General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsBernie Sanders Wins Over Crowd Of Rural Trump Supporters By Exposing The Truth About Trumpcare
[font size="4"]The Vermont senator went into tough terrain, but he was able to show West Virginia Trump supporters how the GOP is conning them.[/font]
Bernie Sanders went into hostile territory for progressives and convinced the presidents supporters in West Virginia that Donald Trumps campaign was a massive con job and his policies would hurt the voters he promised to help the most.
This is particularly true in McDowell County, West Virginia, one of the poorest counties in the country that overwhelmingly supported Trump in last falls presidential election. Despite their support for Trump, those living in the deep red county will likely be hurt the most by what Republicans are trying to do, especially with health care.
During the town hall event with MSNBCs Chris Hayes, Sanders laid out how Trumpcare will hurt those who need coverage the most, like coal miners in West Virginia, and mainly benefit the wealthy.
Not only did Sanders debunk the myth that Trump and Republicans constantly feed to their base of supporters that there isnt enough room in the budget to help those who need it most, but he also convinced one coal miner a man who voted for Trump that its time to make health care in the United States a universal right.
Sanders asked the Trump voter, What do you think, do you think we should join other countries and guarantee health care as a right of all?
Yeah, I think every American citizen should have health care, the Trump voter responded to applause.
Republicans have successfully fooled working- and middle-class voters especially those in white, rural areas into thinking their policies will help them the most when in reality, voters in places like McDowell County, West Virginia stand to lose the most under the new president.
Democrats need to continue hammering the point, as Sanders did, that while Republicans talk a good game about being the party of blue-collar workers, its Democratic policies that will and historically have helped them the most.
http://www.politicususa.com/2017/03/13/bernie-sanders-storms-deep-red-west-virginia-convinces-trump-voters-conned.html
Rhiannon12866
(205,320 posts)Doodley
(9,088 posts)elleng
(130,895 posts)and I hope they will LEARN from him.
democrank
(11,094 posts)and am more convinced than ever that we must reach out to rural America. Most responded to Bernie in a very positive way.
Locrian
(4,522 posts)He makes it look easy.
karynnj
(59,503 posts)To Congress. He has had lots of practice both talking and listening.
seaglass
(8,171 posts)democrank
(11,094 posts)There were upwards of 15,000 people there.
seaglass
(8,171 posts)karynnj
(59,503 posts)Last edited Tue Mar 14, 2017, 01:43 PM - Edit history (2)
He also did many rallies around the country with Sue Minter, TJ Donovan, and David Zuckerman in October 2016. He did have both a victory rally when he won 86% of the vote in Burlington and he had his announcement in May 2015. Of course, for that year and a half when he was running for President, he did not spend the normal amount of time in Vermont.
seaglass
(8,171 posts)Town Halls which I thought was the subject of this conversation. Not rallies.
http://www.sevendaysvt.com/vermont/outta-town-vermonts-congressional-delegation-spends-recess-far-from-home/Content?oid=4184580
But Sanders himself hasn't held a live, in-person town hall in Vermont since 2014, according to state director Phil Fiermonte.
karynnj
(59,503 posts)I think it comes down to town hall vs rally -- and I would not argue with Fiermonte on what that means.
seaglass
(8,171 posts)lillypaddle
(9,580 posts)and it was excellent. This is what Dems need to be doing. Kudos, Bernie and Chris Hayes.
OregonBlue
(7,754 posts)listen and really care about these people's lives. Loved the lady who said how great it was that a Senator from Vermont would come all this way to hear their problems but McConnell never does.
lillypaddle
(9,580 posts)stuffmatters
(2,574 posts)Response to Donkees (Original post)
Post removed
Locrian
(4,522 posts)Lucky Luciano
(11,254 posts)sharedvalues
(6,916 posts)"Major Bernie Sanders backers suspect Russians flooded their social sites with anti-Hillary memes"
Lucky Luciano
(11,254 posts)seaglass
(8,171 posts)and it doesn't lead to post removal.
lillypaddle
(9,580 posts)just keeps the fights going. I voted for Hillary. I said something nice about Bernie, too - he deserved it. Please just stop.
