U.S. fears Syria preparing for massacre in Aleppo

[UnrepentantLiberal]

Source: Reuters

By Khaled Yacoub Oweis and Mariam Karouny July 27, 2012

AMMAN/BEIRUT - President Bashar al-Assad's forces renewed a ground and aerial bombardment of Aleppo on Friday, extending efforts to crush rebels in Syria's commercial capital in what the United States said it feared could become a massacre.

Insurgents targeted army roadblocks and security installations, with both sides avoiding close-quarters warfare in the city of 2.5 million people, Syria's biggest urban centre.

The U.S. State Department said credible reports of tank columns moving on Aleppo, along with air strikes by helicopters and fixed-wing aircraft, represented a serious escalation of Assad's efforts to crush a rebellion that began 16 months ago.

"This is the concern: that we will see a massacre in Aleppo, and that's what the regime appears to be lining up for," State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland said.

Read more: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/07/27/us-syria-crisis-idUSBRE8610SH20120727

[FailureToCommunicate]

1. We have friends in Aleppo. We pray for their safety.

[leveymg]

2. They're trying to spin this, like Benghazi, to sell a "no-fly zone" (NATO intervention)

9 March 2011: The head of the Libyan National Transitional Council, Mustafa Abdul Jalil, "pleaded for the international community to move quickly to impose a no-fly zone over Libya, declaring that any delay would result in more casualties".[39] Three days later, he stated that if pro-Gaddafi forces reached Benghazi, then they would kill "half a million" people. He stated, "If there is no no-fly zone imposed on Gaddafi's regime, and his ships are not checked, we will have a catastrophe in Libya."[40]

10 March 2011: France recognized the Libyan NTC as the legitimate government of Libya soon after Sarkozy met with them in Paris. This meeting was arranged by Bernard-Henri Lévy.[56]

11 March 2011: Cameron joined forces with Sarkozy after Sarkozy demanded immediate action from international community for a no-fly zone against air attacks by Gaddafi.[57]

12 March 2011: Nine out of the twenty-two Arab League members "called on the United Nations Security Council to impose a no-fly zone over Libya in a bid to protect civilians from air attack".[47][48][49][58] The Arab League's request was announced by Omani Foreign MinisterYusuf bin Alawi bin Abdullah, who stated that all member states present at the meeting agreed with the proposal.[47] On 12 March, thousands of Libyan women marched in the streets of the rebel-held town of Benghazi, calling for the imposition of a no-fly zone over Libya.[41]

14 March 2011: In Paris at the Élysée Palace, before the summit with the G8 Minister for Foreign Affairs, Sarkozy, who is also the president of the G8, along with French Foreign Minister Alain Juppé met with US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and impressed her upon to push for intervention in Libya.[59]

US Supports No-Fly Zone Against Libya.ogv
VOA News report on the United States joining Lebanon, France and United Kingdom to support the no-fly zone.

[UnrepentantLiberal]

3. Different country.

Different situation.

[leveymg]

4. Same tactic, though.

We've been treated to the big run-up to this battle for a reason. Screaming heard about "massacre" in Aleppo and No-fly zone south from Turkey border is probably it.

[UnrepentantLiberal]

5. Do you have any credible evidence that the U.S.

is doing or going to do the same thing they did in Libya? Oh, our paws are in there to some extent. They always are. But there are different things at play here. That's why we're letting Turkey and Saudi Arabia funnel guns in and mostly staying out of it.

[leveymg]

7. You mean "any credible evidence" that the neocon wing (wants) to do the same thing?

Have you been paying attention, at all?

Council on Foreign Relations is about as close to the Establishment party line as you'll get. Opinion's split, but the press is on. See, particularly, Zenko at the bottom. Here's some of what the Mandarins have to say to each other:

http://www.cfr.org/issue/humanitarian-intervention/ri68
Humanitarian Intervention


Op-Ed
Frustration Over Syria
Author: Julia E. Sweig
June 6, 2012
Folha de Sao Paulo

Julia E. Sweig dissects the international quandary over the humanitarian implications of violence in Syria.

See more in United States, Brazil, Syria, Humanitarian Intervention
Interview
A Syrian Turning Point for Russia?
Interview of: Mona Yacoubian
May 29, 2012

The weekend massacre near Houla that has galvanized international outrage may spark a stronger Russian stand against the Assad regime, says Syria expert Mona Yacoubian.

See more in Russian Fed., Syria, Humanitarian Intervention, Political Movements
First Take
Serious Steps to Stop Atrocities
Author: Paul B. Stares
April 24, 2012

President Obama's move to strengthen efforts to prevent genocide and mass killings deserves credit, but must be given time to work properly, says CFR's Paul Stares.

See more in Sudan, Syria, International Peace and Security, Conflict Prevention, Humanitarian Intervention
Must Read
Brookings: Saving Syria: Assessing Options for Regime Change
March 2012

Syria is trapped on a crumbling precipice, and however it might fall will entail significant risks for the United States and for the Syrian people, says this memo written by experts on Middle East at Brookings.

