Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Whiskeytide

(4,461 posts)
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:38 PM Oct 2014

The Dallas events re Ebola are actually weirdly reassuring, and are strong evidence ...

...that we will NOT have an outbreak in the US.

First, prayers and good vibes to the nurses who are infected, and all hope is extended to them for a full recovery.

But here's why I'm beginning to understand what's happening:

All Americans have heard or understood about this virus for the last 20-30 years is that it is super contagious, incurable and practically un-treatable, wipes out entire villages so fast that it doesn't usually spread beyond the bush (the old "it's so deadly it's not a threat to us" meme), but ... (dah, dah, DAHHHH) if it ever gets going here, it would be a nightmare pandemic. We all saw the movie, right?

Fortunately for us, it was always a problem in Africa. Meh. Lemme know when it gets here and has infected a Kardashian. Then I'll give a shit.

Now - it has shown up at a Dallas hospital. A DALLAS HOSPITAL!!! I think Dallas is in the US!! In fact, I'm pretty sure it is. Uh oh. We're all gonna die!!! Death by hemorrhagic fever. What a way to go!!! Worst day ever! Did you see that freakin' movie?!!!

But then, the CDC and other "experts" - even the ones here at DU (the most trusted source of civilization ending events) - start telling us to chill. Don't panic. Its not that contagious, and we're not likely to have an outbreak in the US. WTF???? How does that jive with what we think we know about this bug? I mean, shit, we ALL saw the damn movie, right?!!!

So - the natural conclusion is to assume the government and health care experts are lying to us. We ARE all gonna die a horrible, bleeding from the eyes death, but they don't want a panic on their hands until they have the quarantine camps and the coffins and the corpse disposal ovens and all that shit ready for the carnage. Donald Southerland is in charge of it all! Damn. I wish I HADN'T seen that scary-ass movie!!!!!

But what's the evidence telling us?

So far - NONE of Duncan's pre-hospitalization contacts have been diagnosed. Not even the fiancee and other occupants of the apartment who had CLOSE contact. I know we're not past the possible incubation period - but we're well past the likely incubation period, and every hour that passes looks good for those people.

But then, two health care professionals are diagnosed. All within a week of Duncan's death. HOLY SHIT!!!!! Get me some plastic, duct tape, canned goods and ammo (in case someone tries to take my plastic, duct tape and canned goods), I'm running for the hills!!!!!!

But here's the thing. The apparent inconsistency of the pre-hospital contacts seeming to be clear, and the nurses contracting the disease, tells us a lot. This disease, like most viruses, has varying potential for transmission - depending upon when you have contact with someone who is infected. Well, duh. I should have thought of that before, but I was too busy putting out my hair.

In the early stages, the virus is hard to transmit. It is fragile outside the body, and you have to come into direct contact with the bodily fluids to contract it. In other words, you've got to go swimming in vomit and feces to get it. Thus - none of Duncan's pre-hospitalization contacts seem to have it. And remember, Duncan was sent home after he started having symptoms - and still it's not looking like his contacts at the apartment have been infected. The virus was certainly there, but not in high concentrations.

But in the later, final stages of the disease, apparently the infected patient's body is quite literally crawling with the Ebola virus. It is still fragile outside the body - but the sheer numbers, as well as the increased presence of contaminated bodily fluids, make transmission significantly more likely. Thus, we have nurses that are caring for Duncan become infected - because they were there to the bitter end with a patient who was spewing high concentrations of Ebola via explosive diarrhea and projectile vomiting.

Now - don't get me wrong. There were lots of problems with our state of preparedness - from the top down - and it should not have gone down like it has. We HAVE to get better at handling this. But it does seem to explain why the nurses were infected when the fiancee was not. It was the stage of the disease at the time of exposure.

In Africa, the sick are more likely than not cared for by friends and family until death, or at least until close to the end stage of the disease. Then the bodies are handled by friends and family through the burial process. Thus, we have untrained and unprotected exposures at the most contagious stage of infection. Those people are, figuratively at least, swimming in Ebola. Its no wonder there is an outbreak in West Africa that will get much worse before it gets better. And every country on the planet needs be pitching in there to turn it back. THAT would do more to protect all of us than all the plastic and duct tape at the all the Walmart stores in the world.

In the US, by contrast, most (most) of those who get sick end up at a hospital much sooner. They are likely to be isolated and undergoing treatment before the final stages of the disease are reached. Transmission from casual contact prior to hospitalization (like on an airplane, or from a doorknob) or even in the early stages of hospitalization (like in a waiting room or at a Doc-in-the-Box) is just not very likely. Possible, I suppose, but not likely. I don't think we have a single well documented case of such casual transmission. Not that I have seen, anyway.

