General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsI would like to clear something up about that flag.
Last edited Thu Jul 2, 2015, 02:08 PM - Edit history (1)
This is the first flag of the confederacy
This is the second flag of the confederacy
This is the third flag of the confederacy
And this is the battle flag of the confederacy
I am making NO excuses for these symbols. I am trying to show some who don't know, the battle flag, is not the flag of the confederacy. All these symbols are distasteful to me, but that does not preclude me from studying the subject.
MineralMan
(146,254 posts)All five of them. So, it doesn't really matter which one is flown. They all symbolize the same ugliness. They all represent the side that lost in a stupid war that cost hundreds of thousands their lives.
They all should be relegated to dusty rooms in museums nobody visits.
uppityperson
(115,677 posts)daleanime
(17,796 posts)abakan
(1,815 posts)From some of the conversations Iv'e seen, it looked like some were not aware the battle flag was not the Confederate flag. I believe what they stand for is reprehensible, but that does not keep me from being a student of the civil war.
I lived in the heart of the civil war, in a civil war battle field for many years. I lived in Spotsylvania in the Wilderness battle field. I drove past Chancellorsville, Spotsylvania Courthouse, and Fredericksburg, every day on my way to work in Quantico.
I could not help but absorb the history, that does in no way means I agree with anything that happened there.
MineralMan
(146,254 posts)was unclear. It's always a good idea to say a little about your subject and your opinion of it on DU. People often use "information" about confederate banners as a way of deflecting criticism. They pretend that there is a difference between the symbolism of one flag and another. The truth is that there is no difference. They all are symbolic of the same things.
Apologists for the Civil War often attempt to defuse arguments against what that war stood for in a vain attempt to destroy someone's argument. That's why it's important to make some sort of statement, rather than just put up a series of images. We've seen those flags before, but usually from people who are trying to tell us we're wrong about the Confederate flag.
All of them are symbols of something, to be sure. They are symbolic of slavery, racism, and an attempt to split this nation along slaveholding and racist lines. All five are ugly and deserving of nothing but contempt.
abakan
(1,815 posts)It is wrong. My intent was to educate, not to praise or make any excuses for the symbols. Next time I have an impulse to post something here, I will think again.
MineralMan
(146,254 posts)it's always useful to add something about your opinion of what you are posting, unless that is obvious from the material you post.
randys1
(16,286 posts)my family was involved but I cant remember how.
The flag, any iteration of it, represents ONLY hate and racism and death.
NO matter what anybody claims it means to them, that is what it actually means.
I didnt see you making any point other than the one you made and as long as you agree with my comment
I am good...if you disagree with me on anything you are a traitor and a moron
just kidding...that was a joke...
abakan
(1,815 posts)I do agree with you, so therefore I am safe.
I don't understand people who look at something and automatically assume the worst of the poster.
If there is a question, they should ask, before they go off on their tangents. Thanks
dixiegrrrrl
(60,010 posts)You posted facts, with pictures.
Too many people too often have called the Stars and Bars flag the Confederate flag as if there were only one,
Information is always handy to have.
There is a tendency on DU for either/or, all or nothing thinking.
Your post might be educational, as you intended.
RKP5637
(67,086 posts)they are rationalized. Yes, a piece of history that should not be forgotten IMO, but placed in museums so future generations understand the ugliness of it all and do not repeat the same mistakes.
Eons ago when I went to college in a border southern university, I was stunned when the guys next door had a flag covering the wall. My reaction was WTF, that shit is over, why the F do you want to symbolize that hatred. Some have such ugliness and hatred in their psyche that often it's unshakable.
The good part is current and future generations are seeing the ugliness of what that flag represents. And IMO during the Obama presidency that ugliness has grown and that flag has gotten far uglier.
trof
(54,256 posts)This is the first flag that flew over our nation that condoned and profited from slavery.
1776
And through many and various permutations to as late as 1859
http://www.ushistory.org/betsy/flagfact.html
Let he who is without sin...
"But I wasn't even alive then,"
"Neither was I."
Peace and Love
trof
underpants
(182,603 posts)They spent all their time sitting around doing all that gay sewing
cwydro
(51,308 posts)Huh?
underpants
(182,603 posts)Irony putting the Confederate flag together with one of the other topics of late - same sex marriage
Rex
(65,616 posts)Yes. Those are flags of the Confederacy.
Rex
(65,616 posts)dunno...don't read minds.
abakan
(1,815 posts)I expect people to think for themselves. I didn't know I would have to draw a picture. Oh wait! I did show pictures. and identified all of them. Clearly I was showing the real flags of the confederacy and not just the battle flag. Real hard to understand I guess.
