Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
128 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
If Democratic Socialism is so bad, where are all the scandinavian immigrants? - img (Original Post) Bubzer Sep 2015 OP
Pinin' for the fjords? The Velveteen Ocelot Sep 2015 #1
Isn't their prime minister Rosa Luxemburg Sep 2015 #3
Conservatives in Europe are more Democratic Socialist than our Democrats. JDPriestly Sep 2015 #31
Conservatism is stronger in hot climates, cools down a bit in cool ones. Hortensis Sep 2015 #52
Very interesting. Thanks. JDPriestly Sep 2015 #70
Alaska is an odd ball with Palinites Rosa Luxemburg Sep 2015 #71
Are you from Alaska, Rosa L? Hortensis Sep 2015 #73
Alaska is weird Scootaloo Sep 2015 #126
No, they're more Social Democratic. BIG difference to us who have lived where there was both. DFW Sep 2015 #98
Bernie is 73 and not about to shoot anyone. Listen to his speeches. JDPriestly Sep 2015 #111
I'm American and agree with your assessment of the domestic situation DFW Sep 2015 #114
I lived in Germany, France, Austria and the UK, JDPriestly Sep 2015 #125
Lovely plumage, the Norwegian blue. nt awoke_in_2003 Sep 2015 #37
Isn't their Deputy Prime Minster a Green? Rosa Luxemburg Sep 2015 #2
I'm not sure. I think it depends which scandinavian country you're refering to. Bubzer Sep 2015 #6
Sorry, Sweden Rosa Luxemburg Sep 2015 #72
Ahh. This is what's listed at wikipedia: Bubzer Sep 2015 #80
Ja Rosa Luxemburg Sep 2015 #89
If Democrtsic Socialism is so good, where are all the US Emigrants? brooklynite Sep 2015 #4
About 20k immigrate to scandinavia from the US per year. Bubzer Sep 2015 #5
It's difficult to emigrate to the Scandinavian countries. The Velveteen Ocelot Sep 2015 #9
It is hard to go to many countries. Hardly any of us would qualify yeoman6987 Sep 2015 #19
One of my college friends did so by taking a post-graduate semester abroad in Oslo Lydia Leftcoast Sep 2015 #83
+1 Bubzer Sep 2015 #94
Since so many people here worry that the Democratic nomination is being "fixed"..... brooklynite Sep 2015 #85
You seem bitter about something. tabasco Sep 2015 #87
What would I be bitter about? brooklynite Sep 2015 #88
I wouldn't call somone detailing their experiences as being flippant. Bubzer Sep 2015 #96
Thats somthing I would expect the GOP or a conservative to say...not a Dem. Bubzer Sep 2015 #95
So eager to get rid of us? daleanime Sep 2015 #24
. Rex Sep 2015 #26
my late husband said DesertFlower Sep 2015 #35
Ever try immigrating to a better place as an American? YabaDabaNoDinoNo Sep 2015 #48
It's also almost imposible to own land outside of the US. Bubzer Sep 2015 #66
It is difficult, but there are a few countries in Asia where it isn't that difficult davidpdx Sep 2015 #116
This message was self-deleted by its author stillwaiting Sep 2015 #49
Depending on the outcome of this election PowerToThePeople Sep 2015 #55
The Scandinavian countries are not democratic socialist. former9thward Sep 2015 #7
Defends them from what? The US is more in the busienss of creating terrorists n/t eridani Sep 2015 #8
Its called NATO. former9thward Sep 2015 #45
Sweden and Finland never joined NATO during the Cold War 1939 Sep 2015 #56
Yes they are. ForgoTheConsequence Sep 2015 #10
+1 Bubzer Sep 2015 #12
No, they're not. NuclearDem Sep 2015 #13
For you as well. Bubzer Sep 2015 #14
And for you: NuclearDem Sep 2015 #16
I really shouldn't need to point this out, but... Bubzer Sep 2015 #17
You do know that social democracy and democratic socialism are not the same thing? NuclearDem Sep 2015 #18
Touche! Though I want to bring some additional perspective into play... Bubzer Sep 2015 #82
And right in that site, they will tell you they are Socialists, & on the very page you linked nt stevenleser Sep 2015 #104
LOL! Rex Sep 2015 #27
That's right, their governments are Social Democracies, not Democratic Socialism. nt stevenleser Sep 2015 #105
You are mistaken sir. Bubzer Sep 2015 #11
No, I am not. former9thward Sep 2015 #44
Then where do you take your deffinition from? Bubzer Sep 2015 #97
I imagine the academic texts sourced in the wiki entry are merely pablum too... LanternWaste Sep 2015 #108
Other posters have agreed with me. former9thward Sep 2015 #110
And other posters have disagreed with you. Bubzer Sep 2015 #120
+100 !! (NT) PosterChild Sep 2015 #28
Democratic socialist countries are capitalist. It's a mixture. JDPriestly Sep 2015 #33
So true. If only we could get rid of this military obsession treestar Sep 2015 #54
Correct, the Scandinavian and many European countries are Social Democracies. Not the same thing stevenleser Sep 2015 #78
They've all committed suicide DavidDvorkin Sep 2015 #15