MaeScott
(878 posts)Loud, long, rinse,repeat.
MBS
(9,688 posts)mwooldri
(10,303 posts)Sorry but Bernie Sanders is showing the way it should be done. As far as I'm concerned he's the anti-Trump all the way, and a good model for actual Democrats to follow. Bernie is a Democrat in all but name. I didn't watch this event, but I remember other people quoting things like that it is odd that it takes someone from the Northeast to do stuff about coal country's healthcare... Stuff that Senator Turtle should be doing... but isn't.
This is how we fight Trump. We espouse facts. We expose Trump for the fraud that he is, as well as the other Republicans. We reconnect with rural voters. The coal jobs are not coming back, and efforts have to be made to replace those jobs. It will take years. But we can not sit on our backsides and do nothing, otherwise people will become radicalized by the extreme right and extreme left.... if not already. I don't know what the solution is. Go like Finland and pour education into the job lost area, hoping for a Nokia? Improve the social safety net so that people are lifted out of poverty that way (as the rich won't be philanthropic enough to do it themselves)? Punish bad megacorps by force relocating them to areas of deprivation?
It's about jobs and personal security. It's not about immigration. It's not about walls. I could get religious about it too... It's feed the hungry, clothe the naked, give homeless shelter, heal the sick... in short love thy neighbour... A Jewish refugee had this message 2000 years ago. He got physically crucified for this message. Didn't invalidate the message.
Maru Kitteh
(28,340 posts)I wish he would join the party - I think it would send an amazing, unifying, important message right now, ahead of the 2018 mid-terms.
I would like to see him join the Democratic Party, because it would be best for the party, as opposed to doing what is best for Bernie Sanders.
bekkilyn
(454 posts)The people in Vermont voted for him as an Independent, so it was only fair to them to go back to being an Independent Senator once he had no immediate reason to remain a Democrat. Think of it this way...would it be fair if you voted for a Democratic Senator and then in the middle of their term, they switched over to Republican? Bernie had to run as a Democrat for the presidential election since he didn't want to divide the Democratic vote, but once that reason was gone, he really needed to go back to being Independent for the people of Vermont.
Maybe once his term is up, he'll run as a Democrat depending on how things go within the Democratic party by then, so we'll just have to wait and see.
truebluegreen
(9,033 posts)He is not a Democrat. He's just a democrat.
LanternWaste
(37,748 posts)It's important you both revel in and advertise what "according to some here at DU" allegedly say.
I can certainly see the critical relevance it imports to any conversation, and it lends a much needed sense of oppression to the nascent movement.
It can be almost impossible to place him on a pedestal unless concurrently implying both fault and blame to a demographic.
Without the "According to some", we have nothing from which to construct an irrelevant, though highly creative straw-man, while yet maintaining the pretense we're simply attempting to fight Trump rather than ourselves.
Most creative, indeed.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Zing Zing Zingbah
(6,496 posts)to them, spend some time with them, and then really explain to them how their concerns can be addressed. I think they perceived Trump as more willing to listen to them and more willing to spend the time with them, but they were duped because Trump was just pretending to care about them. I think it shows that more grassroots campaigns in rural areas are needed for dems to get their message out. I think the dems can focus less on urban areas because they've pretty much got those areas locked up.
bullwinkle428
(20,629 posts)laying out the FUCKING BLUEPRINT!! Just FOLLOW IT!!"
pablo_marmol
(2,375 posts)Did you notice the guy in the foreground who appeared to be launching an objection? Would have liked to heard it, whether it was BS or not.
Donkees
(31,396 posts)pablo_marmol
(2,375 posts)It was impossible to tell who was trying to break in from the truncated version. I'll watch the entire video when I have time.
SharonAnn
(13,772 posts)Blue_Tires
(55,445 posts)But if it takes someone like Sanders to finally make them open their ears, then fine...
seaglass
(8,171 posts)voters I would count on in the future, they appear easily fooled.
