General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIn New Documentary, KKK says Auschwitz a 'Summer Camp' for Jews
By Tova Dvorin
9/29/2015, 12:42 PM
... "At these death camps they gave the so-called people that were being killed cigarettes, there was coffee, there was a movie theater, there was a library, and even a swimming pool in Auschwitz," he adds.
"If you're going to sit there and kill all these people then how come all these things would be in there, it's more like a summer camp" ...
The documentary explores .. a set of Klansmen in rural Alabama .. convinced they are on the front lines of an upcoming race war ...
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/201187#.Vgp0jLRVhHw
The lyin racist shizzheads!
leftynyc
(26,060 posts)and more and more schools don't teach history, more and more are going to believe this. The klan knows the magnitude of nazi crimes is so horrific, people are going to want NOT to believe it.
Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)It is literally history repeating itself. When the reports about the death camps were coming out, people didn't believe it, even the Jews in the States didn't believe it; the idea was too horrific. Education about the Holocaust is sadly lacking, even here it was described as "Jewish history", and people didn't even recognize
as offensive.
Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)It is one of the more uplifting ones I have seen.
I also wrote my own piece about Babi Yar.
leftynyc
(26,060 posts)but promise I will soon. Hope all is well with you.
Initech
(100,075 posts)As well as lots of documentaries about World War 2 and the holocaust. I never fully understood why people worked so hard to keep the full extent of Nazi crimes hidden from us, until I got older and started reading about US business involvement in the development of Nazi Germany, particularly the contributions of one Prescott Bush. No fucking wonder.
Zorra
(27,670 posts)We must teach our children well, so that they may never be the next victims of fascist hate.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)In 1940 the SS was still killing Jews and Poles by taking them out into the woods and shooting them (more died that way than were gassed, ultimately).
It's kind of odd that Auschwitz wound up as the symbol of the Final Solution, because in many ways it was unique. Part of it remained a labor camp until the Soviets "liberated" it, whereas Treblinka, Belzec, etc. were 100% extermination from their outset.
But, anyways, there probably was coffee, cigarettes, and swimming pools at some point in Auschwitz. It's always important to figure out what kernel of fact bullshit was built on...
gollygee
(22,336 posts)Perhaps thats because its all false. Long-time Auschwitz commandant Rudolf Hoess, in the autobiography he wrote shortly before his execution, described how Heinrich Himmler in 1941 himself gave me the order to prepare installations at Auschwitz where mass exterminations could take place, and then detailed the entire horrifying process, including gassings he personally witnessed. Filip Muller, a prisoner who worked for three years in the crematoria but survived, described unbelievably brutal exterminations. And so did thousands of others.
But Carolyn Yeager did stroll through Auschwitz and Birkenau seven decades later, and shes pretty sure the guides didnt give her the real lowdown. One Auschwitz gas chamber was really a morgue, later turned into an air raid shelter. Over at Birkenau, there was a beautiful, modern hygiene building where arriving prisoners had their hair shorn, but that also occasionally doubled as a ballroom. SS guards there regularly socialized with prisoners, with a number of love affairs resulting in postwar marriages. Guards and inmates enjoyed friendly competition on Saturday afternoons and Sundays, with enthusiastic cheering sections.
Actually, Yeager, a relatively new face in denialist circles, seems to have had something of an attitude long before she brought her analytical abilities to Auschwitz. On her website, she describes growing up in a white home town in the Midwest, the daughter of a German-American father who complained about the dishonest Jews who cheated him and the Negroes who stole from him.
She says she was a liberal for a time, sympathetic to the plight of the coloreds, but in the late 1990s began to read conspiracist literature and learned the truth about the takeover of the American monetary system by mainly Jewish and foreign bankers. She let go her fear of being called an anti-Semite. Finally, she writes, I was drawn to National Socialism as a viable alternative, learning about its true nature as opposed to the lies I had been taught.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)In the interim it housed Polish political prisoners, who stayed there doing forced labor throughout the war.
gollygee
(22,336 posts)There was a resevoir for water, and I've heard that later in the war there were diving boards put on for SS officers, but it was at no time a wonderful place. Polish political prisoners were not treated well either.
Edit: I've read that SS guards had a theater they could go to as well. Maybe this woman is thinking of what was available for the SS guards.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)German American supporters of the Nazis. I personally sat in a Bible study group where one such ass would continually say a well known phrase in German that made my father so angry it was not even funny. It was open support in a German American neighborhood where the majority of us had sons, brothers and fathers in the US Army fighting the Nazis.
In the 70s there was a religious news paper written by a denier. I do not remember the name of it but I think it was located in Nebraska.