Oh, they're all moving here to the US to take advantage of the unbelievably expensive healthcare, Zorra Sep 2015 #20
lol Bubzer Sep 2015 #21
I love the tone of you sarcasm! Phlem Sep 2015 #22
But Mureica and freedom. We're exceptional. kairos12 Sep 2015 #38
Exactly. SoapBox Sep 2015 #23
Is there some kind of migration of Americans to Scandinavia? SouthernProgressive Sep 2015 #25
+100 !! (NT) PosterChild Sep 2015 #30
Were I younger and more adventuring, I might consider 1monster Sep 2015 #41
Most Americans don't have a clue how things work in other countries. Very incurious. stillwaiting Sep 2015 #50
Of course, it excludes those who would "hugely benefit" TexasMommaWithAHat Sep 2015 #58
Our social safety net is a disgrace. stillwaiting Sep 2015 #59
+1 Bubzer Sep 2015 #68
I've seen the argument made that their sharp immigration restrictions enable much of what they do Lee-Lee Sep 2015 #57
It's very difficult to emigrate to those countries Lydia Leftcoast Sep 2015 #90
The Bubble Brigade will explain why America is 1# Rex Sep 2015 #29
The upper midwest: Minnesota, Wisconsin, Dakotas, Iowa IronLionZion Sep 2015 #32
And they all came here....when? truebluegreen Sep 2015 #39
I personally know some recent immigrants from Sweden IronLionZion Sep 2015 #60
Yes, I'm sure there's a wave. truebluegreen Sep 2015 #62
People walk past Europeans every day without knowing they're European IronLionZion Sep 2015 #84
Uff da. truebluegreen Sep 2015 #86
+1 Bubzer Sep 2015 #102
Americans of Scandinavian descent outnumber Scandinavians in Scandinavia (nt) Recursion Sep 2015 #43
Bingo. The immigrants fleeing Scandinavia WERE there - before they adopted Democratic Socialism. forest444 Sep 2015 #74
Primarily fleeing a shortage of land NT 1939 Sep 2015 #77
Or rather, the concentration of most good land in a few hundred families. forest444 Sep 2015 #81
White, colder, and 1939 Sep 2015 #93
So what's your opinion of.. PosterChild Sep 2015 #34
Well, lets take a look at that. Bubzer Sep 2015 #100
Bernie's going to be . ... PosterChild Sep 2015 #112
Yikes! that article is enormous! Thats not an article, its a book! Bubzer Sep 2015 #113
Gives new meaning to tl;dr... PosterChild Sep 2015 #115
Sorry but I just don't agree. The fear about socialism has been progressivly fading for a while now. Bubzer Sep 2015 #117
Here are some resources... PosterChild Sep 2015 #118
Yet, in spite of those numbers, Bernie has had vastly more event attendance than anyone else. Bubzer Sep 2015 #119
Good luck with that (nt) PosterChild Sep 2015 #121
Looks like it's started.... PosterChild Sep 2015 #124
Looks like Hillary's attacks are having the opposite impact Bubzer Sep 2015 #127
Keep hoping. (nt) PosterChild Sep 2015 #128
Conservatives There Are Not Like Ours Here colsohlibgal Sep 2015 #36
Bingo! Jason Huh Sep 2015 #40
In a large band from Wisconsin to the Dakotas Recursion Sep 2015 #42
yep you nailed it nt steve2470 Sep 2015 #47
This message was self-deleted by its author stillwaiting Sep 2015 #51
And WHEN did they immigrate there? stillwaiting Sep 2015 #53
Yah, well, the Swedes and Norskies have royal families, you know. MineralMan Sep 2015 #63
Your application of historical context is dramatically lacking. LanternWaste Sep 2015 #109
They're all over Washington state, for one thing. And many of them pnwmom Sep 2015 #46
Can you blame them? It's freaking cold here in MineralMan Sep 2015 #65
They all came to Minnesnowta years ago. MineralMan Sep 2015 #61
Minnesota, Wisconsin, Northern Michigan FrodosPet Sep 2015 #64
Right. Bubzer Sep 2015 #69
These days, I think only upper middle class Scandinavians would try to emigrate to the US KitSileya Sep 2015 #67
Our DIL is a Danish citizen raised in America, KitSileya, but she's never Hortensis Sep 2015 #76
If you refer to Scandinavia, you're thinking of Social Democracy. Not the same thing as "PDS" DFW Sep 2015 #75
I keep telling people this. Maybe if enough of us say it, people will finally get it. nt stevenleser Sep 2015 #79
When swine get permission to launch an airline DFW Sep 2015 #91
I've tried to explain the differences in European political parties.... BooScout Sep 2015 #99
I've seen that. DFW Sep 2015 #101
Not quite. Bubzer Sep 2015 #103
I don't think just "American." I think globally. I have to. DFW Sep 2015 #106
I can certainly respect that. Each culture applies the labels it deems appropriate. Bubzer Sep 2015 #107
If monarchy is bad, where are all the immigrants of noble birth? Kaleva Sep 2015 #92
K & R! Dont call me Shirley Sep 2015 #122
We won't see that type of socialism until the country splits into smaller countries Marrah_G Sep 2015 #123