Blue_Tires
(55,445 posts)that they voted for Trump out of fear/hate/racism instead of some nebulous "economic concerns", because no fucking coal jobs are coming back to WV no matter what Trump says and they damn well knew that...
bdamomma
(63,848 posts)not know. God, don't these people realize they will be getting screwed.
Zing Zing Zingbah
(6,496 posts)If Bernie and the dems could do more outreach to these Trump voters... really take the time with them to help them understand... I think it would make a huge difference.
panader0
(25,816 posts)Keep going to deep red counties and doing this.
Hoyt
(54,770 posts)betsuni
(25,492 posts)I used to buy fancy expensive face creams even though I knew the main ingredient was water and additives, but the ads of beautiful air-brushed women, the hope in that jar ... so seductive. I couldn't resist. Most of the time the jar sat on the bathroom shelf unused. I guess also like New Guinea cargo cults.
gratuitous
(82,849 posts)But if Democratic elected officials and former officeholders keep going back to West Virginia (and Kentucky and Kansas and Texas and Indiana and Michigan and Wisconsin and . . . you get the idea), talking up Democratic proposals and ideas, it's possible that some of them will mark their ballots differently in 2018 and 2020. Bill it as a town hall in the district of a Republican congressman who's too gutless to host a town hall right now.
Here's some of the pluses: It lets a Democrat interact directly with voters. In talking with the local media, it generates coverage and local excitement. For the lonely Democrats in the area, trying to persevere in the face of the unrelenting shitstorm from Republicans and Fox and hate radio, it can be a real tonic, generating even more local excitement.
These people voted for Republicans by a 3-1 margin and scraped together enough electoral wins to put Trump in the White House. Maybe if we reduce their advantage to 2-1 or 3-2, some of those states that went Republican in 2016 will go Democratic in 2020.
Blue_true
(31,261 posts)to those voters help local, State and Congressional Democratic candidates because the locals have a platform to build on.
fleur-de-lisa
(14,624 posts)Demsrule86
(68,556 posts)and they will vote GOP...they never change their votes and vote for their best interests...I hope you all are correct, but I truly doubt it.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)sammythecat
(3,568 posts)of the trending and greatest threads that looked interesting and then there was this one at the bottom. I usually stay away from any threads having to do with Bernie Sanders because they always turn out the same way and I don't like to aggravate myself. I shouldn't have, but I clicked on this one too thinking to myself, "I wonder how long it'll take 'til someone shits on this". I Didn't read the story, didn't read the replies, just scrolled down looking for the familiar and just about came to the end, thinking "holy shit!, they actually let it go for once". Ah, but no, not this time. There you were. Almost at the bottom, but, ever reliable, you showed up. Better late than never, as they say. The snark was mild, but pure snark nonetheless.
Just can't help yourself, can you?
If you choose to respond, you can have the last word. I'm done.
Hassin Bin Sober
(26,326 posts)I always think of this clip:
https://m.
eyeofnewt
(146 posts)Regardless of who they voted for, these are men and women of coal country-tough and strong. They are men and women descended from the Battle of Blair Mountain heroes and strong labor organizers in Matewan. They know the history of fighting and dying for worker's rights and benefits. They lived the boom era of coal and unfortunately the downfall of that prosperous era. I know not everyone perceives them as unreachable (they voted for Trump!), but many do. Having know many of them, I believe that most will come around. Well, I at least hope so.
Wounded Bear
(58,648 posts)I kept screaming over and over in my mind:
Hey, folks! This isn't just about Trump. This is about Republicans! Trump didn't dream up the Deplorable Care Act, House Republicans did. You've been voting for them for decades and what have they done for you? Trump actually said some "decent" things about health care on the campaign. It's the Republicans in the House that dreamed up this crap based on their love of rich folks and tax cuts. Trump will rubber stamp anything they present, but right now the only people really fighting for your healthcare are Democrats.
dae
(3,396 posts)Caliman73
(11,736 posts)It looks like Sanders did well in talking to and listening to this group of voters. What the man said in the second clip however, still gives me pause.
