Alito's Mayhem
from the Progressive:
Alito's Mayhem
By Philip Mattera
Is Justice Samuel Alito really that clueless? During the 2010 State of the Union address, he nervously mouthed the words not true when President Obama warned that the Supreme Courts Citizens United ruling would allow corporate special interests to dominate U.S. elections. A few days ago, Alito wrote an outrageous opinion in the Hobby Lobby case affirming the religious rights of corporations but insisting this would not do much other than prevent a few companies from having to include several kinds of birth control in their health insurance plans.
Alitos claim about the narrow scope is already beginning to unravel. Although the written opinion suggested that only four types of contraception such as IUDs that religious zealots view as tantamount to abortion would be affected, the Court subsequently ordered lower courts to rehear cases in which employers sought to deny coverage for any form of birth control.
Business owners with other religious views contrary to federal policy will undoubtedly soon speak up. This is exactly what Justice Ginsburg warned about in her powerful dissent, calling Alitos opinion a decision of startling breadth that enables commercial enterprises, including corporations, along with partnerships and sole proprietorships, [to] opt out of any law (saving only tax laws) they judge incompatible with their sincerely held religious beliefs.
Alito was apparently so shaken by Ginsburgs accusation that he felt a need to deny it at length. The denial is not only unconvincing, it is clumsy and takes Alito into some strange territory for a supposed business-friendly conservative. ...............(more)
The complete piece is at:
http://progressive.org/news/2014/07/187766/alitos-mayhem#sthash.djCh2XCE.dpuf