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,683 posts)
1. Pinin' for the fjords?
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 08:47 PM
Sep 2015

I've wondered that myself. Strangely, you don't see Norwegians desperate to escape their socialist hellhole (with all that awful free college and health care) lining up at the U.S. Embassy in Oslo to apply for asylum.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
52. Conservatism is stronger in hot climates, cools down a bit in cool ones.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 08:39 AM
Sep 2015

And vice versa.

Yes, this is research-based. I read it in a thick book. But wonderers can just take a quick look at political maps. Both the nations of the world and the U.S. states that are more "liberal" tend to cluster in cooler areas, and also tend to be more prosperous and stable. (There are other geographic factors, of course, like coastal locations, etc.)

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
73. Are you from Alaska, Rosa L?
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 04:38 PM
Sep 2015

I'm thinking Alaska would have both the kind of life-challenging conditions that cause populations to be more conservative (i.e., protective) in order to survive -- we're not talking "cool" here! -- and jobs and economy very heavily dependent on Big Oil and Gas. At least these are my assumptions based on what I've read.

A lot of people also seem to say they moved there not only because of its beauty and wilderness but because of its differences from a variety of things they disliked about continental America, including widespread urbanization. I'm just guessing that doesn't weight the newcomers toward a preponderance of liberal personalities, though.

 

Scootaloo

(25,699 posts)
126. Alaska is weird
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 10:33 PM
Sep 2015

Most people there are actually pretty liberal. However, there is a SERIOUS distrust of "big government" and then there's the influence of the oil industry.

Democrats could take Alaska, if we'd just put forth the effort.

DFW

(54,370 posts)
98. No, they're more Social Democratic. BIG difference to us who have lived where there was both.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:37 AM
Sep 2015

The Party of Democratic Socialism did exist. THESE were the "Democratic Socialists" where I now live.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Party_of_Democratic_Socialism_%28Germany%29

Some of them still claim it was their perfect right to shoot people down at the Berlin Wall. They are not nice people. Labels are just that: labels. "Democratic Socialist" has never meant murdering your own citizens in the USA, so it doesn't raise eyebrows back home. In Germany, where I live, it'll get you more than just shoes thrown at you.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
111. Bernie is 73 and not about to shoot anyone. Listen to his speeches.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 06:46 PM
Sep 2015

Go to one of his rallies.

I lived in Austria, France, Germany and the UK.

Those countries are relatively socialist. We are talking about truly universal health care insurance, free post-secondary education and training, child care that is of high quality, really basic stuff that is taken for granted in European countries. Just what the movement behind it is called is unimportant. It's what America needs to be doing to make life less frightening and guilt-ridden that matters.

I don't know whether you are American or not but when you look at our family law courts and see the bickering over child support payments, it's pretty disgusting.

Some of the costs of caring for children should be shared for all of us. We should expect parents to be responsible in planning their families, but some (not all by any means) of the responsibility for making sure children have shoes on their feet and food in their tummies when they go to child care or school should be shared by all of us. It's just the moral thing to do.

DFW

(54,370 posts)
114. I'm American and agree with your assessment of the domestic situation
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 05:58 AM
Sep 2015

In Germany, however, it far from being as rosy as you picture. German men neglect their child support as often as men of any other nationality, and there is no universal health care at all. It is not France. It is a patchwork system that asked me to pay €2500 euros a month for health insurance if I wanted German health insurance, even though I pay my taxes there. I keep my US insurance, crappy though it is, rather than lay out $34000 a year for health insurance. I mean gimme a break. You either don't speak German or weren't there very long. The child care is spotty. The word "kinderunfreundlich" is hard to pronounce to some non-Germans, but every Germany learns it early, and it applies well to the German approach to little ones. I've lived there for years, married to a German (SPD/Greens voter) and we speak German at home. I'm no stranger there.