He said, "Yeah, I think every American CITIZEN should have health care". This is where the dividing line is still strong and where the Republicans and Trump are still effective.
The man distinguished between "citizen" and other. While I have no theoretical problem with that (citizens have rights as they should by citizenship), I think that he said that purposefully to maintain that "those other people" (meaning immigrants who are not citizens) should not have access to health care and implying that they are the reason why we all don't.
Perhaps I am reading too much into the statement, but I think that this is what Republicans have been pushing all along to derail any collective assistance for all Americans. The idea that someone "undeserving" is going to get what you deserve to get, so we can't give it to everyone right now, until we get all of the "undeserving" people out of here. Republicans have made the following groups of people into "undeserving" people: Women, Black people, Gay and Lesbian people, Transgender people, Latinos, immigrants (legal or not - they don't distinguish), and Muslims. The people in the town hall see themselves as hard working Americans who have been left behind, but they do not see the other groups, who work just as hard, as being left behind. They see those people as parasites who take from the country and give nothing in return. That makes them easy to rile up against proposals like universal health care.
bettyellen
(47,209 posts)politics" It's not so hard to get someone on your side of one issue like healthcare, but the minute you get super liberal on them they go back to hating us. sanders is in a tough position because His goal is so far off and he was not so supportive of the ACA.
GulfCoast66
(11,949 posts)If we as a party reject the idea that some benefits are reserved only for legal citizens or we will never win another election.
Caliman73
(11,736 posts)One, you did not explain how I was reading "way more" into this statement. Two, you seem to be suggesting that healthcare should only be provided to citizens as well. What about legal residents? What about people here on temporary Visas who get sick? What about anyone who gets sick? Are you suggesting that we reject those people at the emergency room.
If I am travelling in Britain, Canada, France, Denmark, or other industrialized countries and I get sick, I get treated. I also do not get stuck with a catastrophic medical bill because they have universal or some form of collective coverage. What would your solution be to dealing with healthcare for people who are working, paying taxes, and adding to the economy even though they are not here with the proper documentation?
Lunabell
(6,080 posts)Our party should listen to what he has to say, too.
RadiationTherapy
(5,818 posts)as much as we fumbled it away and lost it.
truebluegreen
(9,033 posts)trotsky
(49,533 posts)But we ran our ultimate "establishment" candidate. Was she qualified for the job? Absolutely. But last year, the 'outsider" theme resonated with a lot of apolitical voters. Most of us know Trump was no "outsider" either but he fooled enough people to win.
Kimchijeon
(1,606 posts)ailsagirl
(22,896 posts)kentuck
(111,092 posts)JudyM
(29,236 posts)potential to start an undercurrent of murmurings in their social circles -- favoring Dems. Hopefully feeding a contrarian uprising.
Talking with people instead of at them, listening to what they're saying. NPR has been doing some interesting journalism about 45's voters current thinking, too. They seem movable... let's hope, anyway.
Donkees
(31,396 posts)about poverty affecting lifespan. Some of his staff traveled there, and a social worker from McDowell County was invited to take part in the hearing.
JudyM
(29,236 posts)And a mensch.
WinkyDink
(51,311 posts)Curmudgeoness
(18,219 posts)by all of the Democratic politicians and leaders. There is no other way to save this country. Many people just don't know all the facts, and Bernie is willing to educate them. Shouldn't all of our leaders?
Lordquinton
(7,886 posts)And encouraging us all to reach for it.
Posting Anonymously
(32 posts)Stuff like that can spread like wildfire. Game Over, Trump. Please leave town (permanently) on the first train out. And, take the rest of the "republican" filth with you on your way out (to Russia). Don't forget to turn the lights out!
LiberalLovinLug
(14,173 posts)He is a Democrat on steroids!
When you have Blue Dog DINOs humping Trump and what Bernie is doing every day...I wish the letter D puritans in here would just lay off of him! But even more than that, they should be applauding him.