GoneFishin
(5,217 posts)I agree that it is important to understand where and how the tiny bit of truth is woven into the story in order to completely unravel their mountain of bullshit.
struggle4progress
(118,282 posts)because they were not all the same; and because the German regime lied about nearly everything. The total number of camps was around 20000. Dachau, the first, was established in 1933 to imprison political opponents. There were also POW camps, slave labor camps, and mass killing camps. Use of innocuous-sounding euphemisms (such as "resettlement in the east" for "send to killing center" was official policy. What is often called Auschwitz was actually a complex of several large camps, that ultimately included POWs, slave laborers, and persons destined for industrial murder. From the earliest days, much of that was built by prisoner labor, but under sadistic conditions, including arbitrary brutality -- including beatings, shootings, and hangings -- that very few prisoners survived
COLGATE4
(14,732 posts)Birkenau (2 kms away from the main Auschwitz facilities) was a pure extermination camp. After being 'selected' on the train ramp, most of the new 'arrivals' were hustled directly off to Birkenau for their 'shower'. Any amenities at Auschwitz were undoubtedly there for the guards, not the prisoners (and more especially, not the Jews). Just more vile holocaust revisionism.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)You are correct there were other camps which were solely death factories. What many don't know about Auschwitz is there were actually two camps; the main one was a labor camp, and the expansion, often called Auschwitz-Birkenau or Auschwitz II., which was the extermination camp located about 2 miles north of the main camp. Auschwitz I did have many of the amenities listed (I have never heard about a swimming pool), but they were for the SS and also included a brothel. There is also a famous Red Cross video from that time showing the concentration camps as a "summer camp" which was used for propaganda.
I don't know that your correct in your assertion more people were killed by the SS in the forests (actually most was done in the open after pits were dug) than in the death/labor camps. While that is certainly how and when the Holocaust started, the incredible number of those liquidated in the camps were likely move voluminous than the initial killings and destruction of towns and shtetls .
Recursion
(56,582 posts)Depressing as hell book, but very informative. His thesis is that the Nazis had to create "stateless spaces" for the extermination to happen in. So, in Poland the mass shootings largely stopped with the creation of the General Government but continued throughout the war on occupied Soviet land, and even late in the war a Dutch or French passport would often mean the difference between concentration and extermination; Anne Frank died of thyphoid not Zyklon.
What was really interesting was how he connected Kristalnacht to the Anschluss. It was largely a copy of the "spontaneous" pogrom in Austria but caused a significant backlash in German popular opinion (which opened the door for the Long Knives).
But, anyways, Snyder estimated it as 4 million shot by the Einsatzgruppen or by collaborators, which exceeds the carbon monixide and Zyklon death tolls.
Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)I have searched and searched and I can't anything that confirms your (his) numbers, nor anything which definitively disproves it. I don't doubt that the Einsatzgruppen totals surpass the CO2 and Zyklon deaths, but not the number of deaths in the camps, including those starved to death and shot.
Anyway, your post reminded me of something I was going to do which was post about Babbi Yar on the anniversary of that event; so I did: The Little Known Holocaust, Before the Death Camps: Babi Yar. I was watching a documentary about the pre-death camp killings and that stuck out to me in a big way. Our conversation reminded me of it...so thank you!
Recursion
(56,582 posts)And actually I think the people shot in the camps were included in his number; his point was that bullets killed more Jews, Poles, and Gypsies than gas did.
I saw your post and thought immediately of the book; Babi Yar features heavily in it. It and the liquidation of Vilnius are kind of his key narratives. Though I have to say I knew almost nothing about Vilnius going in. The pattern there was astounding: it was the largest Jewish center in the Baltic and so became a huge center for refugees. Many people fled from Poland there, but in general the further you were from state institutions the less safe you were, so Germany itself was paradoxically safer for Jews than occupied Poland, which was safer than the Baltics or occupied Russia.
ProfessorGAC
(65,042 posts)Even though i concur with someone upthread who said survivors are dying off and history is ill taught, there are films of what those places did.
There's no unlearning something that is on film, in multiple locations in multiple countries.
Ilsa
(61,695 posts)said Obama's birth certificate and even the microfilm birth announcement in the newspaper was a plant. At that point, I realized the level of her paranoia and suspicion and I knew that this and other crap would get in the way of our friendship soon.
ProfessorGAC
(65,042 posts)lonestarnot
(77,097 posts)struggle4progress
(118,282 posts)lonestarnot
(77,097 posts)KamaAina
(78,249 posts)jwirr
(39,215 posts)the people running the camp just like we have these in many of our military camps throughout the world today.
It is also possible that things like cigarettes and coffee were in Red Cross packages during the few times that they were allowed to "inspect" the camps to convince the world that nothing bad was going on. I think they were handed out while the RC workers were watching but you wonder just how long they got to keep them after the RC workers left.
Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)I am glad to see someone else touched on the Red Cross because they were instrumental in the propaganda used by the Nazis in regards to the detention camps. On the very few times they visited a camp, they were given a 'dog and pony' show and went back saying "things ain't so bad" to the powers that be.
jwirr
(39,215 posts)been taken in by the propaganda regarding Jewish people and money. It was around long before the Nazis. And most of our ancestors came from the place it all started - Europe.
It would not be beyond the possibility that those RC "inspectors" shared some of this belief. But I am sure that the Nazis did everything they could to cover up what was really happening.
Even today we are very gullible when it comes to man's inhumanity to man.
tabasco
(22,974 posts)NaturalHigh
(12,778 posts)joeybee12
(56,177 posts)from right after the War where they can find anyone denying these camps existed...they can't produce that...because the evidence was overwhelming...