I realize that Bernie isn't about to shoot anyone, no matter what his age. However, as one who has dealt with an existing version of "Democratic Socialism," the term makes me cringe. Not only because to all Europeans, it means the killers at the Wall, but because Bernie advocates a classic Social Democratic line as is practiced in most northern European countries, which is something else entirely. He's not running for Bundeskanzler of Germany, so it obviously doesn't matter in the States. Should he win, however, he had better have some reassuring talks with countries that have buried 19 year olds who died at the hands of "Democratic Socialists," as happened when their European version was in power.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
125. I lived in Germany, France, Austria and the UK,
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 09:47 PM
Sep 2015

Had babies there and went through kindergarten and elementary with then in Austria. Maybe things have changed since we lived there, and of course services have to be paid for but I loved the health care and the kindergarten system in Europe.

It is really much worse here.

French doctors and their healthcare system saved my life.

Rosa Luxemburg

(28,627 posts)
2. Isn't their Deputy Prime Minster a Green?
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 08:48 PM
Sep 2015

Most of the government are SAP Social Democrats. I went to Malmo in Sweden it is nice, people very friendly and nice coffee.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
80. Ahh. This is what's listed at wikipedia:
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 06:56 PM
Sep 2015
Kjell Stefan Löfvén is a Swedish politician who has been the Prime Minister of Sweden since 2014 and the Leader of the Social Democrats since 2012.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
5. About 20k immigrate to scandinavia from the US per year.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:00 PM
Sep 2015

Applications to immigrate are considerably higher. However, Scandinavian countries have considerably higher immigration standards then the US.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,683 posts)
9. It's difficult to emigrate to the Scandinavian countries.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:19 PM
Sep 2015

But I do know a few Americans who have done so (they qualified by marriage or having a parent from there) and they are very happy there.

 

yeoman6987

(14,449 posts)
19. It is hard to go to many countries. Hardly any of us would qualify
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 10:05 PM
Sep 2015

For New Zealand. The United States is the easiest in the world to come to.

Lydia Leftcoast

(48,217 posts)
83. One of my college friends did so by taking a post-graduate semester abroad in Oslo
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 07:09 PM
Sep 2015

While she was there, she heard that Norway was in desperate need of IT professionals. Since she had a good math background, she applied for the new computer science department at the University of Oslo and was accepted.

From then on, she was in. She currently works for the Norwegian equivalent of the IRS. Like all Norwegian residents (she never got around to becoming a citizen, although she was thinking about it), she gets four weeks of paid vacation by law, an additional week as a government employee, and another week for being over sixty.

She and her long-term gentleman friend live in Oslo and have a beautiful cabin in the mountains, but they don't own a car. They don't have to. Urban or intercity transit or bicycles do the job.

About twenty years ago, she was seriously injured when a car hit her bicycle, and she spent months in the hospital without ever seeing a bill.

I asked how her parents felt about her decision to stay in Norway, and she said that at first they were upset, but once they had visited a few times, they realized that she had a better quality of life than she would have had in the States.

brooklynite

(94,520 posts)
85. Since so many people here worry that the Democratic nomination is being "fixed".....
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 08:27 PM
Sep 2015

....maybe you could claim political asylum?

brooklynite

(94,520 posts)
88. What would I be bitter about?
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 09:15 PM
Sep 2015

All I'm doing is addressing flippant comments about the political process.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
96. I wouldn't call somone detailing their experiences as being flippant.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:16 AM
Sep 2015

But it does seem you're trying to be dismissive.

DesertFlower

(11,649 posts)
35. my late husband said
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 11:24 PM
Sep 2015

we should have made a move when we were younger. he worked for IBM and could have lived anyplace he wanted.

 

YabaDabaNoDinoNo

(460 posts)
48. Ever try immigrating to a better place as an American?
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 07:18 AM
Sep 2015

It is very difficult if you are not married to a citizen of that country or have direct family to that county.

It is even difficult if you have a skill that an employer needs to bring you in as an American.

It is easier to immigrate if you are a refugee or are wealthy.

Regular person who wants a change of venue with only job skills to offer very, very difficult to do many times a temporary work permit and temporary visa is the best one can get usually one get a no.




Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
66. It's also almost imposible to own land outside of the US.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:20 PM
Sep 2015

You typically have to be native-born or married to someone who is.

davidpdx

(22,000 posts)
116. It is difficult, but there are a few countries in Asia where it isn't that difficult
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 07:17 AM
Sep 2015

I am an immigrant in South Korea. I started working here almost 11 years ago, met my wife and got permanent residency five years ago. Even if you aren't married it's not difficult to work here. One of my co-workers who is not married has been here five years and received permanent residency on his own.

Response to brooklynite (Reply #4)

former9thward

(31,997 posts)
7. The Scandinavian countries are not democratic socialist.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:06 PM
Sep 2015

Last edited Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:21 PM - Edit history (1)

All of them are capitalist based market economies. Their social welfare safety net is much deeper than the U.S. But that is the only difference. They can afford that safety net because their military expenses are negligible. Their military expenses are negligible because the U.S. taxpayer defends them.