Does it mean there can't be an outbreak in the US? No. We can all imagine nightmare scenarios (personally, mine is that when Duncan's vomit was power washed from the sidewalk into the sewer, it infected a couple of rats, and now there are millions of rats teeming with Ebola about to come streaming into the streets of Dallas any minute now - wouldn't THAT make a great movie??).

But I now think I understand why the experts say it's not likely to result in an outbreak in the US. It's not - and that's based on how it has played out in Dallas despite the mistakes and incompetence. The biggest risk in the US is to healthcare professionals, and they need to get up to speed quickly. And people need to get themselves in for treatment (that's a whole other topic, I know, I know).

Hopefully it stops at these two nurses. But it seems safe to say that the "Duncan as pt. zero" scenario is, for now, most likely contained in the healthcare arena. For the general public, that's weirdly reassuring.

My $0.02. Now, I'm going to go put on my flame resistant suit.



30 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Dallas events re Ebola are actually weirdly reassuring, and are strong evidence ... (Original Post) Whiskeytide Oct 2014 OP
What do you think will happen if this shuts down our healthcare facilities? B2G Oct 2014 #1
No. It might strain it, but ... Whiskeytide Oct 2014 #3
I can't find any indication that the hospital has been shut down, hedgehog Oct 2014 #5
If it shut down a facility it would be temporary upaloopa Oct 2014 #8
Hospital was not shut down... FloriTexan Oct 2014 #23
The hospital shut down their ER temporarily LiberalArkie Oct 2014 #26
K and R etherealtruth Oct 2014 #2
Again with the good sense? What has DU come to when people post good sense? hedgehog Oct 2014 #4
I know get the red out Oct 2014 #7
lower viral loads can have incubation periods of up to 42 days. ecstatic Oct 2014 #6
Where is your Ebola contact going to happen? upaloopa Oct 2014 #11
It's not really about me right now, but it could be, if the carefree strategy ecstatic Oct 2014 #14
Everyone? How many is that? upaloopa Oct 2014 #18
The people they've identified as potentially exposed or infected. ecstatic Oct 2014 #20
Well, I can understand that. But... Whiskeytide Oct 2014 #13
So far, the unprepared staff (Dallas) are the ones to contract Ebola from mnhtnbb Oct 2014 #9
Some folks just want to be scared or want to scare others. FLPanhandle Oct 2014 #10
I Have Same Feeling-4 Physicians/Nurses and a Caregiver Stallion Oct 2014 #12
Exactly. n/t Whiskeytide Oct 2014 #15
Thank you. The disease is damned hard to catch Warpy Oct 2014 #16
Still a good movie, though... Whiskeytide Oct 2014 #19
Thank you. Bookmarking this thread! freshwest Oct 2014 #17
Not my first virus scare. For some people, fear is a sort of talisman, if they are afraid enough Bluenorthwest Oct 2014 #21
Oh, Whiskeytide, jen63 Oct 2014 #22
Let me guess--Your Real Life Name is Pollyanna Demeter Oct 2014 #24
I was just thinking this morning AwakeAtLast Oct 2014 #25
Well said, my sentiments exactly. marble falls Oct 2014 #27
I'm truly fortunate. Hatchling Oct 2014 #28
A whisper of sanity in a day of chaos. 7wo7rees Oct 2014 #29
I hope freepers use the duct tape and plastic wrap IronLionZion Oct 2014 #30
 

B2G

(9,766 posts)
1. What do you think will happen if this shuts down our healthcare facilities?
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:43 PM
Oct 2014

One patient has essentially shut down Presbyterian Hospital.

And why would the progression after that be different here than in, say, Liberia?

Whiskeytide

(4,461 posts)
3. No. It might strain it, but ...
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:49 PM
Oct 2014

... not shut it down. Again, if thousands of cases start showing up simultaneously, we're in trouble. That's one of those nightmare scenarios. But Duncan has triggered two cases so far among the medical team that cared for him. There might be more, but it seems likely they, too, would also be in the healthcare field. As long as that's the scenario, we'll be okay because the healthcare professionals will, eventually, get better at handling it.

hedgehog

(36,286 posts)
5. I can't find any indication that the hospital has been shut down,
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:53 PM
Oct 2014

but if so, it wasn't Ebola that shut it down but a piss poor management of an Ebola case.

upaloopa

(11,417 posts)
8. If it shut down a facility it would be temporary
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:56 PM
Oct 2014

and you still have to come in contact with the fluids of the patient. I think that is what most people don't get. None of will ever be in contact with the fluids of a patient.