With Bernie voters it was not ever about Bernie even, despite some in here trying to paint it as some kind of cult of personality. . It is that he spoke truth to power, that he proved you could talk about single payer health care, about the inequalities between the 1% and the 99%, a $15 per hour min. wage, etc...You just have to have a little integrity and belief in what you are saying, because people can tell.
He is fearless. Card carrying Dem members in Washington have a lot to catch up with.
BTW where IS Hillary? I gave her a break after the awful defeat, but its time to jump in. Same with Obama.
Lifelong Protester
(8,421 posts)I was to see Bernie again.
Barack_America
(28,876 posts)4bucksagallon
(975 posts)GallopingGhost
(2,404 posts)and historically have-helped them the most."
This is what has always amazed me about areas like WV. Staunchly, devotedly Republican- because they think what? That the party of tax cuts for the rich, big business, corporate billionaires- gives a damn about whether they have health care and can feed their families?
Yes, I have read books, articles, theories, explanations about why they vote Republican, but there is just no common sense to it. I understand about the economic depression, the mindset that goes back generations, ect, but again-common sense
The man who worried about Americans having health care and jobs was President Obama, Trumpsters. Not your golden toilet messiah.
Shooting oneself in the foot is alive and well, apparently.
mr_lebowski
(33,643 posts)Who have the money to determine, scientifically, the best way(s) to influence a certain type of human being into believing that they 'deserve their lot' and that the only 'rightful' way for them to achieve any degree of comfort and wealth ... is by toiling for/serving ... you guessed it ... THE RICH.
At a very primal level it's simply playing into our inherent tendencies to establish 'hierarchies' and 'alphas', with a huge component of 'tribalism'. Basically Conservatives 'think' using the reptilian part of their brains foremost. With them, it's about fear ... esp. fear of 'the unknown' and especially of 'the other', i.e. that which is 'not what I think of as mine or being of me'.
Every living being has an inherent feeling of mistrust of 'other' bubbling under the surface. But the Cons represent a huge wellspring of easily manipulated political support, due to their reptilian thinking patterns ... They can SO easily be brought to focus solely on "I, Me, Mine".
But this is the biggest difference between 'us' and 'them'. We do not inherently think in 'possessive' terms when it comes to 'life on the planet'. We think in terms of being part of the the tapestry of ALL LIFE. And I firmly believe this 'difference' ... has a strong biological component to it.
Understand the reason I mention reptiles ... it's because they are about the most 'advanced' animals ... that have no inherent 'social structure'. They don't co-operate. There's no 'community' with reptiles. Even Birds, Ants, Bees and heck even the ancient FISH (ffs) have evolved to exhibit 'social structures', even if they engage in 'community' for no other reason than 'survival instinct'.
Liberal types, OTOH, are the humans who've fully evolved past the reptilian stage of humanities ancient genes, to fully EMBRACE the notion of COMMUNITY. To understand we're a SPECIES, we're all FAMILY ... and to understand that what has happened here on this planet, for things to work out 'just right' over the course of 4.5 billion years ... is nothing short of incredible.
I'd say it's a 'miracle', but that's really not accurate. It's really just simple 'math' ...
With as many 'suns' in the Universe as their are grains of sand on all the beaches of the world, there's GOING TO BE ... life ... every so often.
And every so often, it'll reach a stage of true 'intelligence' ... it'll grow to the point of being able to build houses, cars, roads, bridges, solar panels, wind farms, antibiotics, rockets, nuclear power, etc ... but we Liberals understand that the ODDS of what's happening here ... is so mathematically staggeringly low ... And this informs us to understand that what we 'have here' is so incredibly PRECIOUS ... both our 'life' (plant, animal AND human), and our EARTH ... which is the only thing SUSTAINING ALL THIS LIFE. Yet, without a functioning ecosystem, producing oxygen ... which in turn depends on the health of the Earth itself ... this planet would just be another cold, dead rock, floating alone in the vacuum of space.