1939

(1,683 posts)
56. Sweden and Finland never joined NATO during the Cold War
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 11:28 AM
Sep 2015

Only Norway and Denmark did. Sweden, like Switzerland, maintained strict neutrality and also maintained substantial armed forces. Finland maintained neutrality under the Soviet gun with their foreign policy severely constrained. Sweden was often confronted with Soviet naval provocations in the Baltic.

ForgoTheConsequence

(4,868 posts)
10. Yes they are.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:19 PM
Sep 2015

Democratic socialism isn't incompatible with capitalism and market based economics.

And when you're not involved in illegal wars (like the one Hillary voted for in Iraq) you don't need to spend trillions on your military.

 

NuclearDem

(16,184 posts)
13. No, they're not.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:26 PM
Sep 2015

The Nordic Model is one of social democracy, not democratic socialism. Democratic socialism is inherently incompatible with market economies by virtue of the simple fact that it seeks to replace the market system with a socialist model.

The Nordic Model has no such goal.

 

NuclearDem

(16,184 posts)
16. And for you:
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:40 PM
Sep 2015
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model

The Nordic model (or Nordic capitalism[1] or Nordic social democracy)[2][3] refers to the economic and social models of the Nordic countries (Denmark, Finland, Norway, Iceland, Greenland, Faroe Islands and Sweden), which involves the combination of a free market economy with a welfare state.[4]


Democratic socialism isn't the combination of a free market economy with a welfare state. It's the replacement of a free market economy with a socialist economy.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
17. I really shouldn't need to point this out, but...
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:52 PM
Sep 2015

"Nordic capitalism or Nordic social democracy". From your own post no less.

 

NuclearDem

(16,184 posts)
18. You do know that social democracy and democratic socialism are not the same thing?
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 09:57 PM
Sep 2015

The former is a reform of capitalism with a welfare state. The latter is the replacing of capitalism with socialism.

They're not the same thing.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
82. Touche! Though I want to bring some additional perspective into play...
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 07:08 PM
Sep 2015

Democratic Socialism has numerous variants, much akin to the difference between a European Liberal and an American Liberal... by which I mean to say, they are different. In the case of Democratic Socialism, I refer to the brand that developed in the states. I think you'll find its much closer to social democracy:

http://www.dsausa.org/what_is_democratic_socialism

 

stevenleser

(32,886 posts)
104. And right in that site, they will tell you they are Socialists, & on the very page you linked nt
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 11:06 AM
Sep 2015

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
97. Then where do you take your deffinition from?
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:24 AM
Sep 2015

Might I suggest: http://www.dsausa.org/what_is_democratic_socialism ?

If not, please list your source so I can arbitrarily dismiss it, as you just did mine.

 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
108. I imagine the academic texts sourced in the wiki entry are merely pablum too...
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 03:06 PM
Sep 2015

I imagine the academic texts sourced in the wiki entry are merely pablum too... as they disagree with your premise.

JDPriestly

(57,936 posts)
33. Democratic socialist countries are capitalist. It's a mixture.
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 11:19 PM
Sep 2015

I've lived in Germany, Austria, France and the UK all pretty much democratic socialist. There is a huge difference between communism and democratic socialism.

Democratic socialism just means that they have the very strong safety net that the people choose to have through democratic representation.

They do have lower military expenses because we pay their defense costs to a great but not a total extent. We are the fools.

But we need a complete and thorough audit of our defense costs and expenditures.

 

stevenleser

(32,886 posts)
78. Correct, the Scandinavian and many European countries are Social Democracies. Not the same thing
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 06:48 PM
Sep 2015

as Democratic Socialists. They are two very distinct ideologies.

Zorra

(27,670 posts)
20. Oh, they're all moving here to the US to take advantage of the unbelievably expensive healthcare,
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 10:05 PM
Sep 2015

the totally unaffordable college costs, the incredibly expensive child care, our wonderful no maternity leave policies, all the random shootings and murders by firearm, the $7.50 an hour jobs, and the no vacation policies of so many employers. To name a few of the many reasons why thousands of starving Scandinavians are desperately trying to enter the US illegally on a daily basis.

 

SouthernProgressive

(1,810 posts)
25. Is there some kind of migration of Americans to Scandinavia?
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 11:02 PM
Sep 2015

Would the answer to that validate or invalidate our economic system?

1monster

(11,012 posts)
41. Were I younger and more adventuring, I might consider
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 12:34 AM
Sep 2015

checking out Norway, if only it were not so freakin' cold up there and it didn't get so much snow... I'm a warm climate type.

stillwaiting

(3,795 posts)
50. Most Americans don't have a clue how things work in other countries. Very incurious.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 08:22 AM
Sep 2015

Secondly, immigrating to Scandinavian countries is EXTREMELY difficult to do for most Americans.

A small percentage of us would even be eligible to immigrate, and those that are eligible would be the ones that most likely have a great job in the U.S. that provides at least SOME level of benefits and financial security.