See more in Syria, Conflict Assessment, Humanitarian Intervention, U.S. Strategy and Politics
Must Read
HuffPo: Military Intervention in Syria Is a Bad Idea
April 2, 2012

Stephen Zunes, Professor of Politics and Chair of Mid-Eastern Studies at the University of San Francisco, says rather than military intervention, nonviolent resistance combined with targeted international sanctions will force the Syrian government to negotiate with the opposition for a transfer of power to a democratic majority.

See more in United States, Syria, Diplomacy, Humanitarian Intervention
Interview
The Great Syrian Divide
Joshua Landis interviewed by Bernard Gwertzman March 22, 2012

The government of the brittle, one-party state remains dug in against a determined but fractured opposition. Expert Joshua Landis discusses the fault lines in the Syria uprising.

See more in Syria, Humanitarian Intervention, Political Movements, Terrorism
Op-Ed
The Pentagon’s Cold Feet on Syria
Author: Max Boot
March 15, 2012
Washington Post

Max Boot says military action in Syria needs to be carefully thought through, but the Obama administration should not allow itself to be paralyzed by the Pentagon's reluctance to intervene in Syria.

See more in United States, Syria, Wars and Warfare, Humanitarian Intervention
Article
The Dangers of Warmongering on Syria, Iran
Author: Leslie H. Gelb
March 9, 2012
Daily Beast

Leslie H. Gelb says foreign policy experts should be made to answer questions about the consequences and risks of their recommendations to engage the United States in wars with Syria and Iran.

See more in Iran, Syria, Wars and Warfare, Humanitarian Intervention, U.S. Strategy and Politics
Op-Ed
The Perils of Piecemeal Intervention
Author: Jonathan Tepperman
March 8, 2012
New York Times

Jonathan Tepperman says a decision by the United States to intervene militarily in Syria must be made with hard facts and an honest decision about what standing up for U.S. interests and values will entail.

See more in United States, Syria, Wars and Warfare, Humanitarian Intervention
Op-Ed
America’s Duplicity with the Syrian Opposition
Author: Elliott Abrams
February 27, 2012
National Review

Elliott Abrams says that mixed messages from Washington ultimately leave the Syrian opposition to fend for themselves.

See more in Israel, Syria, Humanitarian Intervention, Political Movements, U.S. Strategy and Politics
Op-Ed
West Must Not Intervene Militarily in Syria
Author: Ed Husain
February 9, 2012
cnn.com

Ed Husain says military options in Syria would do much more harm than good.

See more in United States, Syria, Humanitarian Intervention, Political Movements
Op-Ed
We Intervene in Syria at Our Peril
Author: Ed Husain
February 1, 2012
The Atlantic

Ed Husain argues that Western military involvement in Syria would worsen violence, not end it, and could spread the conflict beyond Syria's borders.

See more in United States, Syria, Democracy and Human Rights, Humanitarian Intervention
Op-Ed
How to Help Syria Without Intervening Militarily
Author: Robert M. Danin
January 22, 2012
cnn.com

Robert M. Danin outlines eight steps that the United States and other members of the international community could adopt to help Syria, well short of military action.

See more in United States, Syria, Humanitarian Intervention
Article
Joint Task Force Odyssey Dawn: A Model for Joint Experience, Training, and Education
Authors: Gregory K. James, Larry Holcomb, and Colonel Chad T. Manske, USAF
January 2012
Joint Force Quarterly

Colonel Gregory K. James, USA; Colonel Larry Holcomb, USMC; and Colonel Chad T. Manske, USAF argue that the success of Operation ODYSSEY DAWN, despite its complexity, validates joint planning processes, joint education foundations, joint training opportunities, and joint exercises.

See more in Libya, Wars and Warfare, UN, International Peace and Security, Humanitarian Intervention
Op-Ed
It's Time to Think Seriously About Intervening in Syria
Author: Steven A. Cook
January 17, 2012
The Atlantic

Steven A. Cook says that if the world wants to see the end of Bashar al-Assad, it will likely require international intervention.

See more in United States, Syria, Humanitarian Intervention
Op-Ed
Intervention, Please: The 'No-Fly Zone' Requests You Don't Hear About
Author: Micah Zenko
January 10, 2012
The Atlantic

Micah Zenko says requests for humanitarian intervention by foreign governments and peoples happen all the time, and he examines why some requests are granted while others are ignored.

See more in Libya, Syria, UN, International Peace and Security, Humanitarian Intervention

Must Read

[UnrepentantLiberal]

9. You just proved MY point.

Some people are frustrated because the west isn't doing what it did in Libya.

[leveymg]

10. This is the typical Washington 2-step. While some drag a foot, the other drags the body

The usual pattern: DoD reluctance overcome by CIA covert operations with foreign paramilitaries (al Qaeda and other terrorists). The Pentagon goes along in the end. The net result is the usual death and mayhem. I grant, perhaps Bosnia, Kosovo and Iraq may be the closer precedents for Syrian regime change, as they all involved a considerable amount of covert activity and domestic deception before US military involvement - but, isn't that in many ways worse than the lead-up to Libya?

[The Straight Story]

6. Hopefully the people there are not armed and the government will have an easier time killing them

Cause lord knows the only people you can trust with weapons are those in power.

[UnrepentantLiberal]

8. Yeah, Syria's military is the same as the United States

military. Tell yourself that when you're running around in the woods with your guns.