deny what your beliefs define you as, then by all means do what you have to do...

starroute

(12,977 posts)
22. Except that atheism has turned into a belief system
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 11:39 AM
Feb 2014

Or at least the New Atheists are -- see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Atheism.

And in the same way as the loud-mouthed, self-dramatizing Christians have taken over the public face of Christianity, the combative, billboard-erecting Atheists have taken over from the "whatever" types.





 

SecularMotion

(7,981 posts)
5. The Myth of Christian Persecution
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 08:59 AM
Feb 2014
Christians of all denominations maintain that the Early Church was widely persecuted. They state that in the first few centuries after the death of the Messiah, Christians were hunted, tortured and killed just for following Christ. This persecution is believed to have begun with the deaths of Stephen, the Apostles, and then the Christians persecuted under a long succession of cruel and vindictive Roman emperors.

This history of early Christianity establishes Christianity as a religion of innocent sufferers; as a church beleaguered and under attack. In periods of crisis or perceived crisis Christians of all stripes have returned to this stereotype of the early church in order to find themselves and understand their experiences. This is true even today: during the debate over the HHS mandate last year, a Catholic Bishop said that President Obama was attacking Christians just like the Roman emperors, Hitler and Stalin had. In August 2011 Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum publicly complained that the "gay community ... had gone out on a jihad" against him. In the course of the last election, similar statements were made by Mitt Romney, Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck and Bill O'Reilly, to name but a few.

This is not just a case of election-day banter or political nastiness. Just recently, Fox News host Todd Starnes accused NBC of persecuting Christians because of a skit that aired on Saturday Night Live. The accusation may appear flimsy, but the advertising boycott of NBC that resulted was not. The rhetorical power of persecution language is very real.

These evaluations of modern society and Christianity's place in it trace themselves back to the early Church. Christianity is responsible for changing the way that we think about persecution. Were it not for the belief that early Christians were persecuted, Christian identity would not be so intimately linked to the experience of persecution. It is precisely for this reason that understanding the history is so important.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/candida-moss/the-myth-of-christian-persecution_b_2901880.html

Moostache

(9,897 posts)
16. "X-tians" identify with persecution because it makes $$$ for them.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:56 AM
Feb 2014

I have a low opinion of anyone who hurls "...but I'm a Christian" out of their mouth for any reason, but the ones who go begging for dollars in Jeebus' name are particularly infuriating...

If there were no money in religion, it would have disappeared forever hundreds of years ago. TAX THE CHURCHES AND SYNAGOGUES AND MOSQUES!!!!

jwirr

(39,215 posts)
23. I do not remember being taught to think of myself as a persecuted Christian. I was taught that I
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 11:44 AM
Feb 2014

was lucky to be influenced by His teachings. By the way even in a semi-conservative church my family were liberals. Most of our congregation were since it was in the 40s.

What I have found happening now is that the conservative churches do not even consider my church and others like us to be Christians mainly because we do not believe in their end days take over the government theology. There is a lot of other things we do not agree on also: literal interpretation of the Bible, baptism, women's rights, etc.

My faith is personal and I do not have to or want to force it on others like they do. The only post regarding religion here that I have done are either to explain where I come from or to "persecute" the righties by disagreeing with them.

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
6. Bruce Broughton cheated, his testimony is his lack of ethics.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:10 AM
Feb 2014

Then he lied, claiming religious persecution. He's a cheat and a liar and he cheats and lies within his own community in order to obtain for himself praise and career advantage. So he's a greedy cheating liar.

kairos12

(12,892 posts)
7. Their views were summed up by a recent bumper sticker
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:13 AM
Feb 2014

in the community. The message displayed: "Jesus Loves Me, He Hates You"

Yep.

haele

(12,688 posts)
29. "God Hates Everyone but ME - so if you'll be MY friend, I'll tell Him you're okay..."
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 01:49 PM
Feb 2014

That's pretty much what most evangelicals I come across promote.
No matter what they say, it usually comes down to:

"Give me attention, let me tell you what to think, always agree with me no matter what I actually do - oh, and maybe even give me your time and money. You need to give me the respect I deserve as the bestest friend of the Almighty, before I'll tell God not to send you into the eternal firey pit he's sending the rest of My Enemies to."

Yup, indeedy, they believe in the Loving God of Creation. The God they follow that tells you it's your fault you were poor, hurt, stolen from, or murdered because you were such a disappointment and needed to be punished. Even if you used the talents and free will He supposedly gave you, or when you lived the life you were born with, the one He supposedly made for you, because you still disobeyed some ancient "rule book" that was written by a heirarchy from an alien culture (NOT EXTRA-TERRESTRIAL; but a culture where life, time-sense, technology, opportunities, standards, and society is alien to those who live now - no matter where they are in the world).