Most of us also grasp that, at this 'moment' it's really very likely that the nearest other planet with 'life' like ours ... is so FAR AWAY that you'd have to travel for as long as it's been since we had dinosaurs here at Light Speed ... to get to them. At which point they'd be 250,000,000 years EXTINCT.
These people, these REPTILES among us ... these who worship COMPETITION, and SHUN COOPERATION instinctively, as if they were just a bunch of writhing fucking SNAKES ... are going to be the DEATH of humanity, and of millions of species on this planet, and it's likely not going to be too long before it happens.
And they'll do so whilst all along believing their 'ideology' of 'I, Me, Mine' is just oh, so noble and 'correct'. To some extent because they're 'born with it', but also because they've been TAUGHT that it's 'right' by people who'd manipulate them and use them. And because ... they're not the brightest.
And that feedback loop, in a nutshell ... is what has likely caused the eventual death of ALL advanced life in the history of this universe, which in it's great expanse I believe has happened many millions of times ... the only way you get to the level we humans are at ... is by natural selection, by processes like what has happened here on earth. And I don't believe the 'selfish/greed' gene has likely ever been eradicated before it caused massive extinction in the end.
Yes, "competition" ... Cons, it was SO valuable in early 'development' of life ... essential, even (though many of you don't even believe there WAS 'early stages of life', lol) but in the long run, it also turns out to be ... self-limiting. And that's why I highly doubt any intelligent lifeform in this universe has ever met another intelligent lifeform from another planet, unless perhaps life happened >1X in a single solar-system.
The CONS of every planet in history, have caused the eventual death of every intelligent 'life-form' ... on that planet. Because we have to EVOLVE towards COOPERATION, towards COMMUNITY. IN fact, that is WHAT YOUR OWN FRIGGIN JESUS ... was trying to tell you. The great irony of this fact is that it was ... indeed ... a message from 'God' (basically the intelligent Liberals, 2000 years ago) and you've both 'claimed it as yours' whilst simultaneously pissing all over it, and calling yourself 'pious'.
SAD!
Alice11111
(5,730 posts)Unrelated, sorry!
I've tried for days, and I'm feeling frustrated, and inept.
I tried to file an appeal, which was inadvertently deleted. I have spent hours posting elsewhere trying to contact someone so I could appeal, only to have my post bounced back. I fear I am going to be restricted from posting, when the alert was not appropriate. (I couldn't post at all for many hours, possibly a day, either. It all may be a coincidence.)
My post had the word "Bernie" in the title and I said some good stuff about him (I was actually always a Hillary supporter, not that it should matter.) Anyway, someone
ALERTED me as rehashing the primaries. I was not. I think someone read my title and made that assumption based on the fact that I stated Bernie's name, without reading my post.
If an admistrator could contact me or someone could point me in the right direction, I would appreciate it, as I have tried every avenue I can find.
pat_k
(9,313 posts)Alice11111
(5,730 posts)Blue_true
(31,261 posts)Unfortunately the alerting appears to be biased, IMO. Some people have posted posts that clearly imply that Democrats ran the wrong candidate in the General, and those posts are allowed to stay up (how are such posts not refighting the primary?). The refighting the primary rule seems to be being abused by people that are out to really grind axes. I don't know what can be done short of the site owners stepping in to get things righted.
Alice11111
(5,730 posts)people felt after I got popped for mentioning his name in the title, and pointing out his strengths. I didn't even discuss the primaries.
I've never alerted on anyone, yet.
Chitown Kev
(2,197 posts)this county in West Virginia actually did vote for Obama in 2008 (and, according to Wikipedia, in the elections before that too). It was one of seven counties (out of 55 total counties) in West Virginia that voted for Obama in 2008.
They voted heavily for Romney in 2012, though.
No county in WV voted for Obama in 2012.
Donkees
(31,396 posts)them back.
trotsky
(49,533 posts)Go Bernie!
Calculating
(2,955 posts)After having like 3 posts removed for 'refighting the primaries'. I'll just say that Bernie is an amazingly charismatic man and a true leader. People might disagree with his politics sometimes, but they always seem to still respect him as a person.