FloriTexan

(838 posts)
23. Hospital was not shut down...
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:57 PM
Oct 2014

I know someone birthing a baby there as we speak, and yes, that concerns me a bit; but, in my most humble opinion, it would have been much worse if Duncan had gone to Parkland Hospital.

ecstatic

(32,701 posts)
6. lower viral loads can have incubation periods of up to 42 days.
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:54 PM
Oct 2014

So unfortunately, I don't feel reassured about anything.

ecstatic

(32,701 posts)
14. It's not really about me right now, but it could be, if the carefree strategy
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:05 PM
Oct 2014

continues. According to WHO, the incubation can last 42 days, yet I've yet to hear that discussed by the CDC. So I assume everyone will be free to go once 21 days pass.

upaloopa

(11,417 posts)
18. Everyone? How many is that?
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:14 PM
Oct 2014

I think this is mostly imagination and little fact. It sells air time on news shows that is why the hype IMHO.
In a couple of weeks we will be posting about some other tragedy about to strike.

ecstatic

(32,701 posts)
20. The people they've identified as potentially exposed or infected.
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:17 PM
Oct 2014

Not sure what the total count is now, and I'm not confident that they've identified everyone who fits in that category.

Whiskeytide

(4,461 posts)
13. Well, I can understand that. But...
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:03 PM
Oct 2014

... it still seems as if what we are learning from Dallas is that this CAN be handled. We still have to handle it, but it can be done.

Now, if Duncan's casual, pre-hospitalization contacts do start showing infection, I'll light my hair back up. I promise.

mnhtnbb

(31,386 posts)
9. So far, the unprepared staff (Dallas) are the ones to contract Ebola from
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:57 PM
Oct 2014

treating a patient.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I don't believe there have been any cases of transmission of Ebola
to staff at Emory or Nebraska where Ebola patients have been treated.

That should be telling health care professionals something.

FLPanhandle

(7,107 posts)
10. Some folks just want to be scared or want to scare others.
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 04:58 PM
Oct 2014

You are going to ruin their fun with all that logic and common sense

Stallion

(6,474 posts)
12. I Have Same Feeling-4 Physicians/Nurses and a Caregiver
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:01 PM
Oct 2014

is something quite different than a walking contagion

Warpy

(111,255 posts)
16. Thank you. The disease is damned hard to catch
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:12 PM
Oct 2014

unless you're in ultra close physical contact with a patient who is running a constant stream of vomit, diarrhea, and blood. Nursing puts you into that kind of contact and the barrier methods that stop MRSA and HIV are woefully inadequate for this one.

The virus doesn't live long on surfaces and sunlight kills it, so those rats are going to have to come up with a different disease. We can send them some bubonic plague from NM, they'll like that, they've done that one before.

 

Bluenorthwest

(45,319 posts)
21. Not my first virus scare. For some people, fear is a sort of talisman, if they are afraid enough
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:40 PM
Oct 2014

they feel protected. It is ironic because fear is such a risky plaything.

jen63

(813 posts)
22. Oh, Whiskeytide,
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 05:42 PM
Oct 2014

you and Warpy (in another thread) have ruined a perfectly good hair on fire day. My faith in humanity is restored. I thought the entire world had gone mad.

AwakeAtLast

(14,124 posts)
25. I was just thinking this morning
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 06:29 PM
Oct 2014

that the relatives of Mr. Duncan are (at least so far) fine. And how could that be? You gave a very good explanation. Thanks!

Hatchling

(2,323 posts)
28. I'm truly fortunate.
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 06:48 PM
Oct 2014

I never saw that movie and I still have all my duct tape and plastic left over from 911.

7wo7rees

(5,128 posts)
29. A whisper of sanity in a day of chaos.
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 07:09 PM
Oct 2014

Nice job of putting some perspective quiet into all the heated debates/threads.

We live in Dallas.

IronLionZion

(45,435 posts)
30. I hope freepers use the duct tape and plastic wrap
Wed Oct 15, 2014, 07:44 PM
Oct 2014

before using the ammo. There's nothing worse than panicking gun nuts just itching to stand their ground.

The end of days has been expected for many years now, I think its long overdue for the good old fashioned conservatives to seal themselves in their basement and not come out until they've survived the 7 plagues or the election is over, whichever comes later.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Dallas events re Ebol...