So many that would hugely benefit from living in a Scandinavian country (relative to their lifestyle in the U.S.) are not welcomed there.
Immigration policies exclude them.

TexasMommaWithAHat

(3,212 posts)
58. Of course, it excludes those who would "hugely benefit"
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 12:20 PM
Sep 2015

If they let just anyone in, their safety net stretches thinner!

We, on the other hand, don't have to worry about our safety nets stretching too thin, since we barely have one, anyway.

stillwaiting

(3,795 posts)
59. Our social safety net is a disgrace.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 12:24 PM
Sep 2015

I am simply perplexed that some around here spout off about why Americans aren't immigrating to Scandinavia if it's so great over there. I expect for ignorant right-wingers to say it. I would expect better from informed posters around here.

It would be very difficult for most Americans to immigrate to Scandinavia.

The "love it or leave it" argument is so ignorant and/or disingenuous.

 

Lee-Lee

(6,324 posts)
57. I've seen the argument made that their sharp immigration restrictions enable much of what they do
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 11:51 AM
Sep 2015

Not sure I buy it, but the argument is by making it incredibly hard to emigrate unless you are very wealthy or a refugee they can afford the social welfare benefits by managing how many use them.

The wealthy they allow in will always be a cash positive to the system, so they are welcome.

The number of refugees they allow in is managed and controlled and accounts for the amount of job growth they want to see on the unskilled labor side.

Pretty much nobody else gets in- so no middle class jobs and only a managed number of "lower class" jobs are taken by anyone but the natives of those countries- resulting in far more job availability and far fewer people, including immigrants, using the generous social welfare benefits without working and contributing.

I'm not sure I buy it, but it makes an interesting argument. I do know that the highly restrictive nature of what those counties allow for immigration- allowing only refugees and only in numbers that they feel benefit their economy, not allowing anyone else a chance- is one aspect of their way of governing I don't think we need to emulate at all.

Lydia Leftcoast

(48,217 posts)
90. It's very difficult to emigrate to those countries
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 10:08 PM
Sep 2015

I looked into it in 2000 after Bush was sElected, because I'm half Norwegian and speak some of the language.

No luck.

You have to meet one of a set of stringent qualifications:

1. Be a refugee or political asylum seeker (hating the Bush administration didn't count)
2. Be married to a Norwegian (wouldn't have minded but there were no likely candidates)
4. Be the child of a Norwegian citizen (Sigh, I'm the grandchild of two Norwegian citizens, but that's not close enough.)
5. Have a job offer from a Norwegian employer who has proved that no current resident of Norway is qualified
6. Be skilled in an occupation that is in short supply in Norway

I also tried Germany, but again, one generation too far down. You can be the grandchild of a German citizen, but unfortunately, my grandmother was born two weeks AFTER her parents came from Germany. If they had waited just one month...

 

Rex

(65,616 posts)
29. The Bubble Brigade will explain why America is 1#
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 11:14 PM
Sep 2015

kidding they will just insult you. They are one trick ponies.

IronLionZion

(45,433 posts)
60. I personally know some recent immigrants from Sweden
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 12:59 PM
Sep 2015

in Minnesota and here in Washington, DC where I live now. They were born and raised in Sweden but liked America so much they came over. It's not that hard to believe. People move all the time.

forest444

(5,902 posts)
74. Bingo. The immigrants fleeing Scandinavia WERE there - before they adopted Democratic Socialism.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 05:12 PM
Sep 2015

Between 1840 and 1910 about one in three Swedes left the country, mostly to the U.S. (especially Minnesota, of course).

And what were they fleeing? Their feudal class system - in other words exactly the kind of conditions our friends in the GOP want to recreate here in the U.S.

https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=b6UyAAAAIBAJ&sjid=MukFAAAAIBAJ&pg=2599,1490863&dq=swedish-diaspora&hl=en

1939

(1,683 posts)
77. Primarily fleeing a shortage of land NT
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 06:34 PM
Sep 2015

Upper Peninsula of Michigan has a very large number of people of Finnish descent.

forest444

(5,902 posts)
81. Or rather, the concentration of most good land in a few hundred families.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 07:01 PM
Sep 2015

As hard as it may be to believe now, Scandinavia 100 years ago was a lot like Central America today - only whiter and colder.

1939

(1,683 posts)
93. White, colder, and
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 08:54 AM
Sep 2015

a whole lot less corruption in government.

My grandfather and half of his siblings came to the US after they grew up. Only one brother inherited the farm in Sweden.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
100. Well, lets take a look at that.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:38 AM
Sep 2015

Venezuela is federal republic style of government rather than a democratic socialist state.
http://venezuelanalysis.com/basicfacts

PosterChild

(1,307 posts)
112. Bernie's going to be . ...
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:35 PM
Sep 2015

... tarred and feathered with Venezuelan oil.