Haele



theHandpuppet

(19,964 posts)
32. Not to mention a classic abusive relationship
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 06:00 PM
Feb 2014

1. Do everything I say, without question. I don't have to explain myself and I am never wrong.

2. If you do exactly everything I say without question, I won't punish you.

3. If something horrible should happen anyway, you obviously did not follow rule one as I commanded.

4. To get back in my good graces, get on your knees, proclaim yourself unworthy and beg for my forgiveness.

5. If you follow rule four I may forgive you but punish you anyway as a reminder that I am the one in control. Or perhaps I will curse your children or your children's children, so you may carry the burden of guilt for your own faults.

6. Unworthy as you are, if you have supplicated yourself sufficiently and recognized that it is I who gave you life and allow you to live, after you're dead you may join me in heaven where you can bask in the glory of my greatness and power and worship me for eternity.

7. Failing to follow my rules will result in eternal damnation and torture. You'll only wish you were really dead.

Nice.



 

Egalitarian Thug

(12,448 posts)
12. Despite the careful exclusion of any of the deluded that might give the author some money,
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:46 AM
Feb 2014

the religious are going into panic mode.

Their old standby response to reason, murder and mayhem, doesn't fly anymore and appeals to reason are obviously going to fail (yes Virginia, there really is an all seeing, all knowing, omnipotent man in the sky watching everything all the time, but he's just always broke), so now that people all over the world are coming out and calling them on the bullshit they've been buying for millennia, they are starting to freak out.

Put yourself in their place. If too many people don't share the delusion, they will lose the support they have to maintain the delusion. It's especially hard on the "nice" ones, they are beset on all sides. They have the crazy-mean evangelicals on one side working hard every day to counter every precept of the story, then there are the heathens and heretics that choose to follow some other false god, and now they've even lost the tacit government approval that allowed the old fashioned torture-murder-terrorize tactics that were always in the toolbox when needed.

What's a well-intentioned dissociative to do?

 

Adrahil

(13,340 posts)
15. I actually had an evangafundie tell me...
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 09:54 AM
Feb 2014

... that I was interfering with his first Amendment rights to free exercise of religion by opposing his desire to prohibit certain bahaviors he finds religiously offensive (gay marriage, in this case).

There's no reasoning with someone like that.

Politicub

(12,165 posts)
18. If they would do something useful -- oh, like helping people
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 10:01 AM
Feb 2014

instead of berating those who are not in their mold of perfect, people may give a crap.

There is no whinier bunch, and thank god (harharhar) the number of pious people in the US is quickly shrinking.

mountain grammy

(26,663 posts)
20. This is an important issue and needs much more exposure. Thanks for posting.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 11:06 AM
Feb 2014

Time to stand up to these bullies.

raouldukelives

(5,178 posts)
21. I'd go out of my way to help a Christian following in the footsteps of Jesus.
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 11:20 AM
Feb 2014

I wouldn't have to go out of my way often.
In reality the only attacks I see against Christians are by other self-proclaimed Christians who have no problem killing people for money, voting against the interests of the least and turning a blind eye to massive suffering perpetrated in their name by corporate investments. Those are the ones most responsible for making a mockery of their own professed faith.

JHB

(37,163 posts)
24. It's their breathlessly gullible rumor mill being used as a political tool
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 12:41 PM
Feb 2014

Remember when their gossip about how Proctor & Gamble's moon logo signified the company was a tool of the Devil? And P&G eventually changed it just so they'd go chase a squirrel somewhere else?

How the name of the band KISS stood for "Knights In Service of Satan"?

That same mechanism for telling themselves that the devil is always lurking about, ready to pounce if they let their fervor waver in the slightest, is at work. They already had an outrage mill, it's just that now it's being used to sell "anti-Christian bias".

Not to mention conservative evangelicals' rhetorical bait-and-switch: blurring the difference between all Christians and their version of Christianity.

Tree-Hugger

(3,370 posts)
25. I'm a Christian and I'm sure as hell not persecuted
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 12:56 PM
Feb 2014

I get into this fight with fellow Christians. Mind you, I'm Catholic and I have some pagan leanings as well, so many evangelicals already think I'm satan's bride.

An evangelical friend will say Christian's are persecuted. So, I asked her how often she feels afraid to go to church. She is not. I asked her how many times she has had to pass protesters outside of her church telling her that her religion is wrong, she is going to hell, etc. She has never experienced anything like that. I asked her how often she worries that her faith will interfere with her getting hired for a job. Never. I asked her how often people graffiti her house with slurs against her religion. Never.

Their idea of persecution is having to live with the fact that not everyone believes the same thing as you.

I have pointed out that the only time I have ever felt persecuted for my Christian faith was when people would stand outside my Catholic church and hand out Chick Tracks (spelling? it's those crazy ass booklets) that were geared towards Catholics and how we're going to hell for the Virgin Mary and the belief in the Eucharist.....

Major Nikon

(36,827 posts)
26. They have been doing it for thousands of years
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 01:24 PM
Feb 2014

Much of the early Christian stories of persecution were simply made up.

 

hrmjustin

(71,265 posts)
28. If my fellow Christians in this nation want to see persecution there are plenty of places
Fri Feb 7, 2014, 01:32 PM
Feb 2014

on this planet that Christians are actually being persecuted.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Christian Right's Biz...