Rex
(65,616 posts)Was that so hard? Why not just tell people your premise instead of making them guess?
abakan
(1,815 posts)HassleCat
(6,409 posts)Most of the people who wave the rebel battle fag call it the "stars and bars," which is actually the name given to the first design you show. The second design, incorporating the battle flag, was usually called "the stainless banner," and the third design was "the blood stained banner." The battle flag was revived in the early 1960s as a symbol of defiance to court ordered school integration. Basically, when you fly the battle flag from your pickup truck, you are saying, "My kids shouldn't have to attend school with the little darkies." I say, "Up to you, Johnny Reb. If that's the message you want to send, go for it."
abakan
(1,815 posts)Thanks for your lesson.
Oilwellian
(12,647 posts)It's totally absurd to think Dylan Roof posed with the confederate battle flag because it represents a pro segregation stance. You also forgot to mention WHO resurrected the confederate battle flag in response to the civil rights movement during the '60's, and NOT just for segregation as you suggest.
But hey, who am I to pop your bubble. LOL
HassleCat
(6,409 posts)You're missing the point that even most members of the South Carolina legislature now admit. The flag has been "misappropriated" to quote one of the legislators. It has been promoted, at various times, as a symbol of segregation, a banner of general defiance to authority, a signal that a good ole boy is riding in this pickup, and so on and so forth. In the particular case of Dylan Roof, no he probably wasn't even aware that the federal government forced school desegregation in southern states. But it's clear he hated black people, and blamed them for various social problems, so that's what the flag meant to him.
TexasProgresive
(12,155 posts)Regardless of what those flags stood for in the minds of people long ago, what they stand for now, especially the Stars and Bars, is a symbol of hatred. There is no defending it as it has become the emblem of the KKK, racists and thugs. TAKE IT DOWN, NOW!
abakan
(1,815 posts)Read my reply above.
Xyzse
(8,217 posts)It is always awesome when you can talk circles and know more about the subject that you oppose in comparison to those that support it.
That is how I went about Religion. I like knowing more about the bible than some so called Bible Thumpers.
It is a great day when I can shut them up.
Last edited Thu Jul 2, 2015, 03:10 PM - Edit history (2)
At least someone understood my intent. Thank you for your open mind and ability to not automatically jump to the conclusion my post was anything other than an attempt to enlighten.
Rex
(65,616 posts)Overreact much?
I done with this. FYI you couldn't read my mind if you wanted to, it's password protected.
kydo
(2,679 posts)Funny thing though, this person has two flags up; A Jewish Flag and the stars and bars traitor slave owner flag (the first one on your list). The lady lives right next to a funeral home. Crazy, a racist Jew. During the last Prez elections she had no fewer then 5 huge ass romney signs. Of course they covered her flags so a few days later she moved the flags to in front of the signs. Crazy people.
No really, right next to this nut job that funeral home, which is next to a gun store, tattoo pallor, karate school, a herb/pill store and a bar. Crazy people I tell you. But then again I am in Central FL that probably explains it.
Uncle Joe
(58,284 posts)unequivocally support Israel.
Here is another contradictory image, different versions of the Confederate Battle Flag flown alongside the U.S. Flag.
Journeyman
(15,024 posts)A wealthy slave owner, and first Jew elected to the US Senate, Benjamin resigned when South Carolina seceded. He would go on to become, first, the Attorney General, then Secretary of War, and finally Secretary of State for the Confederacy. His most far-reaching decision of the war was to advocate that slaves be freed and armed to fight for the Confederacy.
The world is sometimes far more complicated than our easy classifications permit.
MohRokTah
(15,429 posts)TexasProgresive
(12,155 posts)The white flag does not always mean surrender it is asking for parley. That might lead to surrender but not always.
This is the true image of surrender:
abakan
(1,815 posts)Comrade Grumpy
(13,184 posts)57% Southern pride
33% Racist
DU is something of a bubble.
MohRokTah
(15,429 posts)Hoyt
(54,770 posts)spanone
(135,791 posts)former9thward
(31,936 posts)After the war 20,000 Confederates (along with some free slaves) went to Brazil. That area of Brazil is called Americana and now has about 200,000 descendants of the original Confederates. In honor of Carter's visit the city added a Confederate flag to its coat of arms.
abakan
(1,815 posts)But whether right or wrong, we must recognize we as a people have been evolving our attitudes on many issues. We can't condemn history with 2015 eyes because that was a completely different world. We may not like it but it was acceptable at the time.
former9thward
(31,936 posts)that a Confederate colony exists in present day Brazil. One influential enough that a governor of GA went to visit it.
Art_from_Ark
(27,247 posts)It sounds like Confederados became model citizens in Brazil. And one of Rosalynn Carter's great uncles was a Confederado who is buried in Brazil. So Carter's visit to Brazil was nothing to be embarrassed about-- certainly nothing like Reagan's visit to Bitburg.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confederados
ladyVet
(1,587 posts)As you show, there were many flags associated with the Confederate States, and that was but one.
I find them distasteful when used in a hateful way (unlike, say, at a museum when used as a historical display), but I will defend a private citizen's right to own them and fly them. Governments, though, not at all.