From the same source. Be sure to read the whole thing! Its likely donald trump with a vocabulary!

http://venezuelanalysis.com/analysis/3367



Democratic socialism means healthcare, jobs, food, and security, in neighborhoods where in many cases nothing but absolute poverty existed ten years ago..... Bottom up democracy in Venezuela starts with the 25,000 community councils elected in every neighborhood in the country. “We establish the priority needs of our area,” reported community council spokesperson Carmon Aponte.

http://www.globalresearch.ca/democratic-socialism-moves-forward-in-venezuela/11292

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
113. Yikes! that article is enormous! Thats not an article, its a book!
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 12:31 AM
Sep 2015

They may be choosing to move to democratic socialism, but they're not currently there.

Also consider that Bernie doesn't point to Venezuela as being representative of his ideals.

PosterChild

(1,307 posts)
115. Gives new meaning to tl;dr...
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 07:04 AM
Sep 2015

The problem for bernie is simple - the westren European democraciees bernie does point to are social democracies and do not embrace or exemplify democratic socilism . The European People's Party is not socilistic. They are not, and never will be democratic socialist states.Venezuela however explicitly embraces and exemplifies the political ideology that bernie espouses . And, by the way, bernie knows it.

But more importantly bernie's electoral competition knows this and they are going to make good use of it. So you can be quite sure the voters will know all about it too.

What the voters will hear is one candidate saying Make America Great and another candidate saying Make America Venezuela .

Bernie, and the Democratic Party , will be smeared with Venezuelan crude.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
117. Sorry but I just don't agree. The fear about socialism has been progressivly fading for a while now.
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 09:36 AM
Sep 2015

It's just not the issue it was during the red-scare. In fact, with as much as we've delved into a fascist/oligopoly state, people are desiring and even demanding something to counter the iron grip of corporations. Bernie represents that.

The GOP can trot out the toothless dog of "But he's a socialist" all they want, it'll make little difference. The media has already tried that tactic, and it's failed... people just aren't biting onto that shriveled old bait.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
119. Yet, in spite of those numbers, Bernie has had vastly more event attendance than anyone else.
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 01:17 PM
Sep 2015

There are a number of issues I take with the polling methods used, and the opinion piece article... but even setting those concerns aside, that poll just isn't consistent with the enormous enthusiasm out there for Bernie. You think the federal republic of Venezuela will harm Bernie's campaign... I see this argument as facile. It's a distraction at most. Bernie sticks to the issues and points to Scandinavian counties as an example of what he's aiming for. His actions speak louder than the words of his detractors. Substance over smoke and mirrors.

colsohlibgal

(5,275 posts)
36. Conservatives There Are Not Like Ours Here
Sat Sep 12, 2015, 11:24 PM
Sep 2015

They differ from progressives on immigration more than anything. On most things they are left of the DNC Wall Street dems.

Also...like every other non tinhorn country other than us they do not allow for profit health care.

Response to Recursion (Reply #42)

stillwaiting

(3,795 posts)
53. And WHEN did they immigrate there?
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 09:56 AM
Sep 2015

A long time ago for the most part.

I don't believe that there have been many Scandinavian immigrants to the U.S. over the past few decades. Those that are here are not first generation immigrants for the most part. That is some very important missing information.

MineralMan

(146,288 posts)
63. Yah, well, the Swedes and Norskies have royal families, you know.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:03 PM
Sep 2015

They're still sort of monarchies.

Here's the King of Sweden:



And the King of Norway:

 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
109. Your application of historical context is dramatically lacking.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 03:08 PM
Sep 2015

Your application of historical context is dramatically lacking.

Little more than another post hoc ergo prompter hoc fallacy.

pnwmom

(108,977 posts)
46. They're all over Washington state, for one thing. And many of them
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 05:59 AM
Sep 2015

seem to have arrived via Minnesota.

MineralMan

(146,288 posts)
65. Can you blame them? It's freaking cold here in
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:09 PM
Sep 2015

the Winter. Lots have stayed, though. You can still attend church services here in the Twin Cities, conducted in Swedish and Norwegian, if you like. I went to the Norwegian Lutheran service once with my Mother-in-law.

MineralMan

(146,288 posts)
61. They all came to Minnesnowta years ago.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:00 PM
Sep 2015

Yah, you betcha.

Disclaimer: I am Norwegian by marriage, so I know these things.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
69. Right.
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:48 PM
Sep 2015

Having the benefit of the internet permits many to look into various locations prior to moving. It surprises me that anyone would immigrate here given the hostility of the right wing toward immigrants.

KitSileya

(4,035 posts)
67. These days, I think only upper middle class Scandinavians would try to emigrate to the US
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 01:28 PM
Sep 2015

And only those who have good, safe jobs, like upper management, visiting Professor-type white-collar jobs, or who try for the American dream in entertainment or other flashy jobs.

I currently live in Norway, but I have family in the US, and I have lived there before. However, these days I know that moving back isn't an option unless I win the lottery. Not only would it hurt me economically (I am a high school teacher,) but I would not last long in the American work environment. I have gotten too used to actually having rights as a worker. I wouldn't accept the expectations, not having a say in my job duties, no having the worker's safety net of not fearing being fired if I speak up.

Even if I got a job that isn't teaching, I would never accept so little vacation, no maternity leave, the hours and hours of unpaid overtime most white-collar workers do in the US. I spend every summer there, and I see how exploited my friends are, how little spare time they have, how uncertain their lives are. That's not for me.

Hortensis

(58,785 posts)
76. Our DIL is a Danish citizen raised in America, KitSileya, but she's never
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 05:36 PM
Sep 2015

considered giving up the protections of her Danish citizenship, for herself and her children, for love of both heritages and because of all the differences you describe, and more, when she visits relatives in Denmark.

Fortunately, now for the first time she can get dual citizenship, which she is doing, but I've recommended she carefully do everything required to retain her citizenship rights under Danish law now that she is accepting U.S. citizenship and lives here. What the laws of nations can confer, they can also take away.

Because of the the destabilizing effects of climate change alone, in future many more mass population migrations will be occurring. Today's are just the beginning, and I believe protective reactions in many places are inevitable. I even imagine I am hearing the sound of doors slamming in the future... She doesn't believe it could happen, but unlikely as it is, some of those migrations could conceivably be from hard-hit regions of the U.S. in decades to come if heat, drought and fresh water scarity continued to increase and economic decline set in.

DFW

(54,370 posts)
75. If you refer to Scandinavia, you're thinking of Social Democracy. Not the same thing as "PDS"
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 05:20 PM
Sep 2015

In Sweden, for example, they are "Socialdemokraterna (social democrats)," of Socialdemokratiska Partiet " (the Social Democratic Party). Die Sozialdemokraten in Germany (Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands, or SPD)

There WAS a Party of Democratic Socialism until recently. "Democratic Socialism" to us in Europe means these guys:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Party_of_Democratic_Socialism_%28Germany%29

These are the people who got their jollies putting people in mental institutions for being dissidents, forcing dissidents out of jobs and then jailing them for the crime of "parasitism (i.e unemployment)," and shooting them down at the Berlin Wall if they tried to escape. Not the same to those of us who have lived through both.

DFW

(54,370 posts)
91. When swine get permission to launch an airline
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 07:38 AM
Sep 2015

No one gets anything they don't want to get. But I laud your optimism.

BooScout

(10,406 posts)
99. I've tried to explain the differences in European political parties....
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:37 AM
Sep 2015

...and US political parties here at DU before. I got a called a GOP troll and got a hide for saying that in many ways the Tory party in the UK was further left than the Democratic party in the US. I have given up trying to explain the differences. Folks that have never set foot outside the US, much less lived abroad are going to insist they are well informed....when they aren't.

DFW

(54,370 posts)
101. I've seen that.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 10:38 AM
Sep 2015

I see people in the USA who live inside their "smart" phones. A lot of uninformed people on their smart phones.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
103. Not quite.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 11:01 AM
Sep 2015

I'm using the local (think American) version of the term. Much as there is considerable difference between a European Liberal and a US Liberal, there are differences between the Democratic Socialism of Germany and that of the US.
http://www.dsausa.org/what_is_democratic_socialism

DFW

(54,370 posts)
106. I don't think just "American." I think globally. I have to.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 11:58 AM
Sep 2015

I live in Germany, am married to a German and we speak German at home. You cal use whatever label floats your boat here. After all, there won't be many Germans voting in the Democratic primaries, why should you care?

However, in Germany, no one calling himself a "Democratic Socialist" will ever be associated with anything other than the Wall murderers without a LOT of "'splainin' to do." It just leaves a bad taste in our mouths. Not anyone's fault. It just does. You have to have lived here to know.

Bubzer

(4,211 posts)
107. I can certainly respect that. Each culture applies the labels it deems appropriate.
Mon Sep 14, 2015, 12:48 PM
Sep 2015

In the US, there's a big push to malign Bernie Sanders with the term Democratic Socialist... though when Bernie refers to Democratic Socialism, he points to Scandinavian countries as prime examples of his ideology. That, to a very large degree, is where most of this contention lies. Its a battle of defining words... partly because there's a group of individuals who will use the concrete meaning of a word as a wedge, rather than recognizing and acknowledging the intent behind it.

Those who dislike Bernie, want to be able to use Democratic Socialist as a slur... and are apt to ignore the local variant of the word. His supporters, including myself, are not inclined to sit back and let it happen... and so the war of words continues.

Marrah_G

(28,581 posts)
123. We won't see that type of socialism until the country splits into smaller countries
Tue Sep 15, 2015, 08:33 PM
Sep 2015

I could see it working well in the north east and the north west.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If Democratic